Tommy's Pizza

- 1350 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221

For decades, Tommy's Pizza has been a cornerