Brunch & Snack Chat
Brunch & Snack ChatBites & BanterBest Restaurants Near Me
Ohio

Brunch & Snack ChatBest Restaurants Near MeNew YorkNew York CountyNew YorkBest Restaurants in 5th AvenueIl Pesce
Il Pesce ico

Il Pesce
- 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010

Italian restaurant, Seafood restaurant ★3.0·$$$

200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

3.0
During a meeting near the Flatiron District, I decided to revisit Eataly and stopped by II Pesce for lunch. Located on the ground floor, the restaurant is bustling with food traffic, so it’s not the best spot if you’re looking for an intimate or quiet dining experience. That said, the food was decent—nothing extraordinary, but solid and enjoyable. The service was friendly and efficient, matching the casual vibe of the place. Overall, it’s a good option for a quick meal if you’re in the area, but don’t expect a standout culinary experience. - Alan Tan
Il Pesce Overview Intro Menu Detail Photos Location Reviews

Il Pesce Introduce

Il Pesce: A Coastal Italian Escape in the Heart of Manhattan

Il Pesce, Italian for "The Fish," is a culinary gem nestled within the lively Eataly Flatiron marketplace. This is a destination for anyone seeking a true taste of Italy's coastal cuisine right in the middle of New York City. The restaurant is a celebration of fresh, high-quality seafood, prepared with the simple yet elegant techniques of Italian cooking. It stands out by bringing the freshness and authenticity of a seaside trattoria to a bustling urban setting.

The atmosphere at Il Pesce is both casual and vibrant, reflecting the energy of the surrounding Eataly market. While it may not be the quietest spot for an intimate dinner, it offers a dynamic and engaging dining experience. Guests can watch as chefs prepare dishes, surrounded by the sights and sounds of a genuine Italian food hall. This setup contributes to a unique ambiance that is perfect for a lively lunch or a relaxed dinner. For New Yorkers and tourists alike, Il Pesce provides a chance to savor authentic Italian flavors, from the sea to the plate, in a setting that feels both special and accessible.


Location and Accessibility

Il Pesce is located at 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA, as a part of the iconic Eataly Flatiron. This central location in the Flatiron District is a major draw, placing it within easy reach of numerous subway lines and bus routes. The restaurant's position within Eataly makes it a convenient and well-known destination, a natural meeting point for locals and a must-visit for tourists exploring the area.

The establishment is committed to providing a comfortable experience for all guests. The venue offers a wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, ensuring that everyone can dine with ease. The open layout and modern design of Eataly contribute to a smooth and hassle-free visit. The location's proximity to Madison Square Park and other Flatiron landmarks also makes it a great stop to refuel during a day of sightseeing or shopping.


Services Offered

Il Pesce provides a variety of services to make the dining experience convenient and enjoyable.

  • Dine-in: Guests can enjoy the full menu and vibrant atmosphere by dining in at the restaurant's dedicated seating area.

  • Takeout: For those who wish to enjoy their meal elsewhere, the restaurant offers a convenient takeout service.

  • Reservations: Il Pesce accepts reservations, which is a great option for planning a visit and ensuring a table during busy times, as the restaurant can get quite crowded.

  • Table Service: The restaurant offers a traditional table service, allowing guests to relax and be served by the knowledgeable staff.

These services, combined with its location within Eataly, make it a flexible dining option for a range of needs, from a quick solo lunch to a planned group dinner.


Features and Highlights

Il Pesce is known for several key features that set it apart and make it a notable destination in the city's Italian dining scene.

  • Focus on Fresh Seafood: As its name suggests, the main highlight is the fresh and authentic Italian seafood. The menu is a celebration of the sea, with a variety of dishes that showcase the quality of the ingredients.

  • Great Wine List: The restaurant boasts a strong wine list, with an extensive selection of Italian wines by the glass and by the bottle, which are carefully chosen to complement the seafood-heavy menu. This makes it a great spot for wine enthusiasts.

  • Fast and Efficient Service: Despite the bustling environment of Eataly, Il Pesce is known for its fast and friendly service, ensuring that guests can enjoy a high-quality meal even on a tight schedule.

  • Cozy and Trendy Atmosphere: The ambiance is often described as a perfect blend of casual, cozy, and trendy. While it can be noisy due to its location, the lively environment contributes to a unique and memorable dining experience.

  • Authentic Italian Flavors: The dishes are prepared with authentic Italian techniques, providing a genuine taste of coastal Italian cuisine. The commitment to simple, bold ingredients is evident in every plate.

  • Ideal for Solo Dining: The fast service and casual, counter-style seating make Il Pesce a great option for solo diners who want to enjoy a quick and delicious meal without a formal setting.

These highlights collectively create a dining experience that is both high-quality and approachable, making it a favorite for many.


Contact Information

For more information about Il Pesce or to make a reservation, you can contact them using the following details:

  • Address: 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Phone: (212) 229-2560

The staff is ready to assist you and provide any information you may need to plan your visit.


What is Worth Choosing

Il Pesce is an excellent choice for anyone in New York City looking for a dining experience that combines high-quality seafood with an authentic Italian feel. What makes it particularly worth choosing is its specialization. Unlike many other Italian restaurants that offer a broad menu, Il Pesce focuses on what it does best: fresh, expertly prepared seafood. The menu offers a variety of dishes that showcase this expertise, from the Branzino alla Griglia to the Fritto Misto alla Ligure. The restaurant’s "crudo bar" is another major draw, allowing guests to sample fresh, raw fish prepared in the classic Italian style.

While a review noted that the food is "decent but not extraordinary," this perspective can be seen as part of the restaurant's appeal. The focus is on clean, simple flavors that let the quality of the fish shine through, rather than complex or overly sauced dishes. This is a hallmark of authentic Italian seafood cuisine. The lively and bustling atmosphere, while not for those seeking quiet intimacy, is perfect for a casual and fun meal. It’s a great place to feel the energy of Eataly and the city. The extensive wine list is also a major plus, with a wide selection of Italian whites and reds that pair perfectly with the menu. For a refreshing experience, their "Just Chilled" section with a curated list of chilled wines is a perfect escape from the summer heat.

In conclusion, Il Pesce is worth choosing for its dedication to authentic Italian seafood, its high-quality ingredients, and its lively, casual atmosphere. It's a fantastic option for a lunch or dinner that feels both satisfying and refreshingly simple. For a genuine taste of Italy's coast in the middle of New York, Il Pesce is a top contender.

Il Pesce Menu

  • Prosciutto Fest

    Celebrate the kings of prosciutti. JUst Chilled: Summer the Italian way. A delicacy prized across Italy, Culatello di Zibello is a rare Italian salumi from the province of Parma. Boneless pork is seasoned with salt and pepper, wrapped in twine, and slowly aged in cold, humid air, resulting in a distinctive sweet and fragrant flavor

  • Culatello $19.00

    Culatello di Zibello, Black Mission Figs, Chicory, Pecorino Romano DOP. Suggested Wine Pairing: Trento DOC Brut NV | Cantine Ferrari | Trentino Alto Adige - $16/gl, $56/btl

  • Calabria

    Take a quick trip to southern italy & discover Calabria. Located at the tip of the peninsula, Calabria is an ancient Italian region that ranges from sunny beaches to mountain peaks. This rich landscape creates a vibrant cuisine based on simple but bold ingredients. Find a selected Calabrian wine on the back!

  • Panino con Pescato del Giorno $17.00

    Market fish, housemade classic baguette, calabrian chile aioli, radish, arugula

  • Just Chilled

    Summer the Italian way. Just in time for summer, indulge in our sommelier's selection of chilled wines—a perfect way to escape the heat! Shop Our Selection of Chilled Wines at Eataly Vino on 23rd Street

  • Lambrusco Grasparossa 2017 La Battagliola | Emilia-Romagna $12.00
  • Chardonnay "Orsone" 2016 Bastianich | Friuli $11.00
  • "Pithos Bianco" (Grecanico) Azienda Agricola COS | Sicilia $18.00
  • "Rosa Vittoria" 2016 (Nebbiolo) Castello di Santa Vittoria | Piemonte $14.00
  • Frappato 2015 Portelli | Sicilia $13.00
  • Crudo Bar

  • Crudo Bar

    So fresh, we literally just finished writing our oysters, pesce marinato, and crudo selection of the day. Ask your server for details!

  • Verdure

  • Caprese e Acciughe Marinate $16.00

    Housemade Mozzarella, Heirloom Tomatoes, Marinated Anchovies, Basil, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

  • Insalata Tricolore $14.00

    Arugula, Radicchio, Endive, Parmigiano Reggiano Dop®, Aceto Tradizionale

  • Insalatone del Giorno $16.00

    Mixed greens with quinoa and seasonal vegetables

  • Insalata di Cesare $16.00

    grilled greens, anchovy, parmigiano reggiano DOP, egg, lemon, breadcrumbs

  • Carpaccio di Zucchine $14.00

    summer Squash, Pine Nuts, Caprino Cheese, Basil, Mint, Lemon, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

  • Pasta

  • Gnocchetti Sardi con Gamberetti alla Genovese $18.00

    Gnocchetti Sardi, Rock Shrimp, Basil Pesto, Lemon, Breadcrumb, Chili extra virgin olive Oil

  • Lasagna di Fagiolini $18.00

    Housemade lasagna with basil and haricot verts pesto, bechamel, parmigiano Reggiano® DOP

  • Fregola con Mais e Tartufi $24.00

    Fregola, Corn, Red Onion, Pecorino Romano dop, urbani Summer Black Truffles

  • Piccoli Piatti

    Meant for sharing

  • Cozze $17.00

    Moosabec Mussels, Cherry Tomato, White Wine, Red Onion, Garlic, Chili Flake, Oregano

  • Fritto Misto alla Ligure $24.00

    Assorted Fried Seafood Ligurian Style

  • Zuppa di Pesce $21.00

    amalfi-style Fish Soup with Gulf Shrimp, market fish and Spicy mutti Tomato sauce Crostino

  • Burrata $17.00

    Liuzzi Burrata, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Grilled Housemade Bread

  • Sarde al Forno $17.00

    Roasted Sardines, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Lemon, Oregano, Thyme

  • Granchio $22.00

    Soft Shell Crab, Calabrian Aioli, Cherry Tomato, Oregano

  • Piatti

  • Polpo alla Griglia $28.00

    grilled octopus, Marinated Peppers, Potatoes, Mixed Herbs

  • Branzino alla Griglia $31.00

    Grilled Branzino, Mountain Sweet Berry Farm Spigarello, Chili Pepper

  • Tagliata di Manzo $27.00

    Grilled hanger steak, salsa verde, potatoes

  • Pesce Spada alla Griglia $26.00

    Swordfish, tomato, olive, couscous, salmoriglio

  • Salmone alla Piastra $24.00

    Crispy skin Skuna salmon, Green Beans, Romano Beans, Red Onion, Barolo Vinaigrette

  • Platessa alla Piastra

    Local Flounder, Mixed Nuts, Tarragon, Lemon

  • Contorni

  • Patate $8.00

    Crispy Fingerling Potato, Rosemary

  • Zucchine $8.00

    summer Squash, Hazelnuts, Oregano, Lemon

  • Carciofi Fritti $8.00

    Fried Artichokes, Mint, Pecorino Romano DOP

  • Melanzane Marinate $8.00

    Eggplant, Red Wine Vinegar, Honey

  • Spumanti | Sparkling

  • Prosecco NV Flor | Veneto $11.00
  • "Bollicine Rose" NV (Chardonnay, Pinot Nero) Serafini & Vidotto | Veneto $13.00
  • Trento DOC Brut NV Cantine Ferrari | Trentino-Alto Adige $16.00
  • Moscato d'Asti 2015 Brandini | Piemonte $11.00
  • Lambrusco Grasparossa 2017 La Battagliola | Emilia-Romagna $12.00
  • Bianchi | Whites

  • "Vespa" Bianco 2015 (Chardonnay, Sauvignon Blanc, Picolit) Bastianich | Friuli $18.00
  • Chardonnay "Orsone" 2016 Bastianich | Friuli $11.00
  • Roero Arneis "Pradalupo" 2015 Fontanafredda | Piemonte $16.00
  • Fiano di Avellino, Guido Marsella | Campania $13.00
  • Etna Bianco 2017 (Carricante) Tornatore | Sicilia $14.00
  • Arancio | Orange

  • "Pithos Bianco" 2016 (Grecanico) Azienda Agricola COS | Sicilia $18.00
  • Rosati | Roses

  • Cirò Rosé "Pescanera" 2017 (Gaglioppo) Ippolito 1845 | Calabria $12.00

    Take a quick trip to southern italy & discover Calabria. Located at the tip of the peninsula, Calabria is an ancient Italian region that ranges from sunny beaches to mountain peaks. This rich landscape creates a vibrant cuisine based on simple but bold ingredients

  • "Rosa Vittoria" 2016 (Nebbiolo) Castello di Santa Vittoria | Piemonte $14.00
  • Rossi | Reds

  • Dolcetto di Dogliani 2014 San Romano | Piemonte $13.00

    Vino Libero wines are made without herbicides, chemical fertilizers and with a minimal amount of added sulfites. For more info, visit our wine shop on 23rd Street

  • Barbera "Rossore" 2014 Iuli | Piemonte $14.00
  • Sangiovese "I Perazzi" 2016 La Mozza | Toscana $11.00
  • Chianti Classico 2014 (Sangiovese, Merlot) Certosa di Belriguardo | Toscana $15.00
  • Frappato 2015 Portelli | Sicilia $13.00
  • Grandi Rossi | Big Reds

  • "Vespa" Rosso 2013 (Merlot, Refosco, Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc) Bastianich | Friuli $20.00
  • Barolo 2013 Mirafiore | Piemonte $24.00
  • "Lucente" 2016 (Sangiovese, Merlot) Tenuta Luce | Toscana $18.00
  • Rossi | Reds

  • Frescobaldi "Castelgiocondo" Brunello 2012 $30.00
  • Allegrini "La Poja" 2010 (Corvina) $23.00
  • Casale del Giglio "Mater Matuta" 2013 (Syrah, Petit Verdot) $17.00
  • Alla Spina | On Tap

  • Nastro Azzurro, Peroni 5.1˚ ABV (Pilsner) $7.00
  • SeaQuench Ale, Dogfish Head 4.9˚ ABV (Session Ale) $10.00
  • In Bottiglia | Bottled

  • Bionda, Menabrea 5.0˚ ABV (Golden Lager) $7.00
  • Ambrata, Menabrea 5.0˚ ABV (Amber Lager) $8.00
  • Isaac, Baladin 5.0˚ ABV (Italian Blanche) $12.00
  • Nora, Baladin 6.8˚ ABV (Spiced Beer) $11.00
  • Sidro, Baladin 4.5˚ ABV (Cider) $12.00
  • La Rossa, Moretti 7.2˚ ABV (Doppelbock) $7.00
  • 60 Minute IPA, Dogfish Head 6.0˚ ABV $9.00
  • 90 Minute, Dogfish Head 9.0˚ ABV (IPA) $9.00
  • Festina Pêche, Dogfish Head 4.5˚ ABV (Berliner Weisse) $9.00
  • Mixed Media, Dogfish Head 7.5˚ ABV (Beer-Wine Hybrid) $10.00
  • Duchessa, Birra del Borgo 5.8˚ ABV (Saison) $12.00
  • Rossi | Reds

  • Barolo "Cascina Nuova" 2012 Elvio Cogno | Piemonte $140.00
  • Barbaresco "Rabaja" 2012 Bruno Rocca | Piemonte $160.00
  • Barbaresco 2005 Gaja | Piemonte $438.00
  • Schioppettino 2006 Ronchi di Cialla | Friuli $140.00
  • Amarone 2013 Allegrini | Veneto $122.00
  • Sforzato di Valtellina 2015 Nino Negri | Lombardia $108.00
  • Chianti Classico Riserva "Marchese Antinori" 2014 Antinori | Toscana $105.00
  • Montepulciano d'Abruzzo 2001 Emidio Pepe | Abruzzo $524.00
  • "Dedicato a Walter" 2012 (Cabernet Franc) Poggio al Tesoro | Toscana $150.00
  • Tignanello 2014 Antinori | Toscana $273.00
  • Sagrantino di Montefalco "Collepiano" 2009 Arnaldo Capari | Umbria $116.00
  • "Ripe del Falco" Cirò Classico 2007 (Gaglioppo) Ippolito | Calabria $135.00
  • Primitivo "17" 2012 Polvanera | Puglia $94.00
  • "Mille e una Notte" 2009 (Nero d'Avola) Donnafugata | Sicilia $178.00
  • Bianchi | Whites

  • Friulano "Plus" 2011 Bastianich | Friuli $105.00
  • "Terre Alte" 2013 Friulano, Pinot Bianco, Sauvignon, Livio Felluga | Friuli $150.00
  • "Cervaro della Sala" 2015 (Chardonnay, Grechetto) Castello della Sala | Umbria $116.00
  • "Rossj-Bass" 2015 (Chardonnay, Sauvignon) Gaja | Piemonte $158.00
  • Spumanti | Sparkling

  • Trento DOC "Perlè" 2009 Cantine Ferrari | Trentino-Alto Adige $87.00
  • Franciacorta Brut "Cabochon" 2005 Monte Rossa | Lombardia $150.00
  • Trento DOC "Perlè Rose" 2008 Cantine Ferrari | Trentino-Alto Adige $161.00
  • I Volumi Bollati | Fontanafredda

  • Barbera "Briccotondo" 2010 Piemonte $28.00
  • Barolo "Serralunga" 2007 Piemonte $57.00
  • Barolo "Serralunga" 2011 Piemonte $108.00
  • Housemade Cocktails

  • Aperol Spritz $16.00

    Aperol, Flor Prosecco, Splash of Club Soda

  • Canella Cocktails

  • Peach Bellini $12.00

    Peach Purée and Prosecco

  • Blood Orange Mimosa $12.00

    Blood Orange Juice and Prosecco

  • Bibite Tutte Naturali | All Natural Drinks

  • Lurisia Sodas $4.80

    Aranciata, Acqua Tonica di Chinotto, Chinotto, or Gazzosa

  • Baladin $5.80

    Spuma Nera, Cola, Ginger, Cedrata

  • GUS Sodas $3.80

    Dry Cola, Dry Blackberry, Dry Ginger Ale

  • Molecola Soda $4.20

    Italian Cola

  • San Pellegrino Sodas $5.80

    Grapefruit or Blood Orange

  • Niasca Portofino Sparkling Limonata $5.80
  • Niasca Portofino Mandarinata $5.80
  • Niasca Portofino Festivo $5.80
  • Small Lurisia Classic Water $4.00

    Sparkling or Still

  • Large Lurisia Classic Water $6.00

    Sparkling or Still

  • Achillea Fruit Juice $3.80

    Apricot, Pear, Pineapple

  • Small Plain-T Iced Black Tea $3.80
  • Large Plain-T Iced Black Tea $12.80
  • Antipasti

    Choose one:

  • Ostriche

    3 oysters on the half shell

  • Insalata di Cesare

    grilled greens, anchovy, parmigiano Reggiano DOP, egg, lemon, breadcrumbs

  • Pesce Crudo

    Italian-style sashimi finished with ligurian extra virgin olive oil

  • Piatti

    Choose one:

  • Cozze

    Moosabec Mussels Cherry Tomato, White Wine, Red Onion, Garlic, Chili Flake, Oregano

  • Panino con Pescato del Giorno

    market fish, housemade classic baguette, Calabrian Chili aioli, radish, arugula

  • Pesce Azzurro con Pesche

    Seared local fish with Braised Radicchio, Peaches, Balsamic Vinegar

  • Main

    Kids Eat Free. Choice of:

  • Pesce Fritto

    Ligurian Style Fried Fish with Tomato Sauce

  • Nutella e Banana

    Toasted Housemade Rustic Bread Drizzled with Nutella and Bananas

  • Gnocchi

    Housemade Potato Gnocchi with Butter and Parmiggiano Reggiano®

  • Gnocchi with Tomato Sauce

Il Pesce Details

  • Service options

  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Great wine list
  • Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Hard liquor
  • Healthy options
  • Small plates
  • Wine
  • Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Dessert
  • Table service
  • Amenities

  • Bar onsite
  • Restroom
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Trendy
  • Crowd

  • Tourists
  • Planning

  • Accepts reservations
  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards

Il Pesce Photos

Il Pesce Picture 1Il Pesce Picture 2Il Pesce Picture 3Il Pesce Picture 4Il Pesce Picture 5Il Pesce Picture 6Il Pesce Picture 7Il Pesce Picture 8Il Pesce Picture 9Il Pesce Picture 10

Il Pesce Location

Il Pesce

200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

Il Pesce Reviews

An average rating of ★3.8 from 172 user reviews.

pricewineeatalyappetizeroctopusclamslemonmain coursecrudomarket

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More Best Restaurants Near Me

  • ManzoManzo4.0 (119 reviews)

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Farmer's FridgeFarmer's Fridge0.0 (0 reviews)

    Located on the 10th floor in the vending area, 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Rosticceria & PaniniRosticceria & Panini3.0 (35 reviews)

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Il PastaioIl Pastaio4.0 (113 reviews)

    210 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • I Salumi I FormaggiI Salumi I Formaggi3.0 (3 reviews)

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • SERRA by BirreriaSERRA by Birreria3.0 (2982 reviews)

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Street food cartStreet food cart0.0 (0 reviews)

    5th Ave &, W 23 St, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • La Pizza & La PastaLa Pizza & La Pasta4.0 (1052 reviews)

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • La focacceriaLa focacceria3.0 (5 reviews)

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Bar Milano by EatalyBar Milano by Eataly4.0 (191 reviews)

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Eataly NYC FlatironEataly NYC Flatiron4.0 (9667 reviews)

    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Pasha's Halal Food (cart)Pasha's Halal Food (cart)3.0 (22 reviews)

    02 W 23 St, New York, NY 10010, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Trending Bites & Banter Posts