Osteria Pizzeria Columbus Ohio - A Taste of Authentic Italian in Olde Towne East

Osteria Pizzeria Photos

Osteria Pizzeria Introduce

Introduction / Overview: Experience Authentic Italian Flavors at Osteria Pizzeria in Columbus, Ohio

Nestled in the vibrant and evolving Olde Towne East neighborhood of Columbus, Ohio, Osteria Pizzeria has quickly carved out a reputation as a must-visit destination for authentic Italian cuisine. This establishment is more than just a pizza place; it's an "Osteria," offering a welcoming atmosphere where guests can savor a diverse menu that extends far beyond just pies. From incredibly flavorful and tender meatballs to "one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had," Osteria Pizzeria is dedicated to bringing the true tastes of Italy to the heart of Ohio. It prides itself on using high-quality ingredients and traditional recipes, ensuring every dish, from its perfectly thin and chewy pizza dough to its rich marinara sauce, delivers an authentic culinary experience. Whether you're a local seeking a new favorite Italian spot or exploring the buzzing Columbus dining scene, Osteria Pizzeria promises a memorable meal in a charming setting, making it a stellar addition to the city's diverse gastronomic landscape.

Location and Accessibility: Perfectly Placed in Olde Towne East

Osteria Pizzeria is conveniently located at 892 Oak St, Columbus, OH 43205, USA. This address places it firmly within the increasingly popular Olde Towne East neighborhood, a vibrant area known for its historic homes, local businesses, and burgeoning culinary scene. The restaurant has taken over a location with a rich history in Columbus pizza, previously home to Yellow Brick Pizza and Mikey's Late Night Slice, bringing a fresh Italian concept to a familiar spot. Its position on Oak Street ensures good accessibility for diners from across Columbus. While specific parking details aren't widely advertised, street parking is typically available in Olde Towne East, though, as with any popular urban area, it can vary during peak hours. For those utilizing public transportation, several COTA bus routes serve the Olde Towne East area, providing convenient access. The neighborhood is also increasingly walkable and bike-friendly, allowing patrons to easily combine a meal at Osteria Pizzeria with exploring the local shops, parks, and other attractions in the vicinity. This central and accessible location makes Osteria Pizzeria a convenient and appealing choice for any Ohioan looking for an authentic Italian dining experience.

Services Offered: A Diverse Italian Culinary Journey

Hand-Tossed Pizzas: Osteria Pizzeria offers a selection of handcrafted pizzas, known for their perfect thinness and chewy dough. Popular options include the "Numero Uno" (pork pepperoni, ricotta, banana peppers, hot honey, marinara) and the classic "Margherita" (fresh mozzarella, basil, marinara, olive oil, sea salt). They also offer "BYO Pizza" (Build Your Own) and options for cauliflower crust, vegan cheese, and vegan pepperoni.
Flavorful Starters: The appetizer menu features highly praised items such as tender "Meatballs" with fresh marinara and ricotta, and the "outstanding" "Hungarian Stuffed Peppers" (sausage, mascarpone, herbs, marinara, mozzarella). Other options include "Garlic Bread," "Focaccia" (house-made), "Warm Olives," and "Antipasti."
Fresh Salads: A variety of salads are available, including an "Italian Salad" with mixed greens, pepperoni, mozzarella, and focaccia croutons.
Hearty Subs: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a selection of satisfying Italian subs like the "Italian Sub" (mortadella, pork pepperoni, salami), "Meatball Sub," "Chicken Classico," and "Sicilian Hot Honey."
Classic Pasta Dishes: Osteria Pizzeria also offers pasta dishes such as "Tagliatelle Bolognese," "Pesto Pappardelle," and "Stuffed Sheets" (herb lemon ricotta filling, marinara).
Desserts: Finish your meal with authentic Italian desserts like "Tiramisu," "Olive Oil Cake," and refreshing "Lemon Sorbet," as well as various ice cream options.
Full Bar with Cocktails & Wine: The restaurant features a full bar offering a selection of craft cocktails, inspired by Italian flavors, and a curated wine list to complement the meal.
Dine-In Experience: Osteria Pizzeria provides a "beautiful" and "modern design" atmosphere with a "warm and inviting" ambiance, perfect for a cozy family dinner, a night out with friends, or a date night.
Takeout and Delivery: For convenience, pickup orders are available, and the restaurant partners with third-party delivery services like DoorDash and Grubhub, allowing customers to enjoy their food at home.
Kid's Menu: A dedicated kid's menu with kid-friendly "cocktails" (mocktails) is available, making it suitable for families.

