Gatto's Pizza

- 3420 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214

When it comes to finding a truly great pizza in Columbus, Ohio, locals know that tradition and quality are key. Gatto's Pizza is a name that has been part of the city's culinary fabric for years, and for good reason. After moving from their original home on High Street to their current location on Indianola Avenue, Gatto's has continued to deliver the same high-quality, delicious pizza that has made them a beloved institution. This isn't just another pizza joint; it’s a place where history, community, and fantastic food come together.

For many Columbus residents, Gatto's represents the gold standard of classic, tavern-style pizza. The kind of pizza that brings back memories and creates new ones with every bite. The secret to their success is a simple, yet powerful, commitment to using the best ingredients. From the fresh-made dough to the distinctive, in-house-made sausage, every element of their pizza is crafted with care. This dedication to quality is what makes their pies stand out and has earned them a reputation for being one of the top five best pizzas in Columbus.

The new location on Indianola Avenue has only enhanced the Gatto’s experience. While they’ve moved, the heart and soul of the restaurant remain the same. The new space is decorated with a "fascinating array of old pictures detailing their history," which adds a layer of character and charm that is unique to Gatto's. It's a place where you can not only enjoy an incredible meal but also get a glimpse into the rich history of a family business that has been serving the community for decades.

One of the most praised aspects of Gatto's Pizza is their crust. Customers rave about its quality, with many claiming it can "stack up against anyone in the business." The thin, crispy, tavern-style crust is the perfect foundation for their fresh toppings, including the "real deal pepperoni" and their famous in-house-made sausage. It’s this combination of classic technique and top-tier ingredients that makes Gatto’s a can't-miss destination for any pizza lover in the Columbus area.

Gatto's Pizza is conveniently located at 3420 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214, USA. This location places it in the heart of a vibrant community, making it easily accessible for residents of Clintonville and the surrounding neighborhoods. The move to Indianola Avenue has allowed the restaurant to continue serving its loyal customer base while also attracting new patrons who appreciate its local charm and fantastic food.

The Indianola Avenue location is easily reachable by car, and its position on a major thoroughfare means it's simple to find. For locals, it's a familiar landmark that serves as a go-to spot for a delicious meal. While parking can sometimes require a bit of patience in busy urban areas, the payoff is well worth the effort. The restaurant's accessibility, combined with its reputation for amazing food, makes it a prime choice for dinner, a casual lunch, or a quick takeout order.

Gatto's Pizza offers several services to ensure that every customer can enjoy their delicious food, whether they're dining in or taking it home.

• Dine-In: The new location provides a welcoming and special environment for customers to sit down and enjoy their meal. The historical photos add to the unique atmosphere, making it more than just a place to eat. It's an experience.
• Takeout: For those who prefer to enjoy their pizza at home, Gatto's offers quick and efficient takeout. The food is so good that, as one customer noted, it "didn’t even make it to the final destination," a testament to its deliciousness.
• Delivery: As a modern pizza place, Gatto's likely offers delivery through their own service or third-party apps, making it even more convenient for customers to get their favorite pizza without leaving the comfort of their home.
• Menu Variety: While their pizza is the main attraction, they also offer other items like a "salad and homemade dressing," providing a well-rounded meal option for those who want more than just a pie.

What truly makes Gatto's Pizza a standout in the Columbus food scene are its unique features and highlights.

• Signature Tavern-Style Pizza: This classic style is a favorite among locals. The thin, crispy crust and square-cut slices are a hallmark of this type of pizza, and Gatto's executes it to perfection.
• Homemade Sausage: One of their most distinctive and praised features is their "unbelievable" sausage, which is made in-house. This dedication to crafting their own ingredients sets them apart from most other pizzerias.
• High-Quality Ingredients: From the fresh, delicious crust to the "real deal pepperoni" and fresh vegetables, Gatto's commitment to using the best ingredients is evident in every bite.
• Historical and Unique Ambiance: The new location is decorated with old pictures detailing the restaurant's history. This gives the place a special and authentic feel, making it a unique dining experience.
• Consistency: Customers have noted that Gatto’s has been "consistently crushing it" since their move. This reliability is a key factor in building and maintaining a loyal customer base.
• Famous Salad and Dressing: The recommendation to "start with the salad and homemade dressing" shows that their menu extends beyond just great pizza, with other items that are just as delicious and well-regarded.

To experience Gatto's Pizza for yourself, you can visit their location or call to place an order.

Address: 3420 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

Phone: (614) 263-3737

Gatto's Pizza is perfectly suited for locals because it embodies the best of what a community restaurant should be. It's a place with a rich history, a commitment to quality, and a welcoming atmosphere. For Columbus residents, Gatto's isn't just a place to get pizza; it's a local landmark that has served generations. The consistent quality and unique, homemade ingredients make it a reliable choice for any occasion, whether it’s a family dinner, a casual get-together with friends, or a simple night in.

Supporting a place like Gatto's means supporting a business that has deep roots in the community. Their dedication to using homemade ingredients, like their distinctive sausage, shows a level of passion and pride that is hard to find in larger chains. This makes Gatto's not only a great place to eat but also a local gem to be cherished and supported. So, next time you’re in the mood for some of the best tavern-style pizza in the city, head over to Indianola Avenue and experience the tradition and flavor of Gatto's Pizza. You'll understand why it's a local favorite.

Gatto's Pizza

3420 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214, USA