Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery

- 7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

For residents of Reynoldsburg and the greater central Ohio area, Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery has established itself as a must-visit local destination. This isn’t just another pizza joint; it’s a place where passion for quality ingredients and expert craftsmanship come together to create a truly memorable meal. The restaurant is renowned for its wood-fired pizzas, which feature a unique sourdough crust that has been perfected to strike the ideal balance between chewy and crispy. The toppings are consistently noted for their freshness and flavor, and the house-made sauce is clearly a labor of love. Beyond the fantastic pizza, the "Bakery" part of the name is not just for show. Tyler’s offers a selection of baked goods that are just as impressive as the main course, with a cake-like brownie being a particular favorite. This combination of top-tier pizza and exceptional desserts makes it a standout establishment in a region with a multitude of pizza options. For locals, Tyler's has become a new "go-to" for pizza, a testament to the high quality and delicious taste that consistently earns rave reviews. It's the kind of place that, once you try it, you'll be happy to make the extra effort to get there, proving that a fantastic culinary experience is worth the drive, no matter the distance.

Located at 7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA, Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery is positioned in a convenient and accessible spot for residents of Reynoldsburg and the surrounding Columbus suburbs. Its location on East Main Street, a well-traveled thoroughfare, makes it easy to find and get to, whether you're coming from work, running errands, or planning a specific trip to the pizzeria. For many, its placement in the community makes it a go-to spot for a special meal that feels both local and elevated. The restaurant's storefront is part of the local landscape, and its presence contributes to the vibrant dining scene in Reynoldsburg. While a specific review mentioned the location isn't the most convenient for everyone, the high quality of the food makes it a destination spot that people are willing to travel for. The ease of access from major roads means that a great pizza and a delicious brownie are never too far away for those in central Ohio. This accessibility is a key factor in its popularity, as it allows a broad cross-section of the community to enjoy what Tyler’s has to offer, from a casual weeknight dinner to a celebratory feast.

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery offers a range of services that are focused on providing a high-quality and seamless experience for its customers. From the moment an order is placed to the final bite, the establishment is dedicated to ensuring a positive interaction. The services are centered on the core mission of delivering fantastic food with a focus on fresh ingredients and expert preparation. This dedication is evident in the rave reviews that consistently highlight the quality of the food and the craftsmanship behind it. While the restaurant may operate with a lean team, as is common for many local businesses, the focus remains on the customer experience. Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery has a menu of wood-fired pizzas, as well as calzones and strombolis. The bakery side of the business offers a variety of desserts, which are also available for order, with customers often praising the quality. The restaurant’s service model is built around giving customers a choice of how they want to enjoy their meal, whether it’s a spontaneous dinner or a pre-planned order for a special occasion. The option to order bakery items in advance for pickup is a key service that highlights the establishment’s dedication to providing a full-service culinary experience.

• Tyler’s offers a menu of wood-fired pizzas, made with a special sourdough crust, that are available for order.
• A variety of bakery items and desserts, including the highly-praised cake-like brownies, are also available for purchase.
• Customers can enjoy a variety of unique specialty pizzas, such as the "Pauper's Pie" with a white sauce base and the "Pigskin Pie," a meat lover's dream.
• The restaurant also provides catering services for wood-fired pizzas and other baked goods, making it a great option for events and gatherings.
• The full menu includes an array of options with fresh toppings and high-quality ingredients, from classic cheese to more adventurous creations.
• The restaurant provides both dine-in and takeout options, catering to customers who want to enjoy their meal in the restaurant or at home.

What truly sets Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery apart from other pizzerias in the central Ohio area are its unique features and highlights. These are the elements that create a memorable experience and have helped it earn a reputation as one of the best pizza spots in the region. The commitment to quality is evident in every detail, from the handmade dough to the fresh toppings. The use of a wood-fired oven is a significant highlight, as it imparts a distinct smoky flavor and ensures a perfectly cooked crust. The sourdough crust itself is a major feature, with many customers noting its excellent texture and taste, which strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy. The fact that the restaurant is also a bakery means that the desserts are just as much of a star as the pizza. The cake-like brownie, for example, has garnered specific praise for its rich, yet light and airy texture. This dual focus on both savory and sweet items provides a comprehensive culinary experience that is rare to find. These features are what make Tyler's a destination for food lovers and a point of local pride. The attention to detail, from the flavorful sauce to the high-quality ingredients, shows that this is a business that cares deeply about the food it serves and the community it serves it to.

• The pizza features a delicious, perfectly baked sourdough crust that is both chewy and crispy.
• The toppings are fresh, plentiful, and flavorful, while the sauce is clearly made with high-quality ingredients.
• The wood-fired oven is a key highlight, providing a smoky flavor and a perfectly cooked crust.
• The bakery offers exceptional desserts, with the cake-like brownie being a standout favorite for its light and rich qualities.
• The menu includes unique and creative specialty pizzas, such as the "Pauper's Pie" and the "Pigskin Pie," which cater to a variety of tastes.
• Tyler’s has earned recognition as one of the top pizza spots in the Midwest, a significant feature for a local business.
• The overall culinary experience is described as fantastic, with a great balance of flavors and textures in every dish.

For those in the Reynoldsburg, Ohio, area, contacting Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery is straightforward. The physical address is 7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA. This address is the central hub for all in-person interactions, including carryout orders and in-house dining. To reach the restaurant by phone for questions or to place an order, the number is (614) 322-9587. For a mobile contact option, the number is +1 614-322-9587. The availability of these two phone numbers ensures that customers have multiple ways to connect with the restaurant, which is especially important for a busy local establishment. The clear and accessible contact information makes it simple for both new and returning customers to get in touch, whether they have a question about the menu, hours of operation, or to place a large order. This straightforward communication is a vital part of building a positive relationship with the community and ensuring that customers can rely on the restaurant for their dining needs. It’s this attention to detail in customer service that helps Tyler’s solidify its reputation as a trusted and cherished local business.

In conclusion, Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery is an exceptional choice for locals in the Ohio region, particularly in Reynoldsburg and central Ohio, who are seeking a superior pizza experience. The restaurant’s commitment to quality is evident in its delicious sourdough crust, fresh toppings, and expert wood-fired preparation. Beyond the pizza, the bakery offers a delightful surprise with its fantastic desserts, particularly the cake-like brownies that many customers rave about. While the location may not be the most convenient for every single person, the high quality of the food makes it a destination worth the trip. The positive reviews and strong local reputation speak volumes about the dedication and passion that go into every single meal. For anyone looking to support a local business that truly cares about the food it serves, Tyler’s is an ideal spot. It offers a culinary experience that combines the best of a traditional pizzeria with the added bonus of an artisan bakery, making it a unique and valuable asset to the Reynoldsburg community. It's a place that delivers on its promise of flavor and quality, and it's a new favorite for many who call central Ohio home.

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery

7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA