Dante's Pizza

- 3586 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214

Introduction / Overview

For those in Columbus, Ohio, who appreciate a taste of tradition and a sense of community, Dante's Pizza is more than just a restaurant—it's an institution. Tucked away on Indianola Avenue, this local pizza spot has been serving up its unique and beloved pies for decades, becoming a multi-generational favorite in the Clintonville neighborhood. What sets Dante's apart is its unwavering commitment to quality and a deeply personal touch. Customers consistently rave about the pizza, describing it as "out of this world" and praising the fact that you can "tell that the pizzas were made with love and had been made like that for many years." The secret lies in their traditional approach, with dough made fresh daily and sauces made in-house. A long-time employee, Christina Taylor, and her husband, Jeff Egger, who both grew up eating Dante's pizza, took over ownership in 2021, ensuring the original spirit and recipes would continue to thrive. They take pride in not only welcoming customers but also treating them "like you're part of the family." This dedication to both their craft and their community has cemented Dante's as a beloved cornerstone of the local food scene, a place where history and delicious food come together.

Location and Accessibility

Dante's Pizza is conveniently located to serve the heart of Clintonville and the surrounding areas. You can find this iconic pizzeria at 3586 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214, USA. Its prime spot on Indianola Avenue makes it a highly visible and easily accessible destination. The restaurant is situated in a bustling corridor, making it a convenient stop for residents, students, and passersby. For those driving, there is parking available, although it's worth noting that the space is part of a busy shopping plaza. Public transportation is also an excellent option, as numerous COTA bus lines run along Indianola Avenue, with stops located just a short walk away. The accessibility of this location is a major benefit, as it allows customers from all over the city to easily make the trip for their favorite pizza and subs. Whether you're coming for a quick pickup or planning to dine in, the central location on Indianola Avenue makes it a well-worth-it destination.

Services Offered

Dante's Pizza is committed to making its delicious food available to customers in a way that fits their needs, whether it's a quick takeout order or a sit-down meal.

• Dine-in: The restaurant offers a casual and inviting dining area. While it's not a large, full-service restaurant, there are tables available for those who want to eat their meal on-site. The atmosphere is friendly and relaxed, perfect for a casual family meal or a gathering with friends.

• Takeout: Takeout is a major part of the business, and Dante's excels at it. Customers can call ahead to place their orders, and the staff ensures they are made correctly and on time. Reviews highlight that pizzas are "still hot and fresh after a 12-minute drive home," which speaks to the quality and care put into every order.

• Catering: With a variety of pizza and sub options, Dante's is a great choice for catering events of all sizes. The family-friendly style of their food makes it a perfect solution for parties, corporate lunches, or other gatherings where you want to serve high-quality, crowd-pleasing dishes.

• Cash and Check Only: A classic feature that reflects the restaurant's old-school charm is its payment method. It's a "cash and check only" business, which adds to its traditional, no-frills character.

Features / Highlights

Dante's Pizza has a number of standout features that have contributed to its long-standing success and loyal customer base.

• Authentic and High-Quality Ingredients: The restaurant's commitment to using fresh, homemade ingredients is a key highlight. Their dough is made fresh daily, and their signature sauces are prepared in-house. Customers rave about the "Ezzo pepperoni" and the "fresh homemade sausage," both of which are described as "amazinggggg" and a must-try.

• Exceptional Customer Service: Patrons consistently praise the staff and management for their friendly and attentive service. One reviewer noted that the staff "was very apologetic and eager to make it right" when an order was made incorrectly, even "going above and beyond to compensate." This level of care and accountability makes customers feel valued and appreciated.

• A Menu Beyond Pizza: While the pizza is the star, Dante's also offers a great selection of other items. Their subs are highlighted in reviews as being "great also," offering a delicious alternative for those who might want something different. The menu includes a variety of Italian specialties, salads, and appetizers.

• Multigenerational Loyalty: Dante's is a place that has been a part of many families' traditions for years. The current owners grew up in the neighborhood and are carrying on the legacy, and many customers mention that they have been eating at Dante's for decades, now bringing their own children. This deep-rooted loyalty is a testament to the restaurant's consistent quality and community focus.

Contact Information

To place a takeout order or for any other inquiries, you can contact Dante's Pizza using the details below.

Address: 3586 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

Phone: (614) 268-5090

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

Dante's Pizza is a perfect fit for the local Columbus community because it is more than just a place to get a slice—it's a piece of neighborhood history. It provides a reliable and consistently delicious source of classic pizza and Italian-American food, all made with a level of care and tradition that is hard to find. The owners' personal connection to the community, having grown up as customers themselves, ensures that the restaurant's legacy of quality and hospitality will continue. The emphasis on high-quality ingredients, like the homemade sausage and Ezzo pepperoni, sets their food apart, making it well worth the trip. The friendly staff's commitment to treating every customer like family creates a welcoming atmosphere that keeps people coming back. For anyone in Columbus looking for a pizza joint that offers not only fantastic food but also a genuine connection to its community, Dante's Pizza is the place to go. It’s a local treasure that will undoubtedly continue to be a staple in the routines of Clintonville residents for generations to come.

Dante's Pizza

3586 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214, USA