Possum Holler Pizza

- 1874 Lisle Ave, Obetz, OH 43207

For those in the Ohio region, particularly near Columbus and the charming village of Obetz, Possum Holler Pizza is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a slice of local history and a testament to enduring quality. Located at 1874 Lisle Ave, this beloved pizza joint has been a community staple for years, with some customers even remembering its presence from half a century ago. If you're tired of the big chain pizza places and are craving a truly unique and satisfying pie, Possum Holler Pizza offers an experience that is deeply rooted in local tradition and flavor.

Possum Holler Pizza has built its reputation on a distinct style that sets it apart. Known for its generous toppings, a unique sweet sauce, and a remarkably crispy, cracker-like crust, their pizzas deliver a memorable taste that has kept generations coming back. Whether you're indulging in the "Owner's Favorite" with its abundance of Old World pepperoni and extra cheese, or exploring their other popular options, you can expect a pizza that’s rich in flavor and satisfyingly hearty. This attention to detail in their ingredients and preparation makes every bite a testament to their commitment to quality.

Beyond the delicious food, Possum Holler Pizza offers a welcoming and friendly atmosphere. Customers frequently commend the pleasant, attentive, and not overbearing service, creating a comfortable environment for dining. The clean interior further adds to the positive experience, making it a great place for a casual dinner or a quick pickup. It's a true "mom and pop pizza shop" that embodies community spirit, offering a taste of nostalgia for some and a delightful discovery for others.

Possum Holler Pizza is conveniently located at 1874 Lisle Ave, Obetz, OH 43207, USA. Situated in the heart of Obetz, a village just southeast of Columbus, this location makes it a readily accessible spot for both local residents and those willing to make a short trip from surrounding areas like Groveport or even the northeast side of Columbus.

Lisle Avenue itself is a local street, but its connection to main thoroughfares ensures straightforward access by car. The restaurant's presence within the Obetz community means it's a familiar landmark for many locals. While parking specifics aren't always detailed, typical neighborhood parking options are generally available to accommodate customers. The establishment has also undergone renovations and expansions, including plans for a new parking lot, further enhancing its accessibility for patrons. For those who prefer to avoid the larger city traffic, a visit to Obetz to experience Possum Holler Pizza is often described as "well worth the trip," emphasizing its ease of reach and the reward of its unique offerings.

• Dine-In Service: Possum Holler Pizza offers a comfortable and clean dine-in experience. The atmosphere is described as great, providing a pleasant setting for enjoying a meal, particularly during non-peak hours when it might be less crowded.

• Takeout Service: As a popular local pizza joint, takeout is a key service, allowing customers to call ahead and pick up their orders to enjoy at home. This is a favored option for many in the community.

• Delivery Service: Possum Holler Pizza partners with third-party delivery services like Uber Eats and Postmates, providing a convenient option for customers to have their food delivered directly to their door. Delivery fees may apply, but delivery by store staff is also available.

• Variety of Pizzas: The menu features a range of pizzas including specialty options like "Owner's Favorite" (Old World pepperoni with extra cheese), BBQ Chicken Pizza, The Meats, Hawaiian, Veggie, and the Possum Combo. Customers can also customize their own pizzas with various toppings.

• Submarine Sandwiches: Beyond pizza, Possum Holler is known for its delicious subs. The Italian sub, in particular, is highly recommended for its good flavor and slight spiciness.

• Sides and Salads: The menu also includes a selection of sides such as French fries, breadsticks, garlic bread, and Bosco Sticks, along with various salads like side salads, Chef salads, and antipasta salads.

• Beverages and Desserts: A selection of cold drinks are available, including various sodas. While not extensively detailed in reviews, the mention of "S'mores" suggests dessert options are also present.

• Distinctive "Sweet Sauce" and "Cracker" Crust: A signature feature of Possum Holler Pizza is its sweet pizza sauce, which is a particular highlight for those who enjoy this flavor profile. The crust is also unique, described as crispy like a cracker but not thin, providing a satisfying texture.

• Generous Toppings: Customers consistently praise the abundance of toppings on their pizzas. The "Owner's Favorite" with old world pepperoni and extra cheese is noted for having "plenty of pepperoni and a lot of cheese," sometimes so much that toppings slide off, indicating a generous hand.

• Excellent Italian Subs: Beyond pizza, the Italian sub receives high acclaim, described as "very good," "a little spicy," and overall a delicious choice for those looking for something different.

• Friendly and Attentive Service: The staff are frequently commended for being pleasant, friendly, and attentive without being intrusive. This contributes significantly to a positive dining experience and a welcoming atmosphere.

• Clean and Great Atmosphere: The interior of the restaurant is consistently described as clean with a great atmosphere. This creates a comfortable and inviting environment for both dining in and picking up orders.

• Nostalgic Appeal for Long-Time Locals: For some long-time residents of the area, Possum Holler Pizza carries a strong sense of nostalgia, having been a part of their lives for decades. This historical connection adds to its charm and local appeal.

• Alternative to Big Chains: Many customers highlight Possum Holler Pizza as a refreshing alternative to larger, more generic pizza chains, praising its unique taste and local charm.

Address: 1874 Lisle Ave, Obetz, OH 43207, USA

Phone: (614) 497-1355

For the discerning residents of Obetz and the wider Columbus, Ohio area, Possum Holler Pizza at 1874 Lisle Ave is more than just a place to get a meal; it's a deeply ingrained part of the local fabric, offering a unique and consistently satisfying pizza experience. Its suitability for locals is evident in several key aspects that cater to community preferences and values.

Firstly, its distinctive pizza style with a sweet sauce, generous toppings, and a unique, crispy "cracker" crust sets it apart from typical chain pizzerias. This unique flavor profile means that locals looking for something different, or those who appreciate a specific kind of pizza, will find exactly what they're looking for. The commitment to loading up on toppings, as seen with the Owner's Favorite, ensures a hearty and satisfying meal.

Secondly, the friendly and attentive service, combined with a clean and inviting atmosphere, makes dining at Possum Holler Pizza a genuinely pleasant experience. Locals value establishments where they feel welcomed and well-cared for, and the staff's professionalism and attentiveness contribute significantly to this positive perception. This welcoming environment makes it ideal for family outings, casual dinners, or simply grabbing a quick, delicious bite.

The fact that it's a "mom and pop pizza shop" and has been a part of the community for decades (with some customers remembering it from 50 years ago) imbues it with a strong sense of local heritage and nostalgia. This historical connection makes it a cherished landmark for many, fostering a loyal customer base who appreciate supporting a homegrown business that has stood the test of time. It's an antidote to the ubiquity of larger chains, offering a more personal and authentic dining option.

Furthermore, the inclusion of other highly-rated items like the "very good" Italian sub ensures that there's something for everyone, broadening its appeal beyond just pizza enthusiasts. The availability of takeout and delivery services, including through platforms like Uber Eats, adds a layer of convenience that fits seamlessly into the busy lives of modern Ohio residents.

In conclusion, Possum Holler Pizza is a highly suitable choice for locals in the Ohio region because it offers a unique, high-quality product, delivered with excellent service in a welcoming environment, all while embodying the spirit of local community and tradition. It's a place where the food is good, the service is good, and the atmosphere is good—a winning combination that makes it a true local gem and a recommended destination for anyone seeking an authentic and satisfying pizza experience.

Possum Holler Pizza

1874 Lisle Ave, Obetz, OH 43207, USA