Sarabeth's Upper West Side: A Quintessential NYC Brunch Spot

Sarabeth's Upper West Side Introduce

In the heart of the Upper West Side, where historic brownstones meet the vibrant energy of Central Park, you’ll find an American restaurant that has become a true New York institution: Sarabeth's. With a legacy rooted in homemade preserves and fresh baked goods, Sarabeth's has blossomed into a beloved all-day dining destination. This particular location on Amsterdam Avenue embodies the brand's signature blend of sophisticated comfort and classic American fare. It's a place that feels simultaneously a part of the neighborhood fabric and a special destination for a celebration. Whether you're a local craving a weekend brunch or a tourist seeking that iconic NYC dining experience, Sarabeth's Upper West Side offers a warm, inviting, and delicious escape from the city hustle.

Sarabeth's has an almost legendary status, particularly for its brunch. The menu is a delightful showcase of both sweet and savory dishes, all prepared with a focus on quality and freshness. The commitment to using all-natural eggs from Sullivan County Farm and 100% organic maple syrup from Doerflers farm highlights their dedication to sourcing high-quality ingredients. This attention to detail is what transforms a simple meal into an extraordinary culinary moment. The atmosphere is casual yet trendy, and the space is often filled with a lively buzz, a testament to its popularity. It is a family-friendly restaurant that also appeals to groups, couples, and solo diners, making it a versatile choice for any occasion. The combination of a fantastic menu, a welcoming environment, and an iconic reputation ensures that Sarabeth's remains at the top of many New Yorkers' lists.

The establishment's reputation as a "sparkling treasure of the Upper West Side," as one customer review describes it, is well-earned. The charm of Sarabeth’s lies not only in its delectable food but also in its ability to create a cozy and loving atmosphere. Despite being a bustling and popular spot that often has a wait, the staff is known for being "attentive" and "loving," adding a personal touch that makes guests feel truly cared for. It is the kind of place where you are encouraged to linger, with a great selection of coffee and tea to go with your meal. This blend of quality food and exceptional hospitality is the secret to Sarabeth's enduring appeal in a city with no shortage of dining options.

Sarabeth's Upper West Side is perfectly situated at 423 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA, placing it in a prime spot for both residents and visitors. Its location on a vibrant avenue puts it within a few minutes' walk of Central Park, the American Museum of Natural History, and countless shops. Accessibility is a key advantage. For those using public transportation, the restaurant is a short walk from the 1, 2, and 3 subway lines at 72nd Street, as well as the B and C trains at 72nd Street. This makes it incredibly easy to get to from almost anywhere in Manhattan. For those driving, the area offers a mix of free and paid street parking, along with paid parking lots, though finding a spot can be challenging, as is typical for New York City. The restaurant is also committed to inclusivity, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating, ensuring all guests can enjoy their visit comfortably. Additionally, for those with furry friends, outdoor seating is available where dogs are allowed, making it a welcoming spot for the whole family.

Sarabeth's offers a wide range of services to cater to the diverse needs of its clientele, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable dining experience. These options provide flexibility for various dining preferences.

Dine-in and Outdoor Seating: Guests can enjoy their meal in the trendy indoor space or take advantage of the outdoor seating, perfect for a sunny day.
Delivery, No-Contact Delivery, and Curbside Pickup: For those who prefer to eat at home, Sarabeth's provides multiple convenient options for getting your food, whether delivered to your door or ready for pickup.
Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner: While renowned for its brunch, the restaurant serves all three meals, making it a reliable destination throughout the day. The menu includes both healthy options and classic comfort food.
Catering: For larger events, Sarabeth's offers catering services, bringing their beloved dishes and impeccable service to your private event.
Reservations: Given its popularity, reservations are recommended for brunch, lunch, and dinner, though they also reserve a generous portion of seating for walk-in guests. It's important to note that the host stand can get crowded, especially on busy days, so planning ahead is a good idea.

Sarabeth's is celebrated for a number of features and highlights that set it apart. The service is often praised for being "super quick" once you're seated, a significant perk in a city known for its fast pace. The bar is a highlight, offering a great selection of cocktails, beer, hard liquor, and wine. The coffee and tea selection is also a point of pride, with patrons enjoying a high-quality cup to accompany their meal. For a dose of entertainment, live music adds to the cozy and trendy atmosphere. The restaurant is family-friendly, offering a kids' menu and high chairs, making it an excellent choice for a family outing. The menu is a highlight in itself, featuring both comforting staples and healthy options to satisfy every palate.

For inquiries, reservations, or to place an order, you can contact Sarabeth's Upper West Side. Their phone number is (212) 496-6280, and the mobile number is +1 212-496-6280. The restaurant's address is 423 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA. They accept various forms of payment, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a convenient and smooth transaction.

The true value of choosing Sarabeth's comes from the exceptional food and the overall dining experience. Customers consistently rave about certain menu items. The "popovers are a must have," as one review states, and the omelettes are described as "super fresh." The "Fat & Fluffy French Toast" and the "Lemon & Ricotta Pancakes" are iconic and beloved dishes. Another patron calls Sarabeth's their "go-to brunch spot," praising the "loving and attentive" staff and the food, which is "always perfection." While some reviews may mention the high price point or a short wait even with a reservation, the consensus is that the quality of the food and the warm, welcoming service make it worth it. For those looking for a classic New York brunch or a comforting, delicious American meal in a lovely setting, Sarabeth's Upper West Side offers a truly memorable experience that embodies the best of the city's dining scene.

Sarabeth's Upper West Side Menu

FRUITY BEGINNINGS
BREAKFAST (SERVED MONDAY-FRIDAY 8:00AM-4:00PM)
FOUR FLOWERS JUICE $12.00
orange, fresh pineapple, banana & pomegranate juice
COLD PRESSED ORANGE OR GRAPEFRUIT JUICE $10.00
MORNING FRUIT BOWL $14.00
grapefruit & orange, sliced banana & strawberry

LIGHT BREAKFAST
BREAKFAST (SERVED MONDAY-FRIDAY 8:00AM-4:00PM)
APPLE CINNAMON GRANOLA $15.00
Greek yogurt, golden raisins, coconut, almonds, banana
BREAKFAST BOWL $21.00
quinoa, smoked salmon, avocado, pickled onions, pepitas, cherry tomato
STEEL CUT OATS $14.00
chia, pistachio, raspberry
SIGNATURE AVOCADO TOAST $20.00
heirloom cherry tomato, burrata cheese, pepita, petite market greens

SWEET BREAKFAST
organic 100% maple syrup from Doerflers farm. BREAKFAST (SERVED MONDAY-FRIDAY 8:00AM-4:00PM)
FAT & FLUFFY FRENCH TOAST $24.00
strawberries
LEMON & RICOTTA PANCAKES $24.00
blackberries
BUTTERMILK PANCAKES $24.00
strawberries
BASKET OF SARABETH’S MUFFINS & LEGENDARY PRESERVES $19.00
English, Bran, Banana, Pumpkin, Corn

SIDES
BREAKFAST (SERVED MONDAY-FRIDAY 8:00AM-4:00PM)
THREE-PEPPER HOME FRIES $12.00
APPLEWOOD SMOKED BACON $12.00
CHICKEN & APPLE SAUSAGE $13.00
SMOKED SALMON $12.00
1/2 AVOCADO $5.00

