The Old Bag of Nails

- 4661 E Broad St, Whitehall, OH 43213

For residents of Ohio, especially those in and around Whitehall, there's a local establishment that consistently delivers on classic pub charm and delicious, hearty meals: The Old Bag of Nails Pub. This well-known spot has become a fixture in our community, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can unwind and enjoy a satisfying meal. With its roots stretching back to 1996, The Old Bag of Nails has evolved from an old hardware store into a beloved neighborhood pub, known for its signature British-style fish and chips and an extensive menu of pub favorites.

It's a place where you can count on finding comfort food done right, whether you're craving crispy fish, a juicy burger, or a refreshing pint. While individual experiences can vary, the overall sentiment from locals points to a place that prioritizes good food and a welcoming environment. The Old Bag of Nails Pub prides itself on being a gathering spot, perfect for a casual lunch, a relaxed dinner with family, or simply catching up with friends over drinks. It represents that quintessential neighborhood pub feel that so many in Ohio appreciate.

The Old Bag of Nails Pub is conveniently located at 4661 E Broad St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA. This address places it within easy reach for residents of Whitehall and the surrounding communities, including parts of Columbus. East Broad Street is a significant thoroughfare, making the pub easily identifiable and accessible by car.

Its location within the Lofts at Norton Crossing complex also adds to its accessibility, as it is situated in a mixed-use development that often provides ample parking. For those who utilize public transportation, the E Broad St corridor is typically well-served by local bus routes, offering an alternative way to reach the pub. The strategic positioning of The Old Bag of Nails Pub ensures that it's a convenient destination for a meal, whether you're driving, walking, or using public transport, making it a practical choice for locals seeking a comfortable dining experience.

The Old Bag of Nails Pub offers a comprehensive range of services designed to provide a full-service dining experience for its patrons. These services cater to various preferences, ensuring that guests can enjoy their classic pub fare in a way that suits them best.

• Dine-In Service: The pub provides a comfortable and welcoming indoor dining atmosphere, perfect for casual meals with family and friends. The ambiance is generally described as nice, creating a relaxed setting.
• Full-Service Bar: As a pub, The Old Bag of Nails offers a wide selection of alcoholic beverages, including a variety of beers on tap (such as Guinness), wines, and seasonal cocktails like the Kentucky mule, as highlighted in customer reviews. They often feature drink specials, such as $5 16 oz drafts of specific IPAs.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: The restaurant operates throughout the day, typically from 11 AM to 9 PM or 9:30 PM on most days, making it suitable for both lunch and dinner crowds. They are open seven days a week, providing consistent availability.
• Takeout/Online Ordering: For those who prefer to enjoy their meals at home, The Old Bag of Nails Pub offers online ordering for pickup and delivery, providing a convenient option for busy individuals and families.
• Diverse Menu Offerings: The menu spans a wide range of pub classics and American favorites, with a strong emphasis on seafood. Key categories include:
  • Seafood Classics: Most notably their "Classic Fish and Chips" (two crispy British-style Atlantic fillets), but also New England Reuben (fish-based), Three Fish or Shrimp Tacos, Atlantic Salmon, Mussels & Shrimp, and Shrimp Po'boy. Seasonal specials, like lobster rolls, are also featured.
  • Burgers & Reubens: A variety of burgers and Reubens, including the Traditional Pub Reuben and New England Reuben.
  • Starters: A selection of appetizers such as Fried Pickles, Loaded Skins, Fried Mushrooms, Jumbo Pretzel with beer cheese sauce, Cheese Curds, and Coconut Shrimp.
  • Soups & Salads: Options like New England Clam Chowder, French Onion soup, and various salads including Cobb, House, and Spinach salads.
  • Chicken Dishes: Including Chicken Tender Baskets, Buffalo Chicken Wraps, and Spicy Chicken Quesadillas.
  • Desserts: Options like Carrot Cake and Bread Pudding with bourbon sauce.

The Old Bag of Nails Pub in Whitehall stands out due to several key features and highlights that contribute to its enduring popularity among locals in Ohio.

• Signature Fish and Chips: This is arguably their most famous dish. Described as "two crispy British-style Atlantic fillets that were absolutely delicious," served with seasoned steak fries and sweet, tangy coleslaw. The consistency and quality of this classic are a major draw. Many customers specifically praise the large, flavorful, and fresh fish.
• Diverse and Well-Executed Menu: Beyond fish and chips, the pub offers a broad menu that caters to various tastes. Highlights include their seasonal lobster rolls, praised for "the perfect balance of mayonnaise, butter, and lobster," and a variety of other seafood, burgers, sandwiches, and appetizers. This ensures there's something appealing for everyone in a dining party.
• Friendly and Attentive Service: While some isolated incidents might occur, many customers consistently highlight the "friendly and attentive service." A specific mention of a server named Maddison providing excellent care underscores the positive customer experience, contributing significantly to repeat visits.
• Appealing Drink Selection: As a pub, the establishment boasts a good selection of beverages, including "tall, frothy Guinness" and unique cocktails like a "cranberry Kentucky mule." This variety caters to different preferences and enhances the overall pub experience.
• Comfortable and Inviting Atmosphere: The pub aims for a "nice atmosphere," providing a relaxed and casual setting for meals. This laid-back environment is ideal for socializing and enjoying good food without feeling rushed.
• Efficient Service: Despite being a popular spot, food often arrives quickly, as noted by a customer during a "fairly light lunch crowd." This efficiency is a plus for those on a schedule.
• Variety of Pub Staples: Beyond seafood, the menu features other pub staples like loaded skins, jumbo pretzels with beer cheese, wings, and various salads, ensuring a wide array of options for different cravings.

For residents in Ohio looking to visit or contact The Old Bag of Nails Pub in Whitehall, here is the essential information:

Address: 4661 E Broad St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA

Phone: (614) 655-2424

Mobile Phone: +1 614-655-2424

These contact details provide direct avenues for locals to make inquiries, check on wait times, or inquire about their current menu and specials. Given their consistent operating hours, planning a visit is straightforward, and the pub remains a reliable option for a great meal in Whitehall.

The Old Bag of Nails Pub in Whitehall is an excellent choice and highly suitable for locals across Ohio, particularly those in the greater Columbus area, for numerous compelling reasons. Firstly, its established reputation as a purveyor of authentic British-style pub fare, especially their renowned fish and chips, means that locals don't have to travel far to experience a taste of traditional quality. This consistent delivery of beloved classics, combined with other well-executed menu items like their seasonal lobster rolls and diverse appetizers, ensures there’s always something to satisfy a wide range of cravings.

Beyond the food, the pub offers a genuinely welcoming and comfortable atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy a quality meal, and socialize without feeling rushed or out of place. This relaxed setting, coupled with often friendly and attentive service, creates a positive dining experience that encourages repeat visits and builds a strong sense of community. For many Ohioans, a good pub is a cornerstone of local life, and The Old Bag of Nails fits this role perfectly.

Furthermore, its convenient location on East Broad Street in Whitehall makes it easily accessible for many, whether driving or using public transport. This ease of access, combined with flexible hours for both lunch and dinner, means it can effortlessly fit into the routines of busy locals. Whether you're looking for a quick, delicious lunch, a satisfying dinner after work, or a weekend gathering spot, The Old Bag of Nails Pub provides a reliable and enjoyable option. It’s a local institution that consistently delivers on taste, atmosphere, and convenience, making it a perfect fit for the Ohio lifestyle.

The Old Bag of Nails

4661 E Broad St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA