Brunch & Snack Chat
Brunch & Snack ChatBites & BanterBest Restaurants Near Me
CaliforniaNew JerseyNew YorkOhioTexas

Brunch & Snack ChatBest Restaurants Near MeOhioFranklin CountyColumbusSharon HeightsBest Restaurants in North High StreetDonatos Pizza
Donatos Pizza ico

Donatos Pizza
- 5388 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214

Pizza restaurant, Delivery service ★3.0 (48)·US$10–20

5388 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

3.0
This location is a hit or miss, most of the time it’s a miss! I have lived in this neighborhood for almost 3 years and once it became 2025 this restaurant has struggled. I have simple orders! I love a veggie sub and I do modify my sub. Depending on who is working will depend on how my sub looks and tastes. I order my veggie sub with no onion, no Italian dressing, and well done baked. I cannot tell you how many times this has been done wrong and I’ve had to call the store and have them remake it, and run back to the store. I may be 7 mins away but how annoying is the inconvenience. There is a woman in there that makes the sub amazing every time but unfortunately she is not always at the sub station. She has told me multiple times that she needs to train others on how to properly build the sub and have them toast the bread separately from toasting the toppings. Well I wish everyone would get it right !Long story short, I decided to do this review today because my order from my sub issue to the pizza quality has pushed me over the edge. It’s so bad that I want to get a job there just to be the next person at the sub station who makes superb subs. It’s not that hard! So here are photos of my order last night.***My sub was poorly made, my individual cheese pizza looked a mess! The sub was saturated in Italian dressing to the point there was a large puddle in the box. No tomatoes on it, barely any toppings other than a bunch of lettuce and banana peppers. This pizza came just as it looks. It looks like someone separated the slices and it’s just not attractive to look at. There is a huge speed bump in the middle as well.I am so disappointed and I wish they would get new management and new people. - Chevonne Sullivan
Donatos Pizza Overview Intro Food & drink Detail Photos Location Reviews
US$10–20 per person Reported by 48 peopleUS$1–10US$10–20US$20–30US$30–50

Donatos Pizza Introduce

For those in Ohio, especially in the Columbus metropolitan area, the name Donatos Pizza is synonymous with a specific style of pizza: thin crust with toppings that go all the way to the edge. This unique approach to a classic dish has made Donatos a local institution since its founding right here in Columbus. The location on North High Street is a key part of this legacy, serving a community that has grown up with the brand's distinctive flavor. This article is a comprehensive and factual guide to this specific Donatos Pizza, providing insight into its place in the community, its signature offerings, and the services it provides. While customer experiences can sometimes be inconsistent, the core appeal of Donatos—its quality ingredients and signature style—remains. We’ll explore what makes this location a go-to spot for many locals, from the specific menu items that draw a crowd to the various ways you can get their food, helping you decide if it's the right choice for your next pizza night.

The business model of Donatos Pizza is built on a commitment to quality and a unique product. The company's famous "Edge-to-Edge" philosophy means that every slice is loaded with toppings, ensuring a consistent flavor in every bite. This approach, combined with a thin, crispy crust, defines the Columbus-style pizza that the brand is known for. In addition to their pizzas, the menu offers a variety of other items, including oven-baked subs, fresh salads, and shareable sides like breadsticks. The North High Street restaurant operates with this same menu, providing a wide range of options to cater to different tastes. For many, Donatos is a staple for family dinners, a quick lunch, or catering for a large group. It's a place that holds a nostalgic value for those who have lived in the area for a long time, and a convenient, reliable option for newcomers. The brand's focus on fresh ingredients and consistent preparation is a major part of its appeal, even when execution can sometimes be a challenge, as some customer reviews have pointed out.

The Donatos Pizza on North High Street is located at 5388 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA. This location is easily accessible for residents of Columbus and the surrounding communities. North High Street is a major thoroughfare, and the restaurant is conveniently situated in a bustling area, making it a visible and easy-to-find destination. Its position provides easy access from various neighborhoods and is not far from major highways, which is a benefit for those who are commuting or traveling through the city. The restaurant's design typically includes a dining area for those who prefer to eat in, but its business model is heavily geared towards takeout and delivery. The accessibility of the location, with a drive-thru at some spots and ample parking, reinforces its role as a convenient option for a quick and satisfying meal. While one customer noted a long wait for pickup, the location's popularity and high volume of orders from both the drive-thru and pickup windows are indicative of its central role in the community.

Donatos Pizza offers a comprehensive range of services to meet the needs of its diverse customer base. The North High Street location provides the following services:

  • Dine-In: The restaurant has a casual dining area for customers who want to enjoy their meal on-site.
  • Carryout / Pickup: Customers can place orders online, over the phone, or in person and pick them up at the restaurant. This is a popular option for those who live or work nearby.
  • Delivery: Donatos offers its own delivery service, and also partners with third-party delivery apps like DoorDash, Grubhub, and Uber Eats. This provides a convenient way for customers to get their pizza delivered directly to their home or office.
  • Catering: Donatos is a popular choice for catering large events, parties, and office lunches. Their menu of pizzas, salads, and subs is well-suited for feeding a crowd.
  • Online Ordering: The official Donatos website and mobile app provide an easy way to browse the menu, customize orders, and pay ahead of time for both pickup and delivery.

These services demonstrate Donatos' commitment to making their food accessible to customers through multiple channels, ensuring that everyone can get their pizza in a way that works best for them.

Donatos Pizza is known for several key features and highlights that set it apart from other pizza chains. While some customer reviews indicate potential issues with consistency, these are the core elements of the brand that draw a loyal following. Key highlights include:

  • Edge-to-Edge Toppings: This is the signature feature of Donatos. The thin crust is topped with ingredients all the way to the edge, ensuring every bite is flavorful.
  • Thin, Crispy Crust: The pizza is known for its thin, cracker-like crust, which is a hallmark of the Columbus-style pizza.
  • Heritage Pepperoni: Donatos uses a specific type of pepperoni that is known for curling up and becoming slightly crispy when cooked, which is a favorite feature for many customers.
  • Wide Variety of Menu Items: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a range of oven-baked subs like the "Vegy" and "Hot Chicken Sub," as well as fresh salads and appetizers, providing options for everyone in a group.
  • Focus on Fresh Ingredients: The company prides itself on using fresh-cut vegetables and quality meats, which contributes to the overall taste and quality of their food.
  • Local Heritage: As a brand that started in Columbus, Donatos holds a special place in the hearts of many Ohioans, who appreciate its local roots and long history in the community.

These highlights, especially the unique pizza style, are what have made Donatos a local institution and a go-to choice for a specific kind of pizza experience.

For those looking to visit or contact the Donatos Pizza on North High Street in Columbus, here is the essential information:

Address: 5388 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

Phone: (614) 846-3373

The provided phone number is the best way to get in touch with the restaurant for any questions, to place a pickup order, or to report an issue with an order. The address is straightforward to locate on North High Street, a major road in Columbus. For the fastest service, especially during peak hours, it is often recommended to use the online ordering system or call ahead. While customer experiences can vary, having this direct contact information is crucial for ensuring a smooth and satisfactory interaction with the restaurant, whether you are picking up your food or dining in.

In conclusion, Donatos Pizza on North High Street is an excellent choice for locals in the Ohio region, particularly those who appreciate its unique and classic Columbus-style pizza. The restaurant’s main appeal lies in its commitment to its signature thin crust and "Edge-to-Edge" toppings, a taste and style that have been a local favorite for decades. While some customer experiences may highlight inconsistencies in order accuracy or service speed, the restaurant's core strengths—its quality ingredients, diverse menu, and strong local roots—make it a reliable and cherished option for many. Its location is highly accessible, and the wide array of services, including delivery, takeout, and catering, ensures that it can fit into any busy lifestyle. For those in Columbus, Donatos is more than just a pizza place; it's a part of the city's culinary identity, a brand that has been a staple for generations. Whether you are craving their iconic pepperoni pizza or one of their fresh subs, this Donatos location provides a taste of a local tradition that is deeply embedded in the community's food culture.

Donatos Pizza Food & drink

  • Pizza

  • Create Your Own Pizza

    Create your own pizza with up to nine meat| veggie| and cheese toppings. (Calories account for crust, sauce and cheese)

  • Pepperoni Pizza Pizza

    Loaded Edge to Edge with crispy family recipe pepperoni and aged smoked Provolone| Romano. (Calories listed are per piece)

  • Serious Cheese Pizza

    Loaded Edge to Edge with real aged smoked Wisconsin Provolone| Romano. (Calories listed are per piece)

  • Very Vegy Pizza

    Freshly cut Roma tomatoes, green peppers and yellow onions, fresh mushrooms and baby spinach, green olives, smoked Provolone, Romano. (Calories listed are per piece)

  • Ultimate 4 Cheese Pizza

    Covered Edge to Edge with smoked Provolone| fresh mozzarella| Asiago| and Romano cheeses.

  • The Works Pizza

    Family recipe pepperoni and sausage, freshly cut green peppers and yellow onions, fresh mushrooms, smoked Provolone, Romano.

  • Hot Chicken Pizza

    Crispy hot chicken, smoked Provolone cheese, jalapeño peppers, Romano, finished with dill pickles and a Ranch drizzle.

  • Chicken Spinach Mozzarella Pizza

    Sliced chicken breast, fresh baby spinach, smoked Provolone, fresh mozzarella, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, roasted garlic, Romano, olive oil (instead of red sauce). (Calories listed are per piece)

  • Hawaiian Pizza

    Shaved ham, pineapple|, sliced almonds, cinnamon, smoked Provolone.

  • Mariachi Chicken Pizza

    Sliced chicken breast, freshly cut Roma tomatoes and jalapeño peppers, smoked Provolone, mariachi spice and a side of sour cream.

  • Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza

    Family recipe pepperoni, smoked Provolone, fresh mozzarella, crushed red pepper and Mike's Hot Honey.

  • Serious Meat Pizza

    Family recipe pepperoni and sausage, shaved ham, ground beef, hardwood smoked bacon, smoked Provolone, Romano.

  • Margherita Pizza

    Fresh mozzarella and Asiago, smoked Provolone, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, basil, olive oil (instead of red sauce), balsamic drizzle.

  • Founder's Favorite Pizza

    Family recipe pepperoni and sausage, shaved ham, banana peppers, smoked Provolone, Romano.

  • Mariachi Beef Pizza

    Ground beef, freshly cut Roma tomatoes and jalapeño peppers, smoked Provolone, mariachi spice and a side of sour cream.

  • Classic Trio Pizza

    Family recipe pepperoni and sausage, fresh mushrooms, smoked Provolone, Romano.

  • BBQ Chicken Pizza

    BBQ Sauce, Smoked Provolone, Sliced Chicken Breast, Freshly Cut Yellow Onion, Hardwood Smoked Bacon, Chipotle Seasoning.

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Mild Buffalo Sauce, Smoked Provolone, Sliced Chicken Breast, Freshly Cut Yellow Onions, Hot Chicken Seasoning and a Side of Ranch.

  • Calzatos

  • Create Your Own Calzato US$8.79

    Handcrafted and filled with your choice of up to three toppings and smoked Provolone cheese, and topped with Asiago, Romano. Served with marinara sauce for dipping.

  • Subs

  • Big Don US$8.79

    Oven baked with shaved ham, sliced salami, smoked Provolone, banana peppers, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, lettuce, and choice of house Italian dressing or marinara sauce.

  • Ham & Smoked Provolone US$8.79

    Oven baked with shaved ham, smoked Provolone, lettuce, freshly cut Roma tomatoes and yellow onions, house Italian dressing.

  • Vegy US$8.79

    Oven baked with freshly cut Roma tomatoes, yellow onions and green peppers, fresh mushrooms, lettuce, banana peppers, smoked Provolone, house Italian dressing.

  • Hot Chicken US$8.79

    Oven baked with crispy hot chicken, smoked Provolone cheese, jalapeno peppers, dill pickles, ranch dressing.

  • Meatball US$8.79

    Oven baked with family recipe meatballs, marinara sauce, smoked Provolone, Romano.

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch US$8.79

    Oven baked with chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, smoked Provolone, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, lettuce, ranch dressing.

  • Appetizers

  • Family Recipe Meatballs

    Family recipe meatballs with marinara sauce, smoked Provolone and Romano.

  • Asiago Cheese Bread US$6.99

    Oven-baked artisan pull-apart bread topped with Asiago and Romano| with marinara sauce for dipping. Serves 2.

  • Garlic Asiago Cheese Bread US$6.99

    Oven-baked artisan pull-apart bread topped with garlic| Asiago and Romano| with marinara sauce for dipping. Serves 2.

  • Italian Garlic Breadsticks

    2 Italian Garlic Breadsticks with marinara sauce for dipping.

  • Chicken

  • Traditional Sauced or Dry Rubbed Wings

    Oven roasted chicken wings hand-spun with your choice of Donatos wing sauce or dry rub.

  • Boneless Wings

    Oven roasted and breaded all white meat chicken hand-spun with your choice of Donatos wing sauce.

  • Chicken Dippers

    Boneless Chicken Breast Tenders.

  • Salads

  • Italian Side Salad US$4.89

    Banana peppers, family recipe pepperoni, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, smoked Provolone, Romano. Served with house Italian dressing. Made fresh daily.

  • Very Vegy Side Salad US$4.89

    Freshly cut Roma tomatoes, freshly sliced green peppers and onion, green olives and smoked Provolone and Romano Cheeses. Made fresh daily.

  • Italian Chef Salad

    Family recipe pepperoni, shaved ham, sliced salami, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, green peppers, banana peppers, black olives, smoked Provolone, Romano. Made fresh daily.

  • Chicken Harvest Salad

    Chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, bleu cheese, honey roasted pecans, dried cranberries. Made fresh daily.

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad

    Chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, Asiago, Roma tomatoes, and served with ranch dressing. Made fresh daily.

  • Italian Garden Party Salad US$25.79

    Freshly cut Roma tomatoes, and green peppers, banana peppers, smoked Provolone. Served with house Italian dressing. Serves 10 as a side.

  • Desserts

  • OREO® Twists US$6.99

    Sweet and delicious pull-apart twists, served warm, drizzled with vanilla icing and topped with real OREO® Cookie pieces. Full size serves 4.

  • Cinnamon Bread US$6.99

    Oven-baked artisan pull-apart bread topped with sweetened cinnamon spread| streusel topping| drizzled with vanilla icing. Serves 4.

  • Cheryl's Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookie

    Individually wrapped cookie with Belgian bittersweet chocolate chips, semi-sweet chips and milk chocolate chips, pure cane brown sugar and pure Madagascar vanilla bean.

  • Cheryl's Fudge Brownie

    Individually wrapped brownie with real semi-sweet chocolate chips, unsweetened chocolate and cocoa.

  • Beverages

  • Pepsi
  • Diet Pepsi
  • Mountain Dew
  • Dr. Pepper
  • Mug Root Beer
  • Starry
  • Pure Leaf Sweet Tea
  • Aquafina Bottled Water 20 oz US$2.59

Donatos Pizza Details

  • Service options

  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Drive-through
  • Takeaway
  • Dine-in
  • Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings

  • Late-night food
  • Organic dishes
  • Quick bite
  • Salad bar
  • Small plates
  • Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Seating
  • Table service
  • Amenities

  • Gender-neutral toilets
  • Toilet
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Quiet
  • Crowd

  • Groups
  • Payments

  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
  • Children

  • Good for kids
  • High chairs
  • Parking

  • Free of charge street parking
  • Free parking lot
  • Parking

Donatos Pizza Photos

Donatos Pizza Picture 1Donatos Pizza Picture 2Donatos Pizza Picture 3Donatos Pizza Picture 4Donatos Pizza Picture 5Donatos Pizza Picture 6Donatos Pizza Picture 7Donatos Pizza Picture 8Donatos Pizza Picture 9Donatos Pizza Picture 10

Donatos Pizza Location

Donatos Pizza

5388 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

Donatos Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★3.7 from 293 user reviews.

drive thrusubspriceswindowcouplepepperonilettuce30 minutesitalian dressingbanana peppers

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More Best Restaurants Near Me

  • Greek ExpressGreek Express4.0 (926 reviews)

    5328 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • Lieu's Asian CuisineLieu's Asian Cuisine4.0 (190 reviews)

    5320 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • Iron Grill BBQ & DinnerIron Grill BBQ & Dinner4.0 (1535 reviews)

    5295 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • Villa Nova RistoranteVilla Nova Ristorante4.0 (3247 reviews)

    5545 N High St, Columbus, OH 43085, USA

  • El ConquistadorEl Conquistador0.0 (0 reviews)

    5225 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • Over The CounterOver The Counter4.0 (794 reviews)

    5596 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, USA

  • Modern Southern Table (High St.)Modern Southern Table (High St.)4.0 (10 reviews)

    5179 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • Taco BellTaco Bell3.0 (684 reviews)

    5152 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • Arby'sArby's3.0 (552 reviews)

    5150 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • Raising Cane's Chicken FingersRaising Cane's Chicken Fingers4.0 (1707 reviews)

    5132 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • LongHorn SteakhouseLongHorn Steakhouse4.0 (307 reviews)

    5091 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • East Coast PizzeriaEast Coast Pizzeria4.0 (412 reviews)

    5060 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Trending Bites & Banter Posts