EXTRAORDINARY EGGS & OMELETTE
(Choice of Muffin, English, Bran, Banana, Pumpkin, Corn) Scone or Toast & Preserves *not served with additional toast. [Egg Whites +3] All-natural eggs from Sullivan County Farm
SPINACH & GOAT CHEESE OMELETTE $24.00
SARABETH'S QUICHE* $23.00
leeks, ham, potato, gruyere
GARDEN OMELETTE $23.00
peas, zucchini, mushrooms, cheddar
FARMER'S OMELETTE $23.00
leeks, ham, potato, gruyere
CLASSIC HAM BENEDICT* $25.00
Canadian bacon, hollandaise, peppers, chives
SMOKED SALMON BENEDICT* $26.00
hollandaise, peppers, chives
2 EGGS ANY STYLE* $23.00
served with local greens & toast. Choice of: chicken sausage, applewood smoked bacon

POPOVERS
WILD MUSHROOM SCRAMBLE $24.00
boursin cheese, truffle oil, chives
GOLDIE LOX SCRAMBLE $24.00
smoked salmon, cream cheese
BASKET OF POPOVERS $12.00
orange marmalade

APPETIZERS
LUNCH (SERVED MONDAY-FRIDAY 11:00AM-4:00PM)
VELVETY TOMATO SOUP $16.00
cheddar cheese, dill
CRAB & GUACAMOLE $22.00
housemade chips
CRISPY CALAMARI $18.00
spicy marinara, garlic aioli
DEVILED EGGS $15.00
capers, cornichon, parsley
BABY BEET SALAD $16.00
roasted rainbow beets, arugula, crispy everything puff pastry herb fontina fondue

SALADS
LUNCH (SERVED MONDAY-FRIDAY 11:00AM-4:00PM)
FIVE LETTUCE CAESAR $16.00
shaved parmesan, garlic & herb croutons
SARABETH'S CHOPPED SALAD $18.00
market vegetables, salami, feta, lemon vinaigrette
POWER BOWL $19.00
shredded kale, quinoa, beets, apples, goat cheese, pistachios, sherry shallot vinagrette
SEAFOOD COBB SALAD $33.00
Maine lobster, crab meat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, blue cheese

ENTREES
LUNCH (SERVED MONDAY-FRIDAY 11:00AM-4:00PM)
CLASSIC LOBSTER ROLL $36.00
remoulade, slaw, chips
ADULT GRILLED CHEESE $24.00
3 cheeses, pretzel bread, housemade pickles, tomato soup
ROASTED TURKEY CLUB $25.00
bacon jam, burrata, arugula, avocado, croissant
ONE GREAT BURGER $25.00
aged cheddar, bacon, sauteed onions jalepeno maramalade, pickled green tomatoes, house cut french fries
CHICKEN POT PIE $29.00
wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb bechamel
CRISPY BUTTERMILK CHICKEN SANDWICH $26.00
coleslaw, pickles, jalapeno marmalade, French fries
STEAK FRITES $36.00
house cut French fries, bearnaise sauce
FAROE ISLAND SALMON $32.00
eggplant caponata, wilted spinach basil oil

Christmas Eve Dinner Specials
In addition to our regular menu. Enjoy our classic Brunch and Dinner menus along with holiday inspired specials On Christmas Eve.
PARSNIP BISQUE $18.00
salmon rillette crostini, micro herbs, trout caviar
BABY OAK SALAD $17.00
roasted bosc pear, pomegranate, candied pecans, smoked blue cheese
BRAISED SHORT RIBS $34.00
fennel potato puree, maple glazed baby carrots, red wine bordelaise
PAN SEARED DIVER SCALLOPS $36.00
parsnip puree, wilted Swiss chard, dill beurre blanc

New Year's Eve Dinner Specials
Tuesday, December 31st. Join us on New Year's Eve and New Year's Day for Brunch and Dinner at Sarabeth's Upper West Side. Enjoy our classic Brunch from 8am - 5pm and Dinner from 5pm-10pm with holiday inspired specials for Dinner on New Year's Eve...
LOBSTER BISQUE $19.00
seafood crostini, herb crème fraiche
EENDIVE & APPLE SALAD $22.00
shaved fennel, gorgonzola, fine herbs, walnut vinaigrette
MAINE LOBSTER RAVIOLI $34.00
parmesan crema, shaved truffle, micro herb salad
FILET OSCAR $48.00
jumbo crab, asparagus, béarnaise sauce

New Year's Day Brunch Specials
Wednesday - Tuesday, January 1st
SMOKED SALMON $26.00
potato waffle, creme fraiche, caviar, pickled shallots
WAGYU & EGGS $35.00
smashed fingerling potatoes, béarnaise sauce

Lunch
Winter Restaurant Week: January 21st - February 9th, 2025
Lunch $30.00

Lunch - Appetizers
Winter Vegetable Minestrone
parsnip chips, & chive oil
Golden Beet & Goat Cheese Terrine
pistachio crumble, micro herb salad, sherry shallot
Roasted Pear Salad
Boston bibb, shaved fennel, endive, pomegranate molasses

Lunch - Entrees
Sauteed Jumbo Shrimp
grilled artichoke puree, baby carrots, broccoli rabe, Meyer lemon citrus glaze
Steak Tacos "al Pastor"
cilantro-pineapple relish, Spanish rice, black beans
Wild Mushroom Ravioli
honeynut squash puree, shaved pecorino, arugula

Dinner
Winter Restaurant Week: January 21st - February 9th, 2025
Dinner $45.00

Dinner - Appetizers
Winter Vegetable Minestrone
parsnip chips, & chive oil
Golden Beet & Goat Cheese Terrine
pistachio crumble, micro herb salad, sherry shallot
Roasted Pear Salad
Boston bibb, shaved fennel, endive, pomegranate molasses

Dinner - Entrees
Steak Paillard "al Pastor"
baby gem, grilled avocado, crispy tortilla, cilantro-pineapple chimichurri
Nordic Cod
grilled artichoke puree, baby carrots, broccoli rabe, meyer lemon citrus glaze
Wild Mushroom Ravioli
honey nut squash puree, shaved pecorino, arugula

Dinner - Dessert
S'more in a Jar
chocolate pudding, graham cracker crumble, toasted marshmallow
"Milk" & Cookies
vanilla gelato with a splash of milk

First Course
choice of
TUNA CARPACCIO
winter citrus, pistachio crumble, baby watercress
BILLI BI MUSSEL SOUP
smoked pimentón, haystack potato

Second Course
choice of
HERB CRUSTED RACK OF LAMB
parsnip purée, wilted wild greens, au poivre sauce
CRAB CRUSTED HALIBUT
asparagus, dill beurre blanc

Dessert
WILD CHERRY TART
vanilla gelato

FRUITY BEGINNINGS
BRUNCH (SERVED SATURDAY- SUNDAY 8:00AM- 5:00PM), LUNCH (SERVED SATURDAY- SUNDAY 11:00AM-5:00PM)
FOUR FLOWERS JUICE $12.00
orange, fresh pineapple, banana & pomegranate juice
COLD PRESSED ORANGE OR GRAPEFRUIT JUICE $10.00
MORNING FRUIT BOWL $14.00
grapefruit & orange, sliced banana & strawberry

LIGHT BREAKFAST
APPLE CINNAMON GRANOLA $15.00
Greek yogurt, golden raisins, coconut, almonds, banana
BREAKFAST BOWL $21.00
quinoa, smoked salmon, avocado, pickled onions, pepitas, cherry tomato
STEEL CUT OATS $14.00
chia, pistachio, raspberry
SIGNATURE AVOCADO TOAST $20.00
heirloom cherry tomato, burrata cheese, pepitas, petite market greens

SWEET BREAKFAST
organic 100% maple syrup from Doerflers farm
FAT & FLUFFY FRENCH TOAST $24.00
strawberries
LEMON & RICOTTA PANCAKES $24.00
blackberries
BUTTERMILK PANCAKES $24.00
strawberries

