Brooklyn pizzeria

- 4151 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213

For those in Ohio with a discerning palate for pizza, and particularly those who appreciate the classic New York style, Brooklyn Pizzeria in Columbus aims to deliver a taste of the Big Apple right to your neighborhood. Located at 4151 E Main St, this establishment strives to bring the distinctive flavors and textures of a true Brooklyn pie to the Buckeye State. While experiences at any eatery can be varied, Brooklyn Pizzeria has garnered attention for its efforts to provide authentic pizza and a diverse menu that caters to various cravings.

Brooklyn Pizzeria positions itself as a spot where the quality of the crust and sauce are paramount, key elements that define a great pizza. Their menu showcases a wide range of options, from classic cheese and pepperoni to more specialized pies like BBQ Chicken and Veggie Pizza. Beyond pizza, they offer a substantial selection of Italian-American staples, including pastas, hot subs, and even grilled items like burgers, aiming to provide a comprehensive dining experience. Some patrons speak highly of the "delicious" sauce and crust, giving a "10/10" rating and expressing a strong desire to "come every day" due to the "perfect" prices. While some isolated feedback mentions areas for improvement, the overwhelming sentiment from many is that Brooklyn Pizzeria is a solid choice for those seeking an authentic pizza experience, reminiscent of what you'd find on the streets of New York.

Brooklyn Pizzeria is conveniently situated at 4151 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213, USA. This location places it along East Main Street, a prominent and well-trafficked thoroughfare that connects various parts of Columbus and nearby communities, including Whitehall. This strategic positioning ensures easy access for both local residents and those commuting through the area, making it a practical stop for lunch or dinner.

The accessibility of 4151 E Main St extends to its ease of navigation. For individuals traveling by car, there are typically parking options available that make picking up an order or dining in a straightforward process. Being on a major road also means that the pizzeria is often served by local public transportation routes, providing an alternative for patrons who prefer not to drive. The location's visibility further assists in easy identification, ensuring that first-time visitors can find Brooklyn Pizzeria without much difficulty. This blend of central location and convenient access contributes significantly to its suitability as a regular dining spot for the diverse population across Ohio looking for a taste of authentic New York-style pizza.

Brooklyn Pizzeria offers a wide array of services designed to accommodate various dining preferences and needs, ensuring a convenient experience for its customers.

• Dine-In Service: The restaurant typically provides a casual setting for customers who wish to enjoy their pizza and other dishes on-site. While some feedback may vary on the comfort of the dining area, the option to eat in is available.
• Carryout/Pickup: A primary service, allowing customers to place orders for pickup, making it convenient for those who prefer to enjoy their food at home or elsewhere.
• Online Ordering: Brooklyn Pizzeria facilitates online ordering through platforms like Grubhub, Uber Eats, and their own website, enabling customers to easily browse the menu, customize their orders, and pay in advance for seamless pickup or delivery.
• Delivery Service: For added convenience, the pizzeria often partners with third-party delivery services, bringing their New York-style pizzas and other menu items directly to your doorstep.
• Extensive Menu: Beyond a variety of pizza types (including different sizes from 10" to 20" and specialty options like Meat Lovers, Veggie, Hawaiian, BBQ Chicken, and even Gluten-Free options), they offer a broad selection of other dishes. This includes pastas (Marinara, Alfredo, Carbonara, Bolognesa, Baked Ziti, Lasagna), hot subs (Philly Cheesesteak, Chicken Parmigiana, Meatball Parmigiana), grilled items (Cheeseburgers, Bacon Cheeseburgers), and appetizers (Wings in various flavors like Buffalo and BBQ, Mozzarella Sticks, French Fries, Chicken Fingers).
• Pizza by the Slice: For a quick meal or a taste test, Brooklyn Pizzeria offers New York Style pizza slices, including cheese, pepperoni, and vegetarian options.
• Daily Specials and Deals: They frequently offer various specials and coupons, such as combo deals for pizzas and wings, or special pricing on multiple pies, providing excellent value for families and groups.
• Catering Services: For larger events or gatherings, the restaurant may offer catering, providing platters of their popular menu items.

Brooklyn Pizzeria in Columbus stands out with several key features and highlights that aim to attract and satisfy local diners.

• Authentic New York Style Pizza: The primary draw is their commitment to New York-style pizza. This includes thin, foldable crusts, a solid sauce-to-cheese ratio, and a distinct flavor profile that many reviewers compare favorably to authentic New York pies.
• Variety of Pizza Options: Beyond the classic cheese and pepperoni, they offer specialty pizzas like Brunette, Five Cheese, Carbonara, Meat Lovers, BBQ Chicken, and Margherita, catering to diverse tastes. Gluten-free crust options are also available for those with dietary restrictions.
• Extensive Non-Pizza Menu: Brooklyn Pizzeria goes beyond just pizza, offering a full Italian-American menu. This includes various pasta dishes (like Alfredo, Carbonara, Bolognesa, Baked Ziti), a range of hot subs (Philly Cheesesteak, Chicken Parmigiana), grilled items (burgers), and salads, making it a versatile dining spot.
• Wings with Good Sauce: While some feedback on wing seasoning varies, the sauce for the wings is generally well-received and noted as "good." They offer classic options like Buffalo and BBQ.
• Value-Oriented Pricing and Deals: Several customers highlight the "PERFECT" prices, with many daily specials and combo deals (e.g., 2 Large 2-Topping Pizzas Special, Pizza & Wings deals) that make it an affordable option for families and groups.
• Quick Service for Pick-Up: As with many pizzerias, efficiency in order preparation for pickup is a focus, allowing customers to get their food in a timely manner, especially during non-peak hours.
• Diverse Topping Selection: For custom pizzas, they offer an extensive list of cheeses (including fresh mozzarella, feta, smoked gouda, vegan cheese), meats (prosciutto, hot capocolla, halal chicken), and vegetables (sun-dried tomatoes, arugula, roasted garlic, jalapenos), allowing for highly personalized creations.

To connect with Brooklyn Pizzeria or to place an order for pick-up or delivery, here is their contact information:

Address: 4151 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213, USA

Phone: (614) 947-0065

Mobile Phone: +1 614-947-0065

For Ohio locals, particularly those in the Columbus and Whitehall areas, Brooklyn Pizzeria is a highly suitable option for several compelling reasons. Firstly, its commitment to offering authentic New York-style pizza provides a distinct flavor profile that stands out from other local offerings. For residents who appreciate the classic thin, foldable crust and balanced taste of a true New York pie, this pizzeria aims to satisfy that specific craving, often garnering praise for its crust and sauce.

Secondly, the restaurant's extensive menu goes beyond just pizza, providing a wide array of Italian-American dishes including pastas, hot subs, and wings. This diversity means that Brooklyn Pizzeria can cater to varied tastes within a single family or group, ensuring there's something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty lasagna, a satisfying cheesesteak sub, or a classic pepperoni pizza, the options are plentiful and designed to be accessible.

Finally, the combination of convenient accessibility on East Main Street, competitive pricing, and frequent specials makes it a practical and appealing choice for everyday dining. While some minor inconsistencies in service or dining comfort have been mentioned, the overall positive feedback regarding food quality and value suggests that Brooklyn Pizzeria is a solid, go-to spot for locals seeking an authentic and satisfying meal without breaking the bank. It offers a genuine slice of New York culinary tradition right here in Ohio, making it a valuable addition to the local food scene.

Brooklyn pizzeria

4151 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213, USA