The Fish Bar

- 2421 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458

The Fish Bar is a true treasure nestled in the heart of the Bronx's historic Little Italy on Arthur Avenue. This restaurant offers a refreshing and unique concept that distinguishes it from many other dining spots in the area. It is a seafood sanctuary where freshness is not just a promise but a core principle of the dining experience. Patrons have the rare and delightful opportunity to select the exact amount and type of seafood they desire, which is then cooked to their specific instructions. This personalized approach to dining creates an intimate and memorable experience, making The Fish Bar a standout destination. The owner and staff are widely praised for their friendly and accommodating nature, contributing to a welcoming and cozy atmosphere. This level of personal service, combined with the high quality of the food, sets the restaurant apart and has garnered it a loyal following. It provides a much-needed option for seafood lovers in the Bronx who, according to a customer review, may have previously only found such a concept in other boroughs like Queens. The Fish Bar is a testament to the fact that great food and great people can create an extraordinary dining spot. Its commitment to serving fresh, flavorful seafood in a friendly, no-fuss environment makes it a must-visit for anyone in the New York area looking for a top-tier seafood meal. The restaurant's appeal lies in its simplicity and its focus on the quality of its ingredients, allowing the natural taste of the seafood to shine.

The culinary philosophy at The Fish Bar is rooted in the simple joy of fresh, perfectly cooked seafood. The menu is built around the freshest catches, which patrons can view and select themselves. This "pick-your-own" model ensures a truly bespoke meal. The a la carte offerings and daily specials are a showcase of the chef’s expertise. Patrons rave about the baked clams, noting that they are "fresh and hot and not with a bunch of breading," a small detail that speaks volumes about the restaurant's quality-first approach. The grilled shrimp is also a popular choice, praised for its flavor and preparation. The menu is complemented by a fantastic selection of beverages, including a great variety of cocktails, beer, wine, and hard liquor. This makes it an ideal spot not only for a delicious meal but also for a relaxing drink. The price point for sides is very reasonable, ranging from $5 to $8, which makes building a complete meal accessible and affordable. The restaurant’s atmosphere is described as both casual and cozy, creating a comfortable and relaxed setting for diners. The food is made with a clear passion for seafood, from the perfectly cooked sea bass to the flavorful shrimp and scallops, as highlighted by a satisfied customer. This consistent dedication to flavor and quality is why people recommend it to others and keep returning themselves. The restaurant has successfully created a unique dining experience that feels both luxurious and approachable, making it a beloved institution in its neighborhood.

The Fish Bar is conveniently located at 2421 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458, USA. This puts it squarely in the vibrant and bustling heart of the Belmont neighborhood, known as the Bronx's Little Italy. The area is a destination in itself, famous for its authentic Italian markets, bakeries, and eateries. Finding the restaurant is straightforward due to its prominent location on Arthur Avenue. For those driving, paid street parking is available, which is a convenient option in this busy area. The neighborhood is also well-served by public transportation, making it easily accessible for anyone in the New York City region. The restaurant's location in Little Italy adds to its charm, as patrons can enjoy a meal and then explore the rich culinary and cultural heritage of the surrounding area. The atmosphere of Arthur Avenue itself is lively and welcoming, complementing the cozy and casual vibe of The Fish Bar. The accessibility and location make it a great spot for both a planned dinner or a spontaneous drop-in. Being situated in such a historic and beloved neighborhood is a significant part of the restaurant's appeal, drawing in both local regulars and visitors from all over the city who are looking for an authentic and high-quality dining experience. The owner's and staff's friendly attitude further enhance the welcoming nature of the place, making guests feel like they are part of the community.

The Fish Bar provides a variety of services to accommodate different dining preferences. The main service options are delivery, takeout, and dine-in, offering convenience for any occasion. Patrons can enjoy their fresh seafood at the restaurant's seating, which includes table service, making for a relaxed and pleasant dining experience. The restaurant is open for both lunch and dinner, catering to various schedules. For those with a sweet tooth, dessert is also available to round out the meal. The bar onsite serves a wide array of beverages, including alcohol, beer, cocktails, hard liquor, and wine, so you can pair your seafood with the perfect drink. The menu includes comfort food and small plates, offering options for a light bite or a full, satisfying meal. The restaurant is equipped with a restroom for customer convenience. For families with young children, high chairs are available. The payment process is straightforward, with the restaurant accepting both credit cards and debit cards. The friendly and professional service is a consistent highlight, with staff members making guests feel welcome from the moment they arrive. The ability to choose your own seafood and have it prepared to your liking is a unique service that adds a significant layer of personalization to the dining experience, setting The Fish Bar apart from traditional restaurants.

The range of services includes:

• Service options: Delivery, Takeout, Dine-in
• Dining options: Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Seating, Table service
• Offerings: Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Comfort food, Hard liquor, Small plates, Wine
• Amenities: Bar onsite, Restroom
• Payments: Credit cards, Debit cards

The Fish Bar is celebrated for several key features and highlights that make it a favorite among its patrons. The most notable highlight is the exceptional freshness of the seafood, which a customer review notes is "so fresh." The unique concept of allowing customers to hand-pick their seafood and choose their preferred cooking style is a major draw. The restaurant is known for its fast service, ensuring that even with a personalized order, the wait time is minimal. The bar's offering of great cocktails is another highlight, complementing the delicious food. The atmosphere is described as both casual and cozy, making it a comfortable place to relax and enjoy a meal. It is a popular spot for lunch and dinner, and also an excellent choice for solo dining. The restaurant also caters to groups, providing a great setting for a social gathering. The staff, including the owner and waitress, consistently receive high praise for their niceness and friendliness, making the dining experience feel personal and inviting. The quality of the food is a recurring theme in reviews, with dishes like the baked clams and sea bass made to perfection. The presence of high chairs makes it good for children, and the availability of paid street parking adds to the convenience for visitors. The restaurant's ability to provide a high-quality, personalized meal in a welcoming setting is its most compelling feature.

Key highlights include:

• Highlights: Fast service, Great cocktails, Fresh seafood cooked to order.
• Popular for: Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining, Groups.
• Atmosphere: Casual, Cozy.
• Crowd: Groups.
• Children: High chairs.

The Fish Bar is located at 2421 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458, USA. To inquire about hours of operation, make a reservation, or place an order for pickup, you can call them at (347) 270-3052. Given the note from a customer about calling ahead, it's a good idea to confirm their hours before your visit. The team is always ready to assist and ensure you have a wonderful dining experience.

What makes The Fish Bar worth choosing? It's the unique and exceptional combination of a personalized dining experience and outstanding quality. The ability to select your own seafood and have it prepared to your exact liking is a feature rarely found and highly valued by customers. This, coupled with the commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, ensures a meal that is both delicious and satisfying. The staff's kindness and attentiveness, as highlighted in the glowing reviews, make every visit feel special. The cozy and casual atmosphere provides the perfect backdrop for enjoying your meal, whether you're dining alone or with friends. The availability of great cocktails and other beverages further enhances the experience. While the restaurant’s hours may vary, the high quality of the food and service makes it worth the effort to plan your visit. The Fish Bar fills a special niche in the Bronx's dining scene, providing a high-end seafood experience in a friendly, community-oriented setting. For anyone in New York looking for fresh seafood that is both personalized and perfectly prepared, The Fish Bar is an absolute must-visit destination.

The Fish Bar

2421 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458, USA