Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House

- 558 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081

For many in Westerville and the greater Columbus area, the search for a great local pizza place is a serious quest. It's not just about a quick meal; it's about finding a restaurant with a history, a commitment to quality, and a flavor profile that stands the test of time. Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House has been a beloved fixture in the Westerville community since the 1980s, earning a reputation for serving up excellent pizza and classic Italian-American dishes. The restaurant has moved from its original uptown location to its current spot on Schrock Road, where it has continued to thrive, cultivating a loyal following and a strong carryout business.

The core of Pasquale's appeal is the quality of its food, particularly its pizza. A visitor from out of town, who happened upon the restaurant while waiting for the Westerville Community Center pool to open, described the pizza as "SO GOOD," specifically mentioning the plain cheese and the "Founders Favourite" pizzas as "excellent." Another long-time customer noted that the cheese pizza is "as good as I remember" from the restaurant's earlier days, a testament to the consistency of their recipes over the years. The pizzas are known for being served "super fresh and piping hot," with a generous amount of "extra stringy cheese," a detail that pizza lovers in Ohio and beyond appreciate.

Beyond the pizza, Pasquale's is also celebrated for its wider menu. While reviews specifically call out the pizza, the name itself, "Pizza & Pasta House," and publicly available menu information, indicate that they offer a full range of Italian-American classics. Patrons can find salads, subs, and a variety of pasta dishes, including homemade lasagna and gnocchi, which are often family recipes. This diversity ensures that there's something for everyone, making it a great choice for a family dinner where not everyone is in the mood for pizza. The combination of a rich history, a dedication to fresh ingredients, and a welcoming atmosphere makes Pasquale's a true local gem.

Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House is conveniently located at 558 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081, USA. This places it in a high-traffic area that is easily accessible for residents of Westerville, as well as those in the surrounding communities of Worthington and northern Columbus. The restaurant's current location in a plaza is a major advantage, as it offers "plentiful" and easy parking. This "easy in and out" convenience is a huge plus for customers, especially those who are just stopping by for a quick carryout order. The location is just a short drive from major roads, making it a practical and stress-free option for a mid-week dinner or a weekend meal with friends and family.

Pasquale's provides a variety of services to accommodate the diverse needs of the Westerville community, focusing on both in-house dining and convenient off-site options.

• Dine-In Service: The restaurant offers a "quaint little place with a handful of tables for seating." This cozy atmosphere is perfect for a casual and intimate dining experience. Reviews note that the service is "extremely quick" and the food comes out fresh and hot, making it a great option for a sit-down meal. It's a welcoming environment for families, couples, or solo diners.

• Carryout and Takeout: The restaurant has a significant "carry out crowd," a testament to its popularity as a quick and reliable option for dinner at home. Customers can call ahead to place their order for pickup, which is a convenient service for those with busy schedules. The efficiency and speed of the service, with pizzas taking "maybe 10 minutes to come out," make it an ideal choice for a quick meal.

• Delivery: Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House offers delivery, providing another layer of convenience for its customers. This service is a major advantage for those who can't make it to the restaurant or who prefer to have their food brought directly to their door. Delivery is particularly useful for large parties or for those cold Ohio nights when staying in is the best option.

• Customization and Special Diets: The restaurant is accommodating to a variety of dietary needs. Reviews note that they have "salads, vegetarian options" and can even make a "cheese less pie" or a gluten-free pizza. This flexibility in their menu and service is a great feature that ensures a wide range of customers can enjoy their food.

Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House is celebrated for several key features and highlights that make it a local favorite.

• Consistently Delicious Pizza: The pizza is the main highlight. Reviewers consistently praise its quality, describing it as "SO GOOD," "super fresh," and "piping hot," with "extra stringy cheese." The taste is a standout feature that has earned them a loyal following for over 20 years.

• Homemade and Fresh Ingredients: The restaurant makes many of its items from scratch. Publicly available menu information indicates that they use premium ingredients, make their dough fresh daily, and feature family recipes for their pasta dishes, meatballs, and sauces. This commitment to fresh, quality ingredients is a huge selling point.

• Reasonable Pricing: A customer noted that the pricing was "very reasonable," which is a significant highlight for a restaurant known for its quality. The combination of great food and good value makes it an appealing choice for families and individuals on a budget.

• Efficient and Quick Service: The service is consistently praised for being "extremely quick," with food coming out in a timely manner. This efficiency, combined with friendly service, ensures a pleasant dining experience, whether you're eating in or taking out.

• Local History and Nostalgia: Having been a Westerville staple since the 1980s, Pasquale's holds a special place in the hearts of many locals. Customers who remember the old location appreciate the consistency and quality of the new one. This rich history and sense of nostalgia make it more than just a pizza shop; it's a part of the community's story.

For more information, to place an order for pickup or delivery, or to inquire about their menu, you can contact Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House using the following details.

Address: 558 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

Phone: (614) 882-6200

For residents of Westerville and the broader Columbus area, Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House is a perfect local choice for a delicious and satisfying meal. Its rich history and long-standing reputation for serving excellent food make it a trusted and beloved institution in the community. The convenient location on Schrock Road with ample parking makes it an easy and practical option for a quick stop. Whether you're dining in, grabbing a carryout order, or getting delivery, the service is known for being quick and friendly.

What truly sets Pasquale's apart is the quality and consistency of its food, from the "piping hot" and cheesy pizzas to the various pasta dishes and subs. The menu's flexibility, with options for vegetarians and those with a craving for something other than pizza, ensures that it can cater to a wide range of tastes. For anyone seeking a restaurant that combines a cozy, local feel with high-quality, delicious food at a reasonable price, Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House is a highly recommended destination that is sure to become a new favorite.

Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House

558 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081, USA