Norma Turtle Bay Introduce
Nestled in the vibrant Turtle Bay neighborhood of Midtown East, Norma Turtle Bay is a culinary sanctuary that brings the authentic flavors of Sicily to the bustling streets of New York City. More than just a pizza restaurant, Norma is a true Sicilian gem, celebrated for its commitment to traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients. This is a place where every dish tells a story, and a simple meal becomes a journey to the sun-drenched island of Sicily. From the moment you step inside, the cozy and charming atmosphere transports you away from the urban hustle, inviting you to relax and savor a truly genuine dining experience.
Norma Turtle Bay's menu is a testament to the richness and diversity of Sicilian cuisine. While their pizza is a major draw, the restaurant's identity is rooted in its full range of offerings, from small plates and fresh salads to hearty pasta dishes and main courses. The focus is on authentic, home-style cooking that honors tradition, as evidenced by their signature "Pasta alla Norma." For New Yorkers seeking an escape from the ordinary and a taste of true Italian heritage, Norma Turtle Bay offers a refreshing and delicious alternative to the typical pizza joint. As one satisfied customer noted, the food is so authentic it can make you feel like you're "back in Sicily." This deep connection to its culinary roots is what makes Norma a standout in the city's crowded restaurant scene.
Located at 930 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA, Norma Turtle Bay is perfectly situated for both local residents and those working or visiting in the area. Its Midtown East address places it conveniently close to major landmarks like the United Nations Headquarters and Grand Central Terminal. This prime location makes it an ideal spot for a business lunch, a post-work dinner, or a delightful meal during a day of sightseeing.
The restaurant's accessibility is a key highlight. It is easily reachable via multiple subway lines, with stops for the 4, 5, 6, 7, and S shuttle all within a reasonable walking distance. The area is also well-served by numerous bus routes, making public transportation a breeze. For those with special needs, Norma Turtle Bay offers a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that everyone can enjoy its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. The convenience of its location, combined with its cozy and casual vibe, makes it a go-to spot for groups, tourists, and solo diners alike.
Norma Turtle Bay provides a range of services designed to accommodate various dining preferences and needs.
Services Offered:
- Dine-in: Enjoy a full, sit-down meal in the restaurant's quaint and inviting seating area, which is known for its many seats despite being a cozy space.
- Takeout: For those on the go, the option to pick up an order allows you to enjoy their authentic Sicilian flavors at home or on the move.
- Delivery: Norma offers delivery services, including no-contact delivery, through various platforms, bringing their delicious food right to your doorstep with ease and safety.
- Seating and Reservations: The restaurant provides ample seating for its casual atmosphere, and the ability to make reservations can be a convenient option for planning a special dinner or for larger groups.
The features and highlights of Norma Turtle Bay are what truly set it apart as a premier Italian and Sicilian restaurant in NYC.
Features / Highlights:
- Authentic Sicilian Cuisine: From the Arancine to the Pasta alla Norma, the menu is a deep dive into genuine Sicilian flavors, with dishes that evoke a true sense of place and heritage.
- Diverse Offerings: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a wide range of options, including various pasta dishes, small plates, fresh salads, and exquisite desserts like the classic Cannoli Siciliani and Tiramisù.
- High-Quality Ingredients: The kitchen uses premium ingredients to craft each dish, ensuring an elevated dining experience. The use of buffalo mozzarella on the Pizza Regina is just one example of their commitment to quality.
- Extensive Wine List: The restaurant boasts a comprehensive selection of both red and white Italian wines, many of which are from Sicily, offering the perfect pairing for any meal.
- Family-Friendly Environment: With amenities like high chairs and a kid-friendly menu, Norma is a great spot for families looking for a delicious meal in a comfortable setting.
- Dog-Friendly Outdoor Seating: For those who want to dine with their furry friends, the option to have dogs in the outdoor seating area is a welcome highlight.
For more information, or to plan your visit, you can reach out to Norma Turtle Bay using the following contact information.
Contact Information:
- Address: 930 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA
- Phone: (212) 389-0089
- Mobile Phone: +1 212-389-0089
What is worth choosing at Norma Turtle Bay? It's the unique combination of authentic Sicilian food, a warm and inviting atmosphere, and a menu that goes far beyond the standard pizza joint. For locals and visitors alike, it offers a culinary experience that is both familiar and exciting. Unlike many restaurants that cater to a broad "Italian-American" palate, Norma's commitment to genuine Sicilian dishes provides a rare and rewarding experience. The pizza, as noted by customers, is excellent, with options like the Pizza Prosciutto & Rucola and Pizza 4 Formaggi standing out. However, the true value lies in exploring the entire menu, from the delicious Arancine to the expertly crafted pasta dishes. The wine list, with its emphasis on Sicilian wines, further enhances the authentic dining journey. This is a restaurant for people who appreciate quality, tradition, and a cozy place to share a great meal. Its popularity for lunch, dinner, and solo dining confirms its status as a versatile and beloved neighborhood spot that consistently delivers on its promise of an authentic and delicious taste of Sicily.
Norma Turtle Bay Food & drink
PICCOLI PIATTI
- Olive “Cunsate” $10.00
Mix marinated olives, garlic, oregano, celery, parsley
- Panelle $12.00
Fried chickpea & agli-oli’ sauce
- Bruschetta Classica $14.00
Roasted bread, garlic, extra v. olive oil, tomato, basil
- Burrata $24.00
Bread, imported burrata, arugula, olive oil
- Carciofo Ripieno $22.00
Whole artichoke stuffed with bread crumbs, parmesan, garlic, parsley
- Polpette Di Vitello $23.00
Organic veal meat-ball, tomato sauce, melted provolone cheese
- Involtini Di Melanzane $21.00
Baked eggplant “rollatini”stuffed with bread crumbs, Racine, pine nuts, anchovies and smoked provolone cheese
- Carpaccio Di Bresaola $20.00
Cured beef, lemon, arugula, shaved parmesan, extra v. olive oil
- Carpaccio Di Polipo $26.00
Mediterranean octopus carpaccio, with orange, fennel, moroccan olives salad and “salmoriglio” sauce
- Caprese Salad $23.00
Buffalo mozzarella, tomato, basil
- Caponata $16.00
Eggplant, celery, green olives, capers, onions and tomato in sweet and savor, crostini bread
- Crocchette Di Patate $11.00
- Plate Of Prosciutto Crudo Di Parma $24.00
- Ricotta Di Bufala Con Miele All'arancia $18.00
INSALATE
- Frutta Secca E Gorgonzola $18.00
Mixed salad, tomatoes, roasted peppers, gorgonzola cheese, mixed dried fruit, walnuts, balsamic dressing
- Insalata Di Finocchi Ed Arance $18.00
- Insalata Pantesca $22.00
Olive oil cured fatty tuna filet in extra v. olive oil, green beans, cherry tomato, capers, potato, Nocellara olives, red onions, celery, oregano, white wine vinaigrette
- Rucola E Parmigiano $16.00
Arugula, pear, caramelized walnuts, shaved Parmigiano, balsamic vinegar
PASTE ASCIUTTE
- Busiate Al Pesto Trapanese $26.00
Our imported from Trapani “Busiate Campo" pasta with“Trapanese” pesto: fresh tomato, organic basil, Sicilian garlic, Sicilian’s almond, “Nocellara” extra v. olive oil
- Busiate Con Pesto Di Pistacchi E Gamberi $28.00
- Caserecce Pesce Spada E Melanzane $29.00
- Couscous Con Pesce $32.00
Sicilian organic durum semola slowly steamed, and Sicilian fish broth, with: Branzino, cod, calamari, mussels ; Shrimp ,, cinnamon, tomato, almonds, parsley, flavored! Allergy Shell Fish !
- Fettuccine Funghi Porcini E Olio Tartufato $30.00
Home made fettuccine with sautéed fresh imported porcini
- Gnocchi Bolognese $26.00
Home made potato “Gnocchi” with pork and beef ragout
- Pasta "C'Anchova" $24.00
- Pasta Alla Norma $26.00
Gragnano’s paccheri with fresh tomato and garlic sauce, basil, eggplant, pecorino & ricotta salata cheese
- Tagliolini Al Ragu Di Agnello E Caprino $29.00
Home made spaghetti with braised lamb, served with crambled goat cheese
- Trenette Al Pomodoro $25.00
Home made spaghetti with fresh tomato, garlic, basil, parmigiano cheese
ARANCINE
- Arancina Norma $18.00
Tomato rice ball stuffed with eggplant, mozzarella, basil, served over ricotta sauce
- Arancina Ragu’ $18.00
Saffron rice ball stuffed with “Bolognese meat sauce”, green peas, mozzarella, served over tomato sauce
- Arancina Al Burro $18.00
Saffron rice ball stuffed with Italian prosciutto cotto, mozzarella, béchamel sauce
- Arancina Nero Seppia $18.00
Squid ink risotto rice ball filled w/ spicy shrimp & tomato ragu’
PASTE AL FORNO
- Anelletti Siciliani $32.00
“Ring”shaped pasta baked in wood oven, with beef ragù, green peas, eggplant, basil, Italian ham and pecorino cheese
- Pasta Con Sarde A Timballo $29.00
Durum flour “Spaghetti Setaro”, fresh Portuguese sardine, wild fennel, pine nuts, racine, saffron
- Lasagna Palermitana $28.00
Wide, flat-shaped pasta with, meat ragù, pork sausage, tomato sauce, mozzarella, light béchamel
Piatti Principali
- Cous Cous Con Pesce $32.00
- Fritto Misto $29.00
- Involtini Alla Siciliana $24.00
- Timballo Di Melanzane Alla Parmigiana $25.00
CABBUCI
- Cabbucio Cunzato $20.00
In vine tomatoes, anchovies, primo sale oregano, moroccan olives
- Cabbucio Caprese $20.00
Tomato, mozzarella, basil, prosciutto di parma, rucola, spicy mayo
- Cabbucio Porchetta $22.00
Our roasted porchetta, arugula, provolone cheese, spicy mayo
- Cabbucio Mufoletta $23.00
Italian prosciutto cotto, soppressata, mortadella, cured eggplant, green olive & dry tomato pate’, roasted peppers, provolone cheese
PIZZE
- Pizza Norma $22.00
Tomato, mozzarella, basil, eggplant, ricotta salata cheese
- Pizza Rianata $20.00
Fresh candy tomatoes, anchovies, garlic, parsley, pecorino cheese, oregano
- Pizza Margherita $18.00
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil
- Pizza Regina Con Bufala $26.00
Tomato sauce, bufalo mozzarella, cherry tomato, basil
- Pizza Napoletana $20.00
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, anchovies, oregano
- Pizza Capricciosa $28.00
Fresh candy tomatoes, mozzarella, ham, mushrooms, artichoke hearts moroccan olives, parsley
- Pizza Ortolana $20.00
Eggplants, mozzarella, roasted peppers, zucchini, mushrooms
- Pizza Cotto & Funghi $24.00
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, mushrooms, Italian prosciutto cotto
- Pizza Prosciutto & Rucola $28.00
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, shaved Parmigiano, arugula, Prosciutto di Parma 36 months aged
- Pizza Funghi & Porchetta $29.00
Our roasted porchetta, mozzarella, mix sautéed mushroom, provolone cheese, red onions
- Pizza 4 Formaggi $22.00
Mozzarella, gorgonzola, ricotta, stracchino cheese, basil
- Pizza Carrettiera $22.00
Our made sausage, mozzarella, broccoli rabe
- Pizza Diavola $26.00
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, Calabrese ‘Nduja, spicy salami, black olives, parsley
- Pizza Tonno $24.00
Cherry tomatoes, mozzarella ,olive oil cured tuna, onions, cappers, black olives, parsley, oregano
- Pizza Mortadella $28.00
Mortadella, mozzarella, pistachio & arugula pesto, stracciatella
- Pizza Bresaola $26.00
Cherry tomatoes, arugula, bresaola, stracciatella cheese
- Pizza Porcini $30.00
Fresh Italian porcini mushrooms, mozzarella, Caciocavallo Ragusano, lardo di Colonnata, red onions, truffle oil
DESSERT
- Cannoli Siciliani $12.00
Small cannoli stuffed with sheep milk ricotta and pistacchio
- Cassatella Con Ricotta $12.00
Deep fried sweet “ravioli” stuffed w/ricotta cheese & chocolate
- Cassatina Siciliana $13.00
Traditional little cake made with soft ricotta cheese, marzapane, candy fruit
- Pizza Alla Nutella $18.00
Pizza pie stuffed wit creamy Nutella (recommended for two)
- Tiramisu $12.00
Light ladyfinger infused with coffee, layered with mascarpone and topped with powdered cocoa
- Torta Cioccolato Senza Farina $12.00
Flowerless chocolate cake, whipped cream
- Torta Della Nonna $12.00
Shortcrust cake, stuffed with lemon creme and covered with toasted almonds and pine nuts
- Panettone Fiasconaro Classico Alla Malvasia Delle Lipari Passito D.O.C $68.00
- Panettone Al Pistacchio Di Sicilia Dolce E Gabbana Verde $109.00
- Panettone Fiasconaro Alle Nocciole Di Sicilia Con Crema Alla Manna Da Spalmare Dolce E Gabbana Rosa $72.00
- Tiramisù All’ Arancia Con Panettone E Crema Inglese $14.00
- Torroncini In Latta Dolce E Gabbana Nougats $38.00
- Pizza Alla Nutella Gluten Free $22.00
Vini Rossi - Bottiglia
- BLT Barone Di Serramarrocco,Sammarcello Perricone $122.00
- BTL Feudo Montoni, "Core" Perricone $74.00
- BTL Nero Di Serramarrocco Nero D'Avola $110.00
- BTL Barbazzale , Etna Rosso , Cottanera $59.00
- BTL Barone Di Villagrande, Etna Rosso $72.00
- BTL Benanti Serra Della Contessa Etna Rosso $216.00
- BTL Donnafugata "Floramundi" Cerasuolo Di Vittoria $58.00
- BTL DonnaFugata "Sedara" Nero D'Avola $58.00
- BTL Graci "Arcuria Sopra Il Pozzo" $250.00
- BTL Nero D'Avola Baglio Di Serramarrocco $68.00
- BTL Nocera Planeta $86.00
- BTL Paolo Cali' "Jazz" Frappato & Nero D'Avola $47.00
- BTL Pignatello "San Marcello" $89.00
- BTL Planeta "Mamertino" $79.00
- BTL Purato Nero D"Avola $45.00
- BTL Tornatore, Etna Rosso $59.00
- BTL Vigna Nica, Mamertino , Artigiani Del Vino $84.00
- BTL Pietradolce Contrada Rampante Etna Rosso $128.00
- BTL Winemakers Selection, Nero D"Avola $45.00
- BTL Ghiaia Nera , Tenuta Tascante , Etna Rosso $59.00
- BTL Le Casematte N.Mascalese, Nocera, Peloro Rosso $54.00
- BTL Perricone Fina $60.00
- BTL Le Sabbie Dell'Etna Ross0 $62.00
- BTL NERELLO CAPPUCCIO NOCERA , FARO, LE CASE MATTE $110.00
Vini Bianchi e Rosati - Bottiglia
- Bottle Regaleali, Tasca D'Almerita,Inzolia/Catarratto $54.00
- Bottle Alessandro Di Camporeale, Mandranova, Grillo $58.00
- Bottle Del Masso Catarrato Feudo Montoni $69.00
- Bottle Etna Rosato Terre Nere $68.00
- Bottle Purato, Rose' $52.00
- BTL Baglio Di Grisi Grillo $46.00
- Btl Barone Di Villagrande Etna Rose' $54.00
- BTL Ciuri Terrazze Dell"Etna, Etna Bianco $62.00
- BTL COS "Rami" Orange Grecanico Inzolia $72.00
- BTL Del Barone Grillo , Serramarrocco $60.00
- BTL Murgo Etna Bianco $75.00
- BTL Orange Wine Terre Siciliane Turi $72.00
- BTL Sabbie Etna Bianco $58.00
- BTL Salina , Colosi , Inzolia Catarratto $74.00
- BTL TIURI , TERRE SICILIANE , ORANGE WINE $72.00
- BTL Zibibbo 100% Quojane , Serramarrocco $84.00
- BTL Zibibbo 100% Quojane Serramarrocco $84.00
- BTL Peloro Bianco - Grillo Caricante- Le Casematte $56.00
Bevande
- Coke $5.00
- Diet Coke $5.00
- Sprite $5.00
- Limonata $6.00
- Aranciata $8.00
- Chinotto $6.00
- Coke Zero $5.00
Acqua
- San Pellegrino - 0.5 Liter $8.00
- San Pellegrino - 1 Liter $10.00
- Acqua Panna - 0.5 Liter $8.00
- Acqua Panna - 1 Liter $10.00
Norma Turtle Bay Details
Service options
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Wine
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
Amenities
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
Crowd
- Groups
- Tourists
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Pets
- Dogs allowed outside
Norma Turtle Bay Photos










Norma Turtle Bay Location
Norma Turtle Bay Reviews
italianwinearancinapricesoctopus carpacciomortadella pizzaporkpistachioour last nightlamb ragu
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Delicious Sicilian style pizza in a quaint and cozy space that has many seats. Their 4 fromaggi pizza and pizza with prosciutto and rucola were both excellent. I got a glass of Sauvignon Blanc which was quite pricey $19 but was fruity and good. It was very empty around noon.
August 20 · EllenI am an Italian American and part of my family comes from Sicily. We just returned a couple weeks ago from a trip to Sicily and have been craving the food. When we traveled to NYC this weekend and saw the menu (not Italian American dishes, but true Sicilian dishes we ate in Sicily), we had to try it because we’ve been missing the food so much. Norma is the real deal! Authentic Sicilian food and wine that was DELICIOUS. We all felt, for a brief moment, like we were back in Sicily. When we return to NYC in July, we’ve already decided we will be eating here again. Thanks so much for making the food that reminds me of home and my ancestors
April 20 · Crystal MateyAbsolutely incredible Sicilian spot in NYC! The appetizers were delicious, but the entrées were next-level. Hands down the best pasta I’ve had in the city and the closest to what I’ve tasted in Sicily. Every dish was packed with authentic flavor and cooked to perfection. Huge thanks to our waiter, Giovanni, who was friendly, attentive, and made us feel so welcome in the restaurant. Can’t wait to come back time and time again!
July 10 · JuliaOn my way to another restaurant, I came across Norma's new location and could not resist but to dine in. The atmosphere & menu alone, was unavoidable. Trully beautiful, cozy with that Sicilian touch. The staff was really friendly and welcoming. We git sat right away, but I'm sure the wait will increase in no time. Thus is the best next thing that has happened to the neighborhood. The food was beautifully presented, rich in flavors & simply delicious. Cannot wait to try it all! My fav new spot. Highly recommend it.
September 02 · RAM IMAGERYAuthentic Sicilian neighborhood restaurant with terrific pizza and bruscetta. But the arancini au burro was exceptional.
June 15 · Katrina Samen
More Best Restaurants Near Me

928 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

924 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

301 E 49th St, New York, NY 10017, USA

937 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

939 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

950 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

922 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10017, USA

304 E 49th St, New York, NY 10017, USA

302 E 49th St, New York, NY 10017, USA

304 E 49th St, New York, NY 10017, USA

249 E 49th St, New York, NY 10017, USA

945 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





