DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus Photos










DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus Introduce
Welcome, fellow Ohioans! When that pizza craving hits, there's a name that consistently comes up in conversations about the best slices in the state: DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus. Nestled right in the heart of Columbus, this isn't just another pizza place; it's a local institution, celebrated for its unique take on a classic comfort food. If you're searching for a pizza experience that stands out from the crowd, whether it's for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a game night with friends, DiCarlo's offers something truly special that has resonated with countless loyal customers across Ohio.
DiCarlo's Pizza - Columbus has earned its reputation by focusing on quality, consistency, and a distinct style that sets it apart. While many pizza establishments aim for a soft, doughy crust, DiCarlo's embraces a satisfyingly crunchy texture that has become its signature. This commitment to a unique culinary experience, combined with a dedication to fresh ingredients and friendly service, has solidified its place as a beloved spot for pizza lovers throughout the Columbus area and beyond.
---## Location and Accessibility
Conveniently situated at 15 E 2nd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, USA, DiCarlo's Pizza - Columbus is easily accessible for residents and visitors alike. Its prime location means it's often just a short drive from many Columbus neighborhoods, making it a hassle-free option for your next pizza fix. The area around 2nd Ave offers a vibrant atmosphere, and while specific parking details are always good to verify upon arrival, the central location typically provides various parking options in the vicinity, including street parking or nearby lots, making your visit as smooth as possible.
The accessibility of DiCarlo’s makes it a convenient choice whether you're picking up an order after work, stopping by for a casual dine-in experience, or having it delivered to your doorstep. Its position within Columbus's urban fabric ensures that it's a straightforward destination, easily reachable by car and often by public transport as well, integrating seamlessly into the daily routines of busy Ohioans.
---## Services Offered
DiCarlo's Pizza - Columbus is dedicated to providing a flexible and convenient experience for all its customers. Here's a look at the primary services you can expect:
Dine-In: For those who enjoy the classic pizzeria ambiance, DiCarlo's offers a welcoming space to sit down and enjoy your hot, fresh pizza right out of the oven. It's an ideal setting for a casual meal with family or friends, allowing you to savor the unique texture and flavor of their pizza in its prime. Many customers appreciate the opportunity to experience the pizza with its cheese in various states of melt, from unmelted to partially melted, right in the store, as noted in customer feedback.
Takeout: If you're on the go or prefer to enjoy your pizza in the comfort of your own home, takeout is a popular and efficient option. Simply place your order by phone, and your delicious pizza will be prepared for quick pickup. This service is perfect for busy weeknights, impromptu gatherings, or when you just want to unwind with some great food without the fuss.
Delivery: For ultimate convenience, DiCarlo's Pizza - Columbus also offers delivery services. This means you can enjoy their acclaimed pizza without even leaving your couch. Whether you're hosting a party, working late, or simply don't feel like cooking, their reliable delivery ensures that your pizza arrives fresh and ready to enjoy. It's a fantastic solution for those living within their delivery radius who crave that unmistakable DiCarlo's taste.
## Features / Highlights
What makes DiCarlo's Pizza - Columbus a standout in the bustling Ohio pizza scene? It's a combination of distinctive qualities that have won over a devoted following:
Crunchy, Thin Crust: This is arguably DiCarlo's most celebrated feature. Unlike many traditional pizzas, DiCarlo's offers a uniquely crunchy crust that is thinner at the base but still provides a satisfying chewiness around the edges. This distinctive texture provides an enjoyable contrast and a memorable eating experience that sets it apart from competitors.
Unmelted or Partially Melted Cheese: A defining characteristic that many patrons have come to love is the pizza often featuring cheese that is either unmelted or only partially melted when served, especially when consumed in-store. This allows for a different, often preferred, textural and flavor profile that some consider to be the "true" DiCarlo's experience. It's a unique approach that contributes to its legendary status.
Fresh Ingredients: Quality is paramount at DiCarlo's. Customers consistently praise the use of fresh ingredients, which contributes significantly to the delicious taste and overall high quality of their pizzas. This commitment to fresh produce and quality toppings ensures every bite is flavorful and satisfying.