SIDES
THREE-PEPPER HOME FRIES $12.00
APPLEWOOD SMOKED BACON $12.00
CHICKEN & APPLE SAUSAGE $13.00
SMOKED SALMON $12.00
1/2 AVOCADO $5.00

EXTRAORDINARY EGGS & OMELETTES
(Choice of muffin English, Bran, Banana, Pumpkin, Corn) Scone or Toast & Preserves *not served with additional toast [Egg whites +3]
SPINACH & GOAT CHEESE OMELETTE $24.00
SARABETH’S QUICHE* $23.00
leeks, ham, potato, gruyère
GARDEN OMELETTE $23.00
peas, zucchini, mushrooms, cheddar
FARMER’S OMELETTE $23.00
leeks, ham, potato, gruyere
CLASSIC HAM BENEDICT* $25.00
Canadian bacon, hollandaise, peppers, chives
SMOKED SALMON BENEDICT* $26.00
hollandaise, peppers, chives
2 EGGS ANY STYLE* $23.00
served with local greens & toast. Choice of: chicken sausage, applewood smoked bacon

POPOVERS
WILD MUSHROOM SCRAMBLE $24.00
boursin cheese, truffle oil, chives
GOLDIE LOX SCRAMBLE $24.00
smoked salmon, cream cheese
BASKET OF POPOVERS $12.00
orange marmalade

APPETIZERS
VELVETY TOMATO SOUP $16.00
cheddar cheese, dill
CRAB & GUACAMOLE $22.00
housemade chips
DEVILED EGGS $15.00
capers, cornichon, parsley
SHORT RIB TATER TOTS $16.00
chipotle aioli
BASKET OF SARABETH’S MUFFINS & LEGENDARY PRESERVES $19.00
English, Bran, Banana, Pumpkin, Corn

SALADS
FIVE LETTUCE CAESAR $16.00
shaved parmesan, garlic & herb croutons
SARABETH'S CHOPPED SALAD $18.00
market vegetables, salami, feta, lemon vinaigrette
POWER BOWL $19.00
shredded kale, quinoa, pista-chios, apples, beets, goat cheese, sherry shallot vinaigrette
SEAFOOD COBB SALAD $33.00
Maine lobster, crab meat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, blue cheese

ENTREES
CLASSIC LOBSTER ROLL $36.00
remoulade, slaw, chips
ADULT GRILLED CHEESE $24.00
3 cheeses, pretzel bread, housemade pickles, tomato soup
ROASTED TURKEY CLUB $25.00
bacon jam, burrata, arugula, avocado, croissant
ONE GREAT BURGER $25.00
aged cheddar, bacon, sauteed onions jalepeno maramalade, pickled green tomatoes, house cut french fries
CHICKEN POT PIE $29.00
wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb bechamel
CRISPY BUTTERMILK CHICKEN SANDWICH $26.00
coleslaw, pickles, jalapeno marmalade, French fries
STEAK FRITES $36.00
house cut French fries, bearnaise sauce

WHITE
WINE BY THE GLASS
PINOT GRIGIO, Italy
SAUVIGNON BLANC, New Zealand
CHARDONNAY, California
SANCERRE, France
ALBARINO, Spain

RED
WINE BY THE GLASS
PINOT NOIR, Oregon
BARBERA D'ALBA, Italy
MALBEC, Argentina
CABERNET SAUVIGNON, Washington

ROSÉ
WINE BY THE GLASS
ROSE, Italy

SPARKLING
WINE BY THE GLASS
PROSECCO, Italy
ROSE, Italy
SPARKLING ROSE, Italy
PROSECCO ROSE, Italy

FOR WINES BY THE BOTTLE PLEASE SEE OUR FULL WINE LIST
FOR WINES BY THE BOTTLE PLEASE SEE OUR FULL WINE LIST

SANGRIA
RED
merlot, vanilla, brandy
WHITE
chablis, apple, brandy

LEMONADE STAND MOCKTAILS
all mocktails made with fresh lemonade, add your favorite spirit to make it a cocktail, additional price applies
LAVENDER LEMONADE $7.00
vanilla syrup infused with lavender
MAI TAI BLOSSOM $7.00
orange blossom water, orgeat syrup, fresh lemonade
SARABETH’S PINK LEMONADE $7.00
Sarabeth's strawberry raspberry preserves

COCKTAILS
Fun in the Sun $16.00
pineapple syrup, lime juice, bitter truth all spice dram, Cointreau, pineapple juice
Tiramisu Martini $16.00
Haku Vodka, Mr. Black, Cre’me de Cacao, Espresso, simple syrup
Blood Orange Coconut Margarita $16.00
Hornitos blanco, triple sec, coconut cream, blood orange juice, lime juice
Hey Honey! $16.00
Gunpowder gin, grapefruit juice, lime juice, honey rosemary syrup
Southern Reverie $16.00
Makers Mark, ginger simple syrup, black iced tea, Luxardo Abona Amaro, lemon juice

BRUNCH COCKTAILS
SIGNATURE BLOODY MARY
spring 44 vodka, pickled vegetables [add jumbo shrimp +4]
CLASSIC MIMOSA
orange juice, sparkling wine
FOUR FLOWER MIMOSA
four flower juice, sparkling wine
FIVE FLOWER MIMOSA
St. Germaine, sparkling wine, four flower juice
CLASSIC BELLINI
white peach purée, sparkling wine

BEER
LAGUNITAS IPA California $9.00
WOLFFER ROSE CIDER New York $9.00
ALLAGASH WHITE Maine $9.00
ABITA AMBER Louisiana $9.00
LANDSHARK LAGER St. Louis $9.00
STELLA ARTOIS Belgium $9.00

SALADS
DINNER (SERVED MONDAY-FRIDAY 4:00PM-10:00PM), MENU (SATURDAY 5:00PM-10:00PM & SUNDAY 5:00PM-9:00PM)
SARABETH’S CHOPPED SALAD $19.00
market vegetables, salami, feta, lemon vinaigrette
POWER BOWL $22.00
shredded kale, quinoa, pistachios, apples, beets, goat cheese, sherry shallot vinaigrette
SEAFOOD COBB SALAD $33.00
Maine lobster, crab meat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, blue cheese

BRUNCH
SPINACH & GOAT CHEESE OMELETTE $24.00
served with local greens, choice of muffin
CLASSIC HAM BENEDICT $25.00
Canadian bacon, hollandaise, peppers, chives
FAT & FLUFFY FRENCH TOAST $24.00
strawberries

SANDWICHES
CLASSIC LOBSTER ROLL $36.00
remoulade, slaw, chips
ADULT GRILLED CHEESE $24.00
3 cheeses, pretzel bread, housemade pickles, tomato soup
CRAB CAKE SANDWICH $27.00
sesame bun, tartar sauce, house cut french fries
ONE GREAT BURGER $25.00
aged cheddar, pickled green tomatoes, bacon, sauteed onions, jalapeño marmalade, house cut French fries

APPETIZERS
PRIX FIXE. choice of
CRAB & GUACAMOLE $22.00
housemade chips
VELVETY TOMATO SOUP $16.00
cheddar cheese, dill
MEATBALLS $17.00
pomodoro, basil, garlic focaccia bread
CRISPY CALAMARI $20.00
spicy marinara, garlic aioli
BANG BANG SHRIMP $15.00
ginger, sweet chili, avocado, micro mint
BABY BEET SALAD $16.00
roasted rainbow beets, arugula, crispy everything puff pastry, herb fontina fondue
FIVE LETTUCE CAESAR $16.00
shaved parmesan, garlic & herb croutons
CRISPY BURRATA $18.00
plum-fennel relish, orange blossom honey, petit herb salad
FIVE LETTUCE CAESAR
shaved parmesan, garlic & herb croutons
VELVETY TOMATO SOUP
cheddar cheese, dill

ENTREES
PRIX FIXE. choice of
STEAK FRITES $36.00
house cut French fries, bearnaise sauce
FAROE ISLAND SALMON $32.00
eggplant caponata, wilted spinach, basil oil
FARM CHICKEN $29.00
confit chicken croquette, creamed spinach, baby carrots, black truffle jus
BLACKENED SHRIMP RISOTTO $33.00
English pea, asparagus, mascarpone
SESAME CRUSTED AHI TUNA $33.00
chickpea hummus, Spring vegetables, sunny side quail eggs
PAN ROASTED BRANZINO $30.00
fava bean spaetzle, heirloom tomato & olive ragout, Thai basil
CHICKEN POT PIE $29.00
wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb bechamel
STEAK FRITES
house cut French fries bearnaise sauce
FAROE ISLAND SALMON
eggplant caponata, wilted spinach, basil oil
FARM CHICKEN
confit chicken croquette, creamed spinach, baby carrots black truffle jus

PRIX FIXE
PRIX FIXE $45.00

DESSERT
PRIX FIXE
Chocolate Truffle Cake

SIDES
FRENCH GREEN BEANS $12.00
shallots, dill
TRUFFLE FRIES $12.00
rosemary, garlic aioli
CREAMED SPINACH $12.00
roasted garlic
EGGPLANT CAPONATA $12.00
capers and basil

LUNCH PRIX FIXE
Served Monday to Friday from 11 am to 4 pm
LUNCH PRIX FIXE $35.00
Choice of two: Appetizer and Entree or Entree and Dessert

APPETIZERS
FIVE LETTUCE CAESAR
shaved parmesan, garlic & herb croutons
VELVETY TOMATO SOUP
cheddar cheese, dill
GUACAMOLE & CHIPS
house made potato chips
DEVILED EGGS
capers, cornichon, parsley
BABY BEET SALAD
rainbow beets, arugula, everything crisp puff pastry, herb fontina fondue
CRISPY CALAMARI $2.00
spicy marinara, garlic aioli
SHORT RIB TATER TOTS
chipotle aioli

ENTREES
SPINACH & GOAT CHEESE OMELETTE
served with market greens
SARABETH’S QUICHE
leeks, potato, ham, cheddar
FAT & FLUFFY FRENCH TOAST
strawberries
POWER BOWL
with grilled chicken
ROTISSERIE TURKEY CLUB
bacon jam, burrata, arugula, avocado, croissant
ONE GREAT BURGER
aged cheddar, pickled green tomatoes, bacon, sautéed onions, jalapeno marmalade, house cut French fries
CHICKEN POT PIE
wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb bechamel
STEAK FRITES $5.00
house cut French fries, bearnaise sauce
FAROE ISLAND SALMON $3.00
eggplant caponata, wilted spinach, basil oil

DESSERTS
Chocolate Truffle Cake
Raspberry Bread Pudding
Seasonal Crostata
Sorbet with Berries
Gelato

WHITE
BOTTLES
PINOT GRIGIO il Narratore, Italy
SAUVIGNON BLANC Frenzy, New Zealand
SANCERRE Maison Chavet, France
CHARDONNAY Valravn, California
ALBARINO Pazo Das Bruxas, Spain
ANTAO VAZ Monte Velho, Alentejo, Portugal $30.00
GAVI Villa Sparina, Piedmont, Italy $30.00
CHARDONNAY La Crema, Sonoma, California $30.00
PINOT GRIS Portlandia, Oregon $50.00
CHARDONNAY Fess Parker, California $70.00
PINOT GRIGIO Cantina Lavis, Trentino, Italy $60.00
RIESLING Empire Estate, Finger Lakes, New York $60.00
GAVI Villa Sparina, Piedmont, Italy $65.00
SAUVIGNON BLANC Cantina Lavis, Trentino, Italy $60.00
POUILLY FUISSE Domaine Deux Roches, France $70.00
CHABLIS Domaine de Varoux, France $65.00

