Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta

- 1097 Worthington Woods Blvd, Columbus, OH 43085

Hello, Ohio pizza lovers and pasta aficionados! When the craving for a truly satisfying Italian-American meal strikes, look no further than Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta in Columbus. This neighborhood eatery, nestled within the Worthington Woods area, has been making a name for itself by serving up delicious pizzas, hearty pasta dishes, and flavorful subs, all crafted with a commitment to quality ingredients and customer satisfaction. It's the kind of local spot that aims to become your go-to for family dinners, a quick lunch, or a cozy night in.

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta offers a menu that clearly reflects a passion for classic Italian-American comfort food. While their name highlights pizza and pasta, customers will find a wider variety of options, from appetizers to subs and even gluten-free choices. Recent customer experiences suggest that the establishment, now under new management, is focused on delivering a product that stands out. One enthusiastic reviewer, a long-time critic of "Columbus pizza," praised Big Tony's for its flavorful sausage, pepperoni, and mushroom pizza, noting the pleasant cheese blend and a crust that, while thicker than some local competitors, avoided the "gravelly cornmeal" texture. The friendly staff and the pizza's ability to hold up as delicious leftovers further solidify its appeal. Even a critical review, while highlighting areas for improvement, expressed a desire to support the local business, underscoring the community's hope for its continued success.

This article will provide you with a clear, factual, and engaging overview of Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta, helping you understand its unique appeal and why it continues to be a suitable choice for locals in the Ohio region seeking delightful Italian-American fare. From its accessible location to its diverse services and notable features, we’ll cover all the essential details that contribute to its place in the community.

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta is conveniently located at 1097 Worthington Woods Blvd, Columbus, OH 43085, USA. This address places it squarely within a bustling commercial strip in the Worthington Woods area, a well-trafficked and easily accessible part of Columbus. Worthington Woods Boulevard is a known thoroughfare, ensuring that the restaurant is visible and straightforward to reach for patrons residing in or traveling through the northern suburbs of Columbus, including Worthington, Westerville, and other nearby communities.

The accessibility of Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta is a significant benefit for its customer base. Being situated in a plaza, there is typically ample parking available, which is a considerable convenience for a restaurant that caters to both dine-in and takeout customers. Its location also makes it well-positioned for efficient delivery services via popular online platforms, extending its reach to a wider segment of the local population. Whether you're making a quick stop for a carryout order after work or planning a relaxed family meal, the ease of access to Big Tony's contributes to its appeal as a practical and appealing choice for the Ohio community. Its proximity to other businesses within the strip also adds to its convenience, allowing for combined errands.

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta offers a comprehensive range of services designed to maximize convenience and enhance the dining experience for its customers.

• Dine-In Service: The restaurant provides a casual and friendly environment for guests who prefer to enjoy their meals directly at the establishment.
• Takeout/Carryout: Customers can easily place orders for pickup, making it a quick and efficient option for those on the go. This is a primary service for many pizza and pasta establishments.
• Delivery Service: Big Tony's partners with major third-party delivery platforms such as Grubhub, DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Slice, allowing customers to have their pizzas, pastas, and other menu items delivered directly to their homes or offices.
• Online Ordering: For added convenience, customers can browse the full menu and place their orders online through the restaurant's website or via popular food delivery apps, streamlining the ordering process and often allowing for pre-payment.
• Catering Options: Big Tony's offers catering services, including platters of pizza, pasta dishes, and subs, making it a suitable choice for various events, office lunches, or family gatherings in the local area. Gift cards are also available.

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta distinguishes itself through several key features and highlights that contribute to its growing reputation and appeal among Columbus locals.

• Diverse and Extensive Menu: While "Pizza & Pasta" are in the name, Big Tony's offers a wide array of Italian-American comfort food. Their menu includes:
  • Pizzas: Tony's Original Crust Pizzas (12" and 14") with a 5-cheese blend, and a wide selection of Gourmet Pizzas like Pepperoni Lovers, Meat Lovers, Tony's Deluxe (pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, ham, Italian sausage, ground beef), White Pizza, Hawaiian, Extreme Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Alfredo, Vegetarian, BBQ Chicken, Cardinal's (steak and buffalo chicken), Mediterranean, and Philly Steak pizza.
  • Pastas: Classic options such as Pasta with Marinara, Pasta with Meatballs, Chicken Alfredo, Baked Beef Ravioli, Baked Three-Cheese Ravioli, Chicken Parm, and Eggplant Parmesan, all served with garlic knots.
  • Calzones: A popular choice, with options like Cheese Calzone, Tony's Calzone (pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms), Philly Steak & Cheese, Extreme Buffalo Chicken, Pepperoni Supreme, and a 'Make Your Own' option.
  • Subs: Including Italian, Meatball Parm, Philly Steak and Cheese, Chicken Parm, Grilled Chicken, Ham and Cheese, Buffalo Chicken Finger, and Veggie subs.
  • Appetizers & Sides: A wide range including Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, Fried Mushrooms, French Fries, Garlic Cheese Bread, Jalapeno Poppers, Chicken Tenders, and Boneless Wings (available in various sauces).
• Quality Ingredients and Flavor Profile: Reviewers note the "flavorful" pepperoni and sausage, a "nice blend" of cheese that "didn't taste 'plasticky' like many chain shops," and a sauce that, while a "little sweeter than expected," balanced well with the "decently salted" crust. The commitment to "fresh foods, quality ingredients" is a stated goal.
• Support for Specific Dietary Needs: Big Tony's offers a Gluten-Free Pizza option, which is a significant highlight for those with dietary restrictions. Reviewers appreciate that it's "not super expensive" and delivers on flavor with a "semi-crispy gluten-free crust," a "traditional sauce," and "quality cheese." It's important to note it's prepared in a kitchen where gluten is present.
• Friendly Service and New Management: The recent change in management has been met with positive feedback regarding friendly staff. A customer noted being greeted by a "very friendly guy at the register" who explained the new management's efforts to enhance the dining experience, which includes a belief that their pizza surpasses nearby competitors.
• Excellent Leftovers: A unique highlight from a customer review, indicating the quality of the pizza is sustained even when reheated, which is often considered the "ultimate test of good pizza."

For direct inquiries, to place an order, or for any other questions, you can contact Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta using the following information:

Address: 1097 Worthington Woods Blvd, Columbus, OH 43085, USA

Phone: (614) 436-3777

Mobile Phone: +1 614-436-3777

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta in Columbus is an excellent choice for locals in the Ohio region, particularly those in Worthington and the surrounding areas, for several compelling reasons. Firstly, it offers a robust and diverse menu that extends beyond just pizza, providing a wide array of classic Italian-American dishes like pasta dinners, calzones, and various subs. This variety ensures there's something to satisfy every craving and cater to different preferences within a family or group. The reported quality of their ingredients, from flavorful toppings to a well-balanced crust and cheese blend, speaks to a commitment to taste that stands out.

Secondly, the recent change in management and the emphasis on friendly service indicate a clear dedication to customer satisfaction and community engagement. The staff's welcoming demeanor and helpfulness contribute to a pleasant dining experience, whether you're dining in, picking up, or having food delivered. Furthermore, the inclusion of convenient services like online ordering, delivery through major platforms, and catering options makes it incredibly easy for busy Ohioans to enjoy Big Tony's offerings. For those seeking a local pizza and pasta shop that offers good value, diverse options, and a commitment to quality, Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta presents itself as a highly suitable and increasingly beloved spot within the Columbus food scene.

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta

1097 Worthington Woods Blvd, Columbus, OH 43085, USA