Features / Highlights: What Makes Osteria Pizzeria a Standout in Columbus

Exceptional Pizza Quality: Customers consistently laud the pizza, with reviews calling it "one of the best pizza I’ve ever had." The "dough had enough chewiness, perfect thinness," and the fresh marinara is praised for its balance of flavor.
"Outstanding" Hungarian Stuffed Peppers: A frequently highlighted appetizer, these peppers are described as "incredibly flavorful" and a "must-try," even with their surprising kick of heat.
Flavorful and Tender Meatballs: The meatballs are noted for being "flavorful, tender, not packed like most other meatball we had in any Italian restaurant," served with a fresh, balanced marinara.
High-Quality House-Made Focaccia: The focaccia served with appetizers is celebrated as "light, airy, crusty yet soft at the same time," showcasing the restaurant's commitment to freshly baked goods.
Authentic Italian Flavors: The restaurant aims to bring the "flavors of Italy" to Columbus, and reviews confirm this, with comments like "Closest to New York style pizza we've had in Columbus."
Warm and Welcoming Atmosphere: The "new modern design is beautiful" and creates an "extremely inviting" atmosphere, making it suitable for various dining occasions, from casual family meals to more intimate date nights.
Friendly and Quick Service: Many customers praise the staff, describing servers as "quick, friendly," and the overall service as "good," contributing positively to the dining experience.
Diverse Menu Beyond Pizza: While a pizzeria, Osteria offers a wide range of authentic Italian dishes including pastas, subs, and unique appetizers, ensuring a comprehensive Italian dining experience.
Strategic Location with History: Located in a spot that was previously home to popular pizza establishments, Osteria Pizzeria carries on a legacy while introducing its own unique Italian identity to Olde Towne East.
Focus on Freshness: The use of fresh ingredients, evident in the marinara sauce and focaccia, underscores their commitment to quality.

Contact Information

For those in Ohio eager to experience the authentic Italian cuisine and exceptional pizzas at Osteria Pizzeria, here is their contact information:

Address: 892 Oak St, Columbus, OH 43205, USA

Phone: (614) 869-0119

Mobile Phone: +1 614-869-0119

Email: krista@osteriacolumbus.com (as found on their official website)

Conclusion: Why Osteria Pizzeria is Suitable for Locals in Ohio

For the discerning residents of Columbus and the wider Ohio region, Osteria Pizzeria stands out as an exceptionally suitable dining destination, offering an authentic Italian experience that resonates with local tastes. Ohioans appreciate quality food, inviting atmospheres, and businesses that consistently deliver on their promises, and Osteria Pizzeria embodies these traits. Its reputation for serving "one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had," characterized by perfect dough and fresh, flavorful ingredients, makes it a top choice for pizza aficionados across the state. Beyond pizza, the restaurant's commitment to authentic Italian flavors shines through in its tender meatballs, savory Hungarian stuffed peppers, and well-executed pasta dishes, providing a comprehensive culinary journey.

The location in Olde Towne East adds to its appeal, situating it within a charming and accessible neighborhood that encourages leisurely visits. Whether locals are looking for a vibrant spot for a casual family dinner, a cozy setting for a date night, or a convenient option for takeout, Osteria Pizzeria’s "warm and inviting atmosphere" and diverse menu cater to a wide range of needs. While some initial experiences with pickup orders might have minor hiccups, the overall consensus points to an overwhelming satisfaction with the food quality, especially when enjoyed in the welcoming dine-in environment. For any Ohioan craving genuine Italian fare, from a perfectly crafted Margherita pizza to unique appetizers, Osteria Pizzeria offers a compelling and delicious reason to visit, solidifying its place as a cherished local Italian eatery.

Osteria Pizzeria Location

Osteria Pizzeria

Ohio Franklin County Columbus Near East Side Oak Street

892 Oak St, Columbus, OH 43205, USA

Osteria Pizzeria Reviews

Came here to experience the 4.9 star ratings and it was up to the stars 👍We can early a bit before noon, so the place was empty. Ordered meatball and 2 pizza (Numero Uno and Margherita).The meatball was flavorful , tender not packed like most other meatball we had in any Italian restaurant. Marinara sauce was fresh, good tomato flavor not sweet yet without acidic taste. Focaccia was light , airy , crusty yet soft at the same time.Both pizza came out very good also. The dough had enough chewiness, perfect thinness. It’s probably one of the best pizza I’ve ever had.Will definitely go back to try their other dishes.Service was also good, server was quick, friendly.
May 26, 2025 · Cindy S
As a local, I was excited to finally try Osteria Pizzeria, a new Italian restaurant that's been getting some buzz. My initial experience was a pickup order, and while it wasn't perfect, it's given me a good reason to plan a dine-in visit.Let's start with the good: the Hungarian stuffed peppers were outstanding. Seriously, they were a 10/10 – incredibly flavorful and a must-try, though they do pack a surprising amount of heat!On the other hand, the Italian salad (with added chicken) felt a bit underwhelming for its $17 price point. The portion seemed quite modest, especially once the dressing container was removed from the salad bowl, which made it appear even smaller. For pickup orders, it might be beneficial to package the dressing separately to optimize the perceived (and actual) volume of the salad. I think my dessert order also got mixed up; I received ice cream instead of the lemon sorbet I'd anticipated.Given these minor issues with pickup, I likely won't be choosing that option again.However, the deliciousness of the stuffed peppers has certainly piqued my interest for a full dine-in experience. I'm hopeful that a meal at the restaurant will provide a more complete and satisfying impression of Osteria Pizzeria.
Jun 29, 2025 · Jalena LeMaster
Everything from the vibes of the restaurant, to the food itself was simply lovely. I consider myself to be a pizza snob so walking into the restaurant and getting the wonderful aroma of fresh bread was a great start! I can safely say that this was the best pizza I’ve had in Columbus so far. It had a nice savory sauce, with not too much mozzarella and a good amount of basil. The crust had a really nice crisp to it. The whole restaurant was very clean which was much appreciated. Service was top notch and we had another drink at our table before the prior one was even empty. The Sicilian Hot Honey Sandwich pictured below was also a must try. A bit on the pricey side, but still worthwhile to give a shot! Overall I would say this location is a must try in Columbus and I certainly will be back.
May 29, 2025 · Lucas Barnard
Happy hour at Osteria Pizzeria was excellent. We went on the back patio which offered some partial shaded areas on a sunny afternoon. We were seated promptly and the server checked in frequently (though it was not very busy). We tried the focaccia and warm olives - the focaccia was hot, crisp on the outside, and soft on the inside, just as we like it! The accompanying olives were delicious and made a rich dipper for the focaccia. We enjoyed the discounted wine (chardonnay and sauv blanc). We ordered the salumi pizza and let me tell you, the crust was one of our favorites in Columbus! Thick, crispy, and buttery, topped with plenty of cheese, salami, and olives. To finish, we had the tiramisu, which was good, and a limoncello dessert cocktail. I would highly recommend going, especially for happy hour on the patio on a nice day!
Jul 06, 2025 · Emma P
So this is a nice place to land for a good meal. Ethan, our server, took very good care of us. The pizza, in my opinion came out a little on the charred side in appearance, but it didn't impact the flavor which was good. I would have liked more toppings, I really felt short changed for the amount you pay for what amounts to a medium pizza. The meatballs appetizer was delicious. We will definitely try again, if we're ever in the area again.
Jun 23, 2025 · Matthew Graphman