Potbelly: Your Go-To Sandwich Shop in New York's Financial District

Potbelly Introduce

In the whirlwind of activity that is New York City's Financial District, a truly great sandwich can feel like a small victory. Tucked away at 1 Dey Street, Potbelly is a popular destination that delivers on this promise, providing a warm and inviting spot for a quick and satisfying meal. This sandwich shop has earned a loyal following by combining classic comfort food with a wide variety of fresh, toasty options, making it a reliable go-to for locals, office workers, and visitors alike.

Potbelly's appeal lies in its commitment to simple, high-quality ingredients and a comforting, no-fuss experience. The core of the menu revolves around its signature toasted sandwiches, which are a fan favorite. The process is quick and efficient, ensuring that even during the busiest lunch rush, you can get a delicious, warm meal without a long wait. While it's a fast-casual spot, it offers a welcoming atmosphere that feels a step above a typical chain restaurant.

The menu is a treasure trove of sandwich options, each crafted to perfection. The iconic **A Wreck®** is a must-try for meat lovers, featuring a combination of turkey, ham, roast beef, and salami. Other popular choices include the savory **Prime Rib Steak**, the classic **Italian**, and the wholesome **Avo Turkey**. For those who prefer plant-based options, the **Veggie Melt** and the **Mediterranean** sandwich (which can be made vegan) are flavorful and satisfying alternatives. The variety of choices means there is something for everyone, whether you are looking for something hearty or something light.

Beyond the sandwiches, Potbelly offers a fantastic range of other comfort food items. Their soups and macs, available after 10:00 am, are a perfect complement to any sandwich. The creamy **Mac & Cheese**, hearty **Chili**, and classic **Chicken Pot Pie** soup provide a warm and comforting side dish. The "Pick Your Pair" deals, allowing you to combine a skinny sandwich with a soup or salad, are a great value and a popular choice for those who want a balanced meal.

Potbelly doesn't stop at just savory items. The dessert and shake menu is equally impressive. The freshly baked cookies, like the **S'mores Cookie** and **Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie**, are a delicious way to end your meal. The hand-scooped shakes, with flavors like **Cold Brew Shake** and **Banana Pudding Shake**, are a decadent treat that many customers rave about. A reviewer from a different location even called the vanilla shake the "best fast food vanilla shake in my opinion," which speaks to the quality of these offerings.

Located at 1 Dey Street, Potbelly is perfectly positioned for a New York crowd. Its proximity to major office buildings and transportation hubs makes it an incredibly convenient spot for a quick lunch or dinner. The restaurant offers a variety of service options to fit your lifestyle, including **delivery, no-contact delivery, takeaway, and dine-in**. This flexibility ensures that you can enjoy your favorite sandwich wherever you are.

Customer reviews, while sometimes mixed on specifics like meat-to-bread ratio or delivery issues, generally praise the quality of the food and the efficiency of the service. Many describe the sandwiches as delicious and the staff as friendly and helpful. One reviewer said, "I could honestly eat their Tuna & swiss melt every day. It is so tasteful." Another mentioned, "I got in and out quickly (thank God). Staff was helpful and friendly. Would definitely revisit." These comments highlight the consistent quality and service that make Potbelly a reliable choice.

In a city where sandwich shops are everywhere, Potbelly stands out for its well-rounded menu, toasty warm subs, and friendly, fast service. It’s a place that understands what a busy New Yorker needs: a delicious, comforting meal that is served with a smile and a sense of efficiency.

Location and Accessibility

Potbelly is conveniently located in the Financial District of New York City.

Address: 1 Dey St, New York, NY 10007, USA

The location offers easy access for local office workers and residents, with multiple options for service.

Services Offered

Dine-in: Enjoy your meal in the comfortable and casual atmosphere of the shop.
Takeaway: A fast and convenient option for a meal on the go.
Delivery & No-Contact Delivery: Get your favorite sandwiches delivered right to your door.

Features / Highlights

Toasted Sandwiches: The signature toasted sandwiches are a major highlight and a fan favorite.
Varied Menu: A wide range of sandwiches, salads, soups, and macs to choose from.
Desserts & Shakes: Famous for their freshly baked cookies and delicious hand-scooped shakes.
Combo Deals: "Pick Your Pair" options offer a great value for a complete meal.

Contact Information

Address: 1 Dey St, New York, NY 10007, USA

Phone: (917) 359-8400

What is worth choosing

Potbelly is worth choosing for its ability to deliver a delicious and comforting meal with speed and variety. The toasted sandwiches, particularly the **A Wreck®** and the **Prime Rib Steak**, are the main draw. However, the true value lies in the complete experience—the option to pair a sandwich with a warm bowl of soup or a fresh salad, and to finish it off with a classic shake or a freshly baked cookie. It's a place that provides more than just a quick bite; it offers a full, satisfying meal that is both reliable and enjoyable. For anyone in the Financial District looking for a go-to sandwich shop, Potbelly is a standout choice.

