Subway in Whitehall, OH: Your Go-To for Custom-Built Sandwiches and More

Subway Photos

No photos available at the moment.

Subway Introduce

For those living in or visiting Ohio, the search for a quick, customizable, and satisfying meal often leads to a familiar name: Subway. Among its many locations across the state, the Subway at 4343 E Main St in Whitehall, OH, stands as a convenient option for residents seeking a freshly made sandwich, salad, or wrap tailored precisely to their preferences. While experiences can vary, the core appeal of Subway lies in its straightforward approach to fast-casual dining, offering a wide array of ingredients that allow you to craft your meal just the way you like it.

Subway has long been a staple for individuals and families looking for an alternative to traditional fast food, emphasizing a build-your-own model that puts the customer in control. At this Whitehall location, you'll find the classic Subway experience, featuring a selection of freshly baked breads, various protein options including meats and plant-based choices, and an extensive bar of fresh vegetables and sauces. This commitment to variety and personalization means that whether you're craving a hearty Footlong or a lighter salad, you can design a meal that fits your dietary needs and taste preferences, making it a flexible choice for everyday dining.

The Subway location at 4343 E Main St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA, offers a highly accessible spot for local residents and those commuting through the area. Situated on East Main Street, a prominent thoroughfare in Whitehall, the sandwich shop is easy to spot and reach. This main road location means it’s well-connected to various parts of Whitehall and neighboring communities within the greater Columbus metropolitan area, ensuring that a fresh sub is never too far away.

For those traveling by car, the location typically provides ample parking, making stops convenient and hassle-free. Its position on East Main Street also allows for easy ingress and egress, a significant advantage during peak dining hours. Public transportation options in Whitehall likely provide routes that pass near or directly to this address, offering an accessible dining solution for individuals without private vehicles. Whether you're heading home from work, running errands, or simply looking for a quick bite while out and about, the strategic placement of this Subway contributes to its role as a practical and accessible food destination in the local Ohio landscape.

The Subway at 4343 E Main St in Whitehall, OH, provides a range of services aimed at making your sandwich experience convenient and enjoyable.

Custom Sandwich Creation: The hallmark of Subway, allowing customers to choose their bread, protein, cheese, vegetables, and sauces to build a personalized sandwich, wrap, or salad.
Dine-In Option: A casual setting for customers who prefer to eat their meal on-site. The restaurant typically provides seating for a quick and comfortable dining experience.
Takeout Service: For those on the go, orders can be quickly prepared for takeout, providing a convenient option for enjoying Subway at home, work, or elsewhere.
Online Ordering and App Services: Many Subway locations, including this one, offer online ordering through their website or mobile app, allowing customers to place orders in advance for quick pickup, saving time during busy periods.
Catering Services: For events, meetings, or larger gatherings, Subway often provides catering options, including sandwich platters and boxed lunches, making it a practical choice for group meals.
Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner Options: This location generally serves meals throughout the day, accommodating various dining schedules from early morning to late evening, sometimes even into the early hours of the morning.
Variety of Menu Items: Beyond traditional subs, the menu includes wraps, salads, protein bowls, cookies, chips, and a selection of beverages to complement any meal.

Subway, as a global brand, often boasts certain features and highlights that draw in customers, and the Whitehall location at 4343 E Main St aims to provide these core elements, although individual experiences may vary.

Extensive Customization: One of Subway's most significant appeals is the ability to fully customize your order. You can choose from a wide variety of breads (like Artisan Italian, Hearty Multigrain), a range of proteins (including turkey, ham, steak, chicken, tuna, and veggie patties), various cheeses, and an abundance of fresh vegetables such as lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, green peppers, and olives. This level of personalization allows customers to create a sandwich that perfectly matches their taste and dietary needs.
Freshly Baked Bread: Subway is well-known for baking its bread fresh daily, which contributes to the overall flavor and texture of their sandwiches. This fresh foundation is a key component of the Subway experience.
Fresh Vegetable Selection: The visible "subway line" setup highlights the fresh vegetables available, allowing customers to see and choose their toppings. This emphasis on fresh produce appeals to those looking for a lighter or healthier fast-food option.
"Subway Series" and Signature Menu Items: Beyond building your own, Subway often features signature sandwiches, such as those in their "Subway Series," which are pre-designed combinations of popular ingredients, offering a quick choice for customers. Examples may include the All-American Club, The Monster, or Supreme Meats, providing diverse flavor profiles.
Healthier Fast Food Alternative: For many, Subway is perceived as a healthier fast-food option due to the availability of fresh vegetables, lean protein choices, and customizable portion sizes. They often provide nutritional information, aiding customers in making informed choices.
Quick Service Model: The assembly-line approach allows for efficient and quick service, making it an ideal stop for those on a tight schedule who still want a fresh, made-to-order meal.

To connect with the Subway at 4343 E Main St in Whitehall, OH, here is the relevant contact information:

Address: 4343 E Main St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA

Phone: (614) 564-9901

Mobile Phone: +1 614-564-9901

For residents of Ohio, especially those in the Whitehall area, Subway at 4343 E Main St remains a suitable and practical dining option for several key reasons. Its established presence and familiar menu offer a sense of reliability for a quick meal, particularly when time is of the essence. The central location on East Main Street makes it an incredibly convenient stop for anyone driving through or living within the surrounding neighborhoods, easily fitting into daily routines, whether it's a lunch break from work or a simple dinner solution after a busy day.

The greatest appeal for locals lies in the customizable nature of Subway's offerings. This flexibility means that every visit can be different, allowing individuals to tailor their sandwiches, wraps, or salads to their precise preferences and dietary needs. Whether you're craving a classic meatball marinara, a fresh veggie delight, or something from the newer "Subway Series" lineup, the power to choose your bread, toppings, and sauces ensures that your meal is made just for you. This level of personalization can be a significant draw for those who appreciate having control over their food choices and prefer fresh ingredients over pre-made options found elsewhere.

While individual experiences can vary, the overall convenience, broad menu options, and accessibility of this particular Subway location position it as a consistent choice for many in the community. For a quick, customizable, and generally reliable meal solution that fits seamlessly into the Ohio lifestyle, Subway in Whitehall continues to be a go-to spot for locals seeking a fresh and fast option.

Subway Location

Subway

Ohio Franklin County Whitehall Bernhards East Main Street

4343 E Main St, Whitehall, OH 43213, USA

Subway Reviews

Went in this location employees were extremely rude. Food being served had flys flying all around it. The guy in front of me was paying with a coupon and they were very extremely rude to him. They put very little veggies on the sub and when I asked for a little more they said that it was extra for more than what they were willing to put on. I will never go back to this location. They also charged me more for my sub then the price on the menu says it is.
Jul 30, 2025 · Phillip Smith
Went in this location employees were extremely rude. Food being served had flys flying all around it. The guy in front of me was paying with a coupon and they were very extremely rude to him. They put very little veggies on the sub and when I asked for a little more they said that it was extra for more than what they were willing to put on. I will never go back to this location. They also charged me more for my sub then the price on the menu says it is.
Jul 30, 2025 · Phillip Smith
I would just like to say, I placed an online order on 3/7 around 7:30pm. I came to pick it up. I saw subs in wrappers sitting on this little cooling rack near the register with receipts attached. I went to look for mine and the employee with reddish colored hair said “AHT AHT I’ll take care of that” as she was reaching towards my hand as I was looking at the receipt that read my name. Then she asked for my name, I gave her it and she put the subs in a bag and just laid them on the counter. To which I said “have a GREAT day!” And she responded to her coworker “ohh she mad” and then I walked out. I come in twice a week and the same employees are working. They have zero customer service and are just RUDE. I work in customer service, and know great customer service when I see if, and this was not that. I will never return to this subway. I’ll drive the extra distance to a different one who respects their customers. Also, I find it funny how the bottom of the receipt it reads “leave a 5 star review and POSITIVE comment on DD and get emailed a free coupon” like that is just not necessary if you serve good food/customer service, as if you did, customers would leave one regardless. Without your customers there would not be a subway or this store. Always remember that!
Mar 08, 2025 · Lexi Taylor
I would just like to say, I placed an online order on 3/7 around 7:30pm. I came to pick it up. I saw subs in wrappers sitting on this little cooling rack near the register with receipts attached. I went to look for mine and the employee with reddish colored hair said “AHT AHT I’ll take care of that” as she was reaching towards my hand as I was looking at the receipt that read my name. Then she asked for my name, I gave her it and she put the subs in a bag and just laid them on the counter. To which I said “have a GREAT day!” And she responded to her coworker “ohh she mad” and then I walked out. I come in twice a week and the same employees are working. They have zero customer service and are just RUDE. I work in customer service, and know great customer service when I see if, and this was not that. I will never return to this subway. I’ll drive the extra distance to a different one who respects their customers. Also, I find it funny how the bottom of the receipt it reads “leave a 5 star review and POSITIVE comment on DD and get emailed a free coupon” like that is just not necessary if you serve good food/customer service, as if you did, customers would leave one regardless. Without your customers there would not be a subway or this store. Always remember that!
Mar 08, 2025 · Lexi Taylor
“Let your words be seasoned with salt...” — Colossians 4:6So here it is, plain and unfiltered:I recently returned to this location, only to be reminded why I stopped coming in the first place.When I arrived, the store was relatively quiet — just a couple dining in, no one else in line. One of the sandwich artists (Kota) was removing bread from the oven, while assisting a couple who had an issue with bacon on their sandwich. To Kota’s credit, she showed the right heart and was willing to remake the sandwich after discarding the incorrect one.But then came the breakdown.Another employee — a woman of Indian ethnicity, whom I’ll respectfully refer to as the “Lead” — publicly told Kota not to remake the sandwich, claiming the error wasn’t Subway’s fault. Whether or not that’s your internal policy, this much is clear:Discussing employee disagreements in front of customers is unprofessional and disruptive.It shifted the atmosphere from service to spectacle.Now I’m still standing, waiting to be served. The line starts forming. Instead of action, there’s a huddle… and more delay.Time elapsed: 12 minutes.I finally begin to place my order — when the previous customer returns to calmly ask if their sandwich would be remade. The Lead worker interrupts him mid-sentence with a tone so sharp it cut the air.RUDE AS HELL.(Yes, I said it — and I meant it.)To her credit, Kota tried to support her coworker, but that wasn’t the moment. The customer maintained his composure and responded,“Now you're being rude. This isn’t an argument — my wife simply didn’t see the bacon listed on the special.”Time elapsed: 17 minutes.At this point, I turned to Kota and said plainly:“I need you to focus on my order, please. I’m on a schedule.”Her reply? “These customers today...”She didn’t get to finish — because I left.As I walked out, the Lead offered a half-hearted apology. I responded,“You don’t mean it.”Training Lesson for Subway:When an issue arises, DO NOT have debates on the floor. Handle concerns with discretion and professionalism.If your team is punished financially for honest mistakes — then perhaps the real mistake is where they’re working.Respect customers. Serve with urgency. Maintain integrity.If the job is a burden, then leadership should lead — or step aside.As a 30-year professional with experience in:Leadership & ManagementRetail & QSRIT SecurityCorrections & Conflict Resolution…I can say this with full confidence:The customer is not the problem. The lack of order is.I came in for a sandwich. I left with a sermon.Fix the system. Honor your employees. Respect the people who keep the doors open — your customers.Signed,A man who loves truth more than comfort.
Jul 24, 2025 · Empowered Faith Life Solutions
“Let your words be seasoned with salt...” — Colossians 4:6So here it is, plain and unfiltered:I recently returned to this location, only to be reminded why I stopped coming in the first place.When I arrived, the store was relatively quiet — just a couple dining in, no one else in line. One of the sandwich artists (Kota) was removing bread from the oven, while assisting a couple who had an issue with bacon on their sandwich. To Kota’s credit, she showed the right heart and was willing to remake the sandwich after discarding the incorrect one.But then came the breakdown.Another employee — a woman of Indian ethnicity, whom I’ll respectfully refer to as the “Lead” — publicly told Kota not to remake the sandwich, claiming the error wasn’t Subway’s fault. Whether or not that’s your internal policy, this much is clear:Discussing employee disagreements in front of customers is unprofessional and disruptive.It shifted the atmosphere from service to spectacle.Now I’m still standing, waiting to be served. The line starts forming. Instead of action, there’s a huddle… and more delay.Time elapsed: 12 minutes.I finally begin to place my order — when the previous customer returns to calmly ask if their sandwich would be remade. The Lead worker interrupts him mid-sentence with a tone so sharp it cut the air.RUDE AS HELL.(Yes, I said it — and I meant it.)To her credit, Kota tried to support her coworker, but that wasn’t the moment. The customer maintained his composure and responded,“Now you're being rude. This isn’t an argument — my wife simply didn’t see the bacon listed on the special.”Time elapsed: 17 minutes.At this point, I turned to Kota and said plainly:“I need you to focus on my order, please. I’m on a schedule.”Her reply? “These customers today...”She didn’t get to finish — because I left.As I walked out, the Lead offered a half-hearted apology. I responded,“You don’t mean it.”Training Lesson for Subway:When an issue arises, DO NOT have debates on the floor. Handle concerns with discretion and professionalism.If your team is punished financially for honest mistakes — then perhaps the real mistake is where they’re working.Respect customers. Serve with urgency. Maintain integrity.If the job is a burden, then leadership should lead — or step aside.As a 30-year professional with experience in:Leadership & ManagementRetail & QSRIT SecurityCorrections & Conflict Resolution…I can say this with full confidence:The customer is not the problem. The lack of order is.I came in for a sandwich. I left with a sermon.Fix the system. Honor your employees. Respect the people who keep the doors open — your customers.Signed,A man who loves truth more than comfort.
Jul 24, 2025 · Empowered Faith Life Solutions
This place has usually been pretty decent, however the last time I ordered here I became violently ill within a few hours of eating my food. The workers seemed like they don’t care and were very sarcastic when I went to pick up my order. After a 12 hr shift at my own job, I was looking forward to enjoying my sandwich without any problems.Not sure I will be returning to this location
Dec 17, 2024 · Alan Kolar
This place has usually been pretty decent, however the last time I ordered here I became violently ill within a few hours of eating my food. The workers seemed like they don’t care and were very sarcastic when I went to pick up my order. After a 12 hr shift at my own job, I was looking forward to enjoying my sandwich without any problems.Not sure I will be returning to this location
Dec 17, 2024 · Alan Kolar
Ordered roast beef and a cookie. Roast beef sandwich was delivered with half the ingredients spilling out of the paper and no cookie
Jun 22, 2025 · Bob Builder
Ordered roast beef and a cookie. Roast beef sandwich was delivered with half the ingredients spilling out of the paper and no cookie
Jun 22, 2025 · Bob Builder