Exceptional Customer Service: Beyond the food, DiCarlo's is lauded for its incredibly kind, sweet, and personable owners and workers. Patrons frequently highlight the pleasure of interacting with staff members like Anna, Nick, and Newton (a hard-working boy often mentioned in reviews). This friendly, welcoming atmosphere enhances the overall dining experience and makes every visit a pleasure.
"Best Pizza in Ohio" Accolades: It's not just a claim; many loyal customers emphatically state that DiCarlo's Pizza offers "absolutely the best pizza in Ohio." This strong endorsement from the local community speaks volumes about the consistent quality and unique appeal of their product.
## Contact Information
Ready to experience the DiCarlo’s difference for yourself? Here’s how you can get in touch:
Address: 15 E 2nd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, USA
Phone: (614) 966-2055
Mobile Phone: +1 614-966-2055
Whether you're calling to place an order for pickup or delivery, or simply have a question, their friendly team is ready to assist you.
---## Conclusion: Why DiCarlo’s Pizza is Suitable for Locals
For anyone living in or around Columbus, Ohio, DiCarlo’s Pizza isn't just a place to grab a slice; it's a community staple. Its unique crunchy crust, fresh ingredients, and the dedication of its incredibly kind and welcoming staff create an experience that keeps locals coming back again and again. It embodies the spirit of a true neighborhood gem – a place where you're not just a customer, but part of an extended family.
The consistent positive reviews, with customers declaring it the "best pizza in Ohio," are a testament to its enduring quality and appeal. From its convenient location to its flexible services (dine-in, takeout, and delivery), DiCarlo's makes enjoying high-quality pizza effortless. It’s the perfect spot for any occasion, whether it's a casual weeknight dinner, a celebratory meal, or simply satisfying that undeniable pizza craving with something truly exceptional. When you choose DiCarlo's Pizza - Columbus, you're not just getting a meal; you're getting a slice of local tradition and a taste of what many consider to be Ohio's finest. So, next time you're thinking about pizza, remember DiCarlo's – your local choice for delicious, crispy perfection right here in Columbus.
DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus Location
DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus
15 E 2nd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, USA
DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus Reviews
Pizza is great. Surprisingly crunchy crust, the base is also thinner than I expected but thick around the edges. Tried some in the store with unmelted cheese and once at home when it was partially melted, and was good both ways.
Jul 26, 2025 · Keaton SweeneyDelicious crunchy crispy perfection! Absolutely the best pizza in Ohio! 🤍Always made with fresh ingredients by the sweetest, and most kind owners/workers ever! Is a pleasure talking with Anna, Nick and Newton each visit! Newton is a very hard working boy.
Jun 14, 2024 · elizabethAmazing pizza in a style most people, not from the Wheeling, WV/Eastern Ohio area, have never seen. Have an open mind when trying it for the first time. The cheese is barely melted and the pepperoni is not cooked. I know, sounds weird but trust me the crust and sauce are simply amazing. Chances are, you will be hooked.I was unaware of this 15 years ago when I was staying at a hotel near Wheeling. I was upset since the pepperoni wasn't cooked and I don't think I even tried it. I assumed they messed up my order and forgot to add the pepperoni before cooking. My mistake. A buddy clued me in and ever since then it is a must eat when traveling East.Thank heavens we can get this locally now.The service being to go only was great so the atmosphere was fine, it's a to go pizza shop. Not needlesly Five Star but clean and nice.Try this if you haven't. You have been missing out.
Mar 24, 2025 · Michael So'SPerfected lunchables are what I would best describe these pies to be. Great crispy crust, hot pizza sauce, and cool cheese come together nicely. I got a half pep half cheese sheet to feed 5. Does well reheating as the cheese doesn't burn as it is not being cooked twice. also, the pie can be perfected any way you like when reheating. Something different, worth a try...
Dec 22, 2023 · Zac WJust like I remember it!!! I glad it’s here in Columbus now. I’m from the Steubenville-Wintersville area and grew up with this type of pizza.
Apr 18, 2025 · Clinton Scott
More Best Restaurants Near Me

976 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

1000 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

958 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

965 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

1026 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

940 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

951 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

1030 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

920 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

1044 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

900 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

895 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