RED
BOTTLES
PINOT NOIR Routestock, California
BARBERA D'ALBA Renato Fenocchio, Piedmont, Italy
CABERNET SAUVIGNON Cataclysm, Washington
MALBEC Bodegas Escorihuela, Argentina
MONTEPULCIANO D'ABRUZZO Zaccagnini, Abruzzo, Italy $25.00
MALBEC Uno Antigal, Mendoza, Argentina $25.00
ZINFANDEL Klinker Brick, Lodi, California $25.00
TEMPRANILLO Baron De Ley, Rioja, Spain $65.00
CABERNET SAUVIGNON Broadside, California $70.00
CHIANTI CLASSICO Vallepicciola, Tuscany, Italy $50.00
GIGONDAS Domaine du Terme, Rhone Valley, France $65.00
GRENACHE Le Paradou, Rhone Valley, France $65.00
AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA Pasqua, Italy $85.00
BARBERA D'ALBA Punset, Neive, Italy $55.00
MONTEPULCIANO D'ABRUZZO Tiberio, Abruzzo, Italy $55.00

SPARKLING
BY THE GLASS
PROSECCO Jeio, Veneto, Italy
SPARKLING ROSE Scarpetta, Fruili-Venezia, Italy
ROSE 11 Minutes, Famiglia Pasqua, Italy

Sarabeth's Upper West Side Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great tea selection
Live music

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Hard liquor
Healthy options
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists

Planning
Brunch reservations recommended
Lunch reservations recommended
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations
Usually a wait

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free street parking
Paid parking lot
Paid street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Sarabeth's Upper West Side Photos

Sarabeth's Upper West Side Location

Sarabeth's Upper West Side

New York New York County New York Amsterdam Avenue

423 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Sarabeth's Upper West Side Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 1587 user reviews.

bruncheggs benedictpancakespopoversricottaquicheavocado toastsalmon benedicttomato soupnatural history museum

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Delicious and super cute spot for brunch with friends or family. Service is super quick once you get your table; however, it does get a little crowded near the host stand, even if you have a reservation. Their popovers are a must have and their omelettes are super fresh. Would definitely come back again.
August 26 · Gabriella
Sarabeth’s is the sparkling treasure of the Upper West Side! The staff are so loving and attentive, the space is gorgeous, and the food is always perfection! We recently went for a special get together and had the best time! This is my go-to brunch spot. Go to there!
May 20 · Elizabeth Bunten
This is a great place to have brunch on the weekends and enjoy it with family or friends.The dishes are well served and very tasty, the recipe for the riccota lemon pancakes is a bit different than the first time I tried them, maybe less moist, but still good flavor. About the place, it is a classic NY place, however, they could take better care of the bathrooms.The attention and service of the waiter who served us stands out; very friendly and willing to answer questions and make recommendations (essential when you have children with you).In general, a pleasant experience.
March 11 · Ana Saenz
Tuesday night. I asked mom why we were eating here, she said bc it’s quiet and she could hear everyone. Mom is 82 this place has definitely gone downhill since I was here last. Menu way smaller and much more expensive. Waitress m.i.a. Most of the meal dad had to get up to find what I’m guessing was a busboy who did actually take our order. Same guy delivered the meals. Waitress after missing for well over 45m finally came back and asked if we were happy with our decisions (?) super weird light switches touched by her next to our table were disgusting I hope she washed her hands after touching them $200 meal for 4 incl 5 drinks total
April 30 · Electronics Guru
Love to have brunch at Sarabeth’s. The chicken buttermilk sandwich was amazing. And lavender lemonade… soooo delicious. Service is great, perfect time to go is 11:30am. 🤩
March 31 · Aryella Almeida