Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop

- 3179 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43204

For decades, when residents of Columbus, Ohio, talk about truly authentic and traditional pizza, Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop often comes up in conversation. This establishment, nestled on Sullivant Avenue, has been serving the community with its distinctive pies since 1969. Joseppi's is more than just a pizza restaurant; it's a piece of local history, a family-owned tradition deeply rooted in Columbus’s west side. The commitment to crafting pizzas with authentic recipes and quality ingredients, many made from scratch, has earned it a loyal following and a reputation as a beloved neighborhood spot.

What truly sets Joseppi's Pizza apart in the competitive Ohio pizza landscape is its dedication to foundational quality. Patrons consistently rave about their signature "Topper" pizza, which features a freshly baked, crispy thin crust, perfectly melted cheese, and a "decent tomato sauce" that forms the perfect base. The Topper specifically boasts Old World pepperoni, provolone, and grated Parmesan, creating a flavor combination that has been perfected over generations. This attention to detail, from the dough mixed fresh in the shop daily to the homemade sausage and signature sauce, ensures that every bite is a celebration of flavor, resonating with those who appreciate classic pizza artistry.

Beyond the signature pizzas, Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop offers a broader menu designed to satisfy various cravings, reflecting its role as a versatile local eatery. From hearty pasta dinners like their highly-praised baked spaghetti with meatballs to a wide selection of oven-baked subs and strombolis, the establishment caters to diverse tastes. This variety, combined with its long-standing presence and commitment to quality, makes Joseppi's a staple for many families and individuals in the Hilltop area and beyond. It’s the kind of place where tradition and hard work shine through in every dish, maintaining its status as a cornerstone of Columbus’s culinary scene and a truly suitable choice for locals seeking a genuine pizza experience.

Conveniently located in a well-established area of Columbus, Ohio, Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop can be found at 3179 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43204, USA. This address places the pizzeria within the heart of the Hilltop neighborhood, a community that values its local businesses and traditional establishments. Its position on Sullivant Avenue ensures it is easily accessible for residents within the Hilltop area, as well as those in neighboring communities.

The Hilltop location makes Joseppi's Pizza a practical choice for a wide array of patrons across Columbus. For those driving, there is typically parking available at or near the establishment. The restaurant itself provides a clean room with several seats, offering a comfortable space for customers who wish to dine in. However, it's particularly well-suited for takeout and delivery, catering to the busy lives of Ohio residents who might prefer to enjoy their pizza at home. Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop offers delivery services to several areas, including the Hilltop, Downtown Columbus, Grandview, Valleyview, Franklinton, Riverbend, Holt-Alkire, and Marble Cliff, significantly extending its reach and convenience for local users.

The ease of access and wide delivery radius are significant advantages for Joseppi's, ensuring that its delicious pizzas and other menu items are readily available to a broad customer base in the Columbus region. Whether you're a long-time resident of the Hilltop or simply looking for a quality pizza delivery option in these surrounding areas, Joseppi's Pizza provides a straightforward and convenient solution. This accessibility, combined with its commitment to quality food, solidifies its position as a key local pizzeria within the Ohio culinary landscape.

• Thin Crust Pizzas: Specializes in freshly baked, crispy thin-crust pizzas available in various sizes, from personal small to large and even 28" party sizes.
• Signature Topper Pizza: Features a highly popular "Topper" pizza with Old World pepperoni, provolone, and grated Parmesan.
• Customizable Pizzas: Offers a "Build Your Own Pizza" option with a choice of 18 toppings, including various meats, vegetables, and cheeses.
• Detroit Style Pizza: Provides an 8x10 Detroit-style pizza with a unique caramelized cheese crust and a premium artisan blend of Wisconsin Brick Cheese.
• Pasta Dinners: Serves classic Italian dinners such as Lasagna, Spaghetti and Meatballs, Spaghetti and Meat Sauce, and Baked Spaghetti, often served with garlic bread or breadsticks.
• Oven Baked Subs: A selection of oven-baked subs, including Italian, Meatball, Crispy Chicken, Ham & Cheese, and Pizza Sub.
• Strombolis and Calzones: Offers hand-tossed Strombolis and calzones, with various fillings and a choice of crusts, served with dipping sauces.
• Appetizers & Sides: Includes items like garlic bread (plain or cheesy), mozzarella sticks, chicken wings, fried mushrooms, cheese sticks, and French fries.
• Salads: Features a variety of salads such as Garden, Chef, Grilled Chicken, Crispy Chicken, and Antipasta.
• Delivery Service: Provides delivery to Hilltop, Downtown Columbus, Grandview, Valleyview, Franklinton, Riverbend, Holt-Alkire, and Marble Cliff.
• Takeout Options: Customers can pick up their orders for convenient at-home dining.
• Dine-In Seating: A clean dining room with several seats is available for those who wish to eat on-site.