Potbelly Food & drink

Combos & Deals
Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich + Soup US$12.99
Choose any skinny sandwich and any cup of soup, chili, or mac & cheese
Pick Your Pair Salad + Soup US$12.99
Choose any half salad and any cup of soup, chili, or mac & cheese
Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich + Salad US$14.99
Choose any skinny sandwich and any half salad

Sandwiches
Prime Rib Steak
Tender sliced prime rib steak, swiss, housemade caramelized onions, garlic aioli. Want to turn up the heat? Try it with our signature Hot Peppers.
Cubano
Slow-cooked pulled pork, hickory smoked ham, swiss, deli mustard, pickles
Sweet Heat Pork BBQ
Slow-cooked pulled pork, cheddar, pickles, and sweet heat BBQ sauce made with our signature hot peppers
A Wreck
A meaty fan favorite! Turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami, swiss. Want to spice it up a little? Try it with our NEW Hot Pepper Ranch.
Italian
Salami, old-world capicola, pepperoni, mortadella, provolone. Want to add even more flavor? Try it with Oil and NEW Red Wine Vinegar.
Avo Turkey
Hand-sliced turkey breast, swiss, fresh-sliced avocado, cucumbers. Want to spice it up a little? Try it with our NEW Hot Pepper Ranch.
Chicken Club
All-natural grilled chicken, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar. Want sweet with a little spicy? Try it with our NEW Sweet Heat BBQ Sauce.
BLTA
Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, fresh-sliced avocado. Want to spice it up a little? Try it with our NEW Hot Pepper Ranch.
Veggie Melt
Fresh-sliced avocado, swiss, cheddar, provolone, mushrooms. Want to add even more flavor? Try it with our NEW Roasted Garlic Aioli.
Pizza Melt
Pepperoni, old-world capicola, crumbled meatball, smothered in marinara sauce, provolone, Italian seasoning, mushrooms [can be made vegetarian]. Want to turn up the heat? Try it with our signature Hot Peppers.
Mediterranean
All-natural grilled chicken, feta, zesty hummus, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, cucumbers (can be made vegetarian)
Mama's Meatball
Homestyle beef + pork meatballs smothered in marinara sauce, provolone, Italian seasoning. Want to turn up the heat? Try it with our signature Hot Peppers.
Turkey Breast
Hand-sliced turkey breast, swiss. Want to add even more flavor? Try it with our NEW Roasted Garlic Aioli.
Smoked Ham
Hickory smoked ham, swiss. Want to add the perfect companion? Try it with our Deli Mustard.
Roast Beef
Angus roast beef, provolone
Grilled Chicken
All-natural grilled chicken, cheddar. Want sweet with a little spicy? Try it with our NEW Sweet Heat BBQ sauce.
Tuna Salad
100% albacore tuna salad, swiss. Want a little crunch? Try adding some Cucumbers.
Chicken Salad
Chicken salad, provolone. Want a little crunch? Try adding some Cucumbers.
PB&J
Creamy peanut butter, grape jelly
Grilled Cheese
Melted cheddar

Underground
Barnyard
Turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami, meatballs, applewood smoked bacon, Swiss. Want to turn up the heat? Try it with our signature Hot Peppers.
Pork BBQ Mac
Our signature three-cheese mac topped with slow-cooked pulled pork and our sweet heat BBQ sauce.
Smokestack
Slow-cooked pulled pork, sweet heat barbeque sauce, and our signature mac & cheese
Chicken Cordon Bleu
All-natural grilled chicken, hickory smoked ham, Swiss cheese, deli mustard, lettuce and tomato served on our toasty bread
Clubby
Oven roasted turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, applewood smoked bacon, provolone, and creamy buttermilk ranch. Want to spice it up a little? Try it with our NEW Hot Pepper Ranch.
Lucky 7
Turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami, old-world capicola, pepperoni, mortadella, provolone. Want to add even more flavor? Try it with Oil and NEW Red Wine Vinegar.
Sicilian
Crumbled meatballs, marinara, salami, old-world capicola, pepperoni, mortadella, mushrooms, provolone. Want to turn up the heat? Try it with our signature Hot Peppers.
Wrecking Ball
Crumbled meatballs, marinara, turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami, provolone. Want to turn up the heat? Try it with our signature Hot Peppers.
Fireball
Homestyle beef + pork meatballs, chili, Potbelly hot peppers, cheddar
A Wreck® Salad
Our fan favorite…now in a salad! Turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami, swiss, hard-boiled egg, cucumber and tomatoes, served on a bed of field greens with creamy buttermilk ranch. Want to spice it up a little? Try it with our NEW Hot Pepper Ranch.

Salads
Farmhouse Salad
All-natural grilled chicken breast, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, hard-boiled egg, cucumber and tomatoes, served on a bed of field greens with creamy buttermilk ranch. Want to spice it up a little? Try it with our NEW Hot Pepper Ranch.
Apple Walnut Salad
All-natural grilled chicken breast, crumbled blue cheese, grapes, apples, dried cranberries and candied walnuts, served on a bed of field greens with balsamic vinaigrette
Powerhouse Salad
All-natural grilled chicken breast, fresh-sliced avocado, hummus, hard-boiled egg, cucumber and tomatoes, served on a bed of field greens with non-fat vinaigrette
Chicken Salad Salad
Freshly made chicken salad, provolone cheese, dried cranberries, cucumber and tomatoes, served on a bed of field greens with balsamic vinaigrette

Soups & Macs
Mac & Soups available after 10:00 am
Chili Mac
Hearty beef chili with kidney beans, bell peppers and onions topped with our creamy, three-cheese mac
Mac & Cheese
Creamy, three-cheese mac
Broccoli Cheddar
Creamy cheese soup with tender pieces of broccoli and carrots
Chicken Pot Pie
Tender, slow-roasted chicken breast and veggies topped with crumbles of fresh-baked pie crust
Chili
Hearty beef chili with kidney beans, bell peppers and onions
Garden Vegetable
Beans, carrots, celery, corn, mushrooms, onions, peppers, potatoes and zucchini in a light tomato broth
Loaded Baked Potato
Hearty potato soup with bacon, cheddar cheese and green onion

Drinks
Coke US$3.79
20 oz. Bottle
Diet Coke US$3.79
20 oz. Bottle
Sprite US$3.79
20 oz. Bottle
Cherry Coke US$3.79
20 oz. Bottle
Coke Zero Sugar US$3.79
20 oz. Bottle
16 oz. Bottled Water US$2.49
16 oz. Bottle
25 oz. Bottled Water US$2.99
25 oz. Bottle
IBC Cream Soda US$3.79
12 oz. Bottle
IBC Root Beer US$3.79
12 oz. Bottle
smartwater US$3.99
20 oz. Bottle
San Pellegrino US$3.79
16.9 oz. Bottle
San Pellegrino Blood Orange US$3.79
11.15 oz Can
Gold Peak Sweet Tea US$3.29
18.5 oz. Bottle
Gold Peak Green Tea US$3.29
18.5 oz. Bottle
Powerade Mountain Berry Blast US$3.79
20 oz. Bottle
Crush US$3.79
12oz. Bottle
Vitamin Water XXX Acai Blue Pomegranate US$3.99
20 oz. Bottle
Vitamin Water Squeezed Lemonade US$3.99
20oz Bottle
Arizona Tea US$3.69
16oz Bottle
Peach Tea Snapple US$3.49
16oz Bottle
Nantucket Nectars Orange Mango US$3.79
16oz Bottle

Chips & Sides
Chips + Drink US$4.59
Make it a Meal Deal! Choose any chips and a drink.
Chips + Bottled Drink US$4.59
Make it a Meal Deal! Choose any chips and a drink.
Chips + Shake US$4.59
Make it a Meal Deal! Choose any chips and a shake.
Zapp's Regular Chips US$2.59
Zapp's Salt & Vinegar Chips US$2.59
Baked Lay's US$2.59
Utz Cheese Curls US$2.59
Zapp's Hotter 'N Hot Jalapeño Chips US$2.59
Zapp's Mesquite BBQ Chips US$2.59
Zapp's Hot Pepper Chips US$2.59
Zapp's VooDoo Regular Chips US$2.59
Hot Peppers Jar US$7.49
Our famous giardiniera hot peppers, ready to spice up your kitchen at home. A perfect gift, too.
Potbelly Whole Pickle US$1.59

Cookies & Shakes
S'mores Cookie
Chocolate chunks, graham crackers and marshmallows
6-Pack Cookie Box
Choose 6 of your favorite cookie or an assortment of our fresh-baked cookies
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie US$2.79
A Potbelly favorite! Freshly baked oatmeal chocolate chip cookie
Sugar Cookie US$2.79
Baked fresh daily
Chocolate Brownie Cookie US$2.79
Baked fresh daily
Dream Bar US$2.79
Rich, chocolatey oatmeal bar with sweet caramel
Bag of Mini Cookies US$5.69
Dozen mini oatmeal chocolate chip cookies
Root Beer Float Shake
The classic flavor of a soda shop favorite in a creamy hand-dipped shake.
Banana Pudding Shake
The creamy vanilla and sweet banana flavors of the dessert classic, now in a delicious hand-dipped shake
Cold Brew Shake
Cold-brewed Arabica coffee and hand-dipped vanilla ice cream. Shake and wake!
OREO® Cookie Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream. OREO is a trademark of Mondelez International group, used under license.
Chocolate Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream
Strawberry Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream
Vanilla Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream

Upsells
Chips + Drink US$4.59
Make it a Meal Deal! Choose any chips and a drink.
Chips + Bottled Drink US$4.59
Make it a Meal Deal! Choose any chips and a drink.
Cookie
6-Pack Cookie Box
Choose 6 of your favorite cookie or an assortment of our fresh-baked cookies
Mac or Soup Cup
Half Salad