• Legendary Signature Topper Pizza: Highly praised for its "Topper" pizza, noted for its crispy thin crust, great cheese, decent tomato sauce, and "amazing" taste, especially the Old World pepperoni.
• Homemade Dough and Sauce: Joseppi's prides itself on making everything from scratch daily, including their dough, signature sauce, and even their own sausage, ensuring fresh and authentic flavors.
• Long-Standing Columbus Tradition: Operating since 1969, Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop is a family-owned business with a deep connection to the Hilltop community, offering a taste of local history.
• Award-Winning Quality: Recognized locally and nationally, having earned accolades like the Columbus Pizza Challenge Grand Champion and Gold Medal honors at the Grove City Pizza Olympics.
• Delicious Baked Spaghetti: A fan favorite, the baked spaghetti (with meatballs, cheddar, and provolone cheeses) is often highlighted as a must-try dish.
• Generous Portions: Reviewers often note the generous quantity of food, especially with items like the chef salad and spaghetti dinners.
• Wide Variety of Menu Items: Beyond pizza, the extensive menu includes subs, calzones, pasta dinners, salads, and appetizers, catering to diverse tastes and meal occasions.
• Clean Dining Environment: The restaurant space is described as clean, providing a comfortable setting for dine-in customers.

To enjoy the traditional and acclaimed pizzas from Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop, or for any inquiries, here’s how you can get in touch:

Address: 3179 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43204, USA

Phone: (614) 272-2724

For mobile users or those dialing internationally, the mobile phone number is: +1 614-272-2724

For the residents of Columbus, Ohio, particularly those in the Hilltop area, Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop is much more than just a pizza place; it's a deeply embedded part of the community's culinary fabric. Its suitability for locals stems from a rich blend of tradition, consistent quality, and a menu that caters to diverse family needs, making it a reliable and cherished choice for any occasion.

One of the most compelling reasons Joseppi's resonates with locals is its authenticity and heritage. Operating since 1969, it stands as a testament to enduring quality, with many customers having grown up savoring its pies. The commitment to making dough, sauce, and even sausage from scratch daily ensures a freshness and flavor profile that mass-produced alternatives simply cannot replicate. This dedication to traditional methods, coupled with accolades like the Columbus Pizza Challenge Grand Champion, speaks volumes about its sustained excellence. For Ohioans who appreciate time-honored recipes and a genuine taste of local craftsmanship, Joseppi's offers an experience that feels both familiar and exceptional.

Furthermore, the variety on Joseppi's menu makes it an incredibly versatile option for local families and individuals. While their signature "Topper" pizza, with its crispy thin crust and perfectly balanced toppings, is a standout, the extensive offerings of Detroit-style pizzas, oven-baked subs, generous pasta dinners like their beloved baked spaghetti, and an array of appetizers ensure there's always something to satisfy every craving. This breadth of choice means that whether it's a quick weeknight dinner, a family gathering, or simply a craving for authentic Italian-American comfort food, Joseppi's has a delicious solution.

Finally, the practical aspects of Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop significantly enhance its appeal to the local community. Its accessible location on Sullivant Avenue, combined with a broad delivery area that spans key Columbus neighborhoods including Downtown, Grandview, and Franklinton, ensures convenience for a wide range of residents. While some individual experiences regarding service may vary, the overall sentiment points to a business that, for many, remains a go-to for its consistently high-quality food. For locals seeking a taste of Columbus tradition, a diverse menu of comforting classics, and the convenience of a neighborhood staple, Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop stands as a truly suitable and enduring choice in Ohio.

Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop

3179 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43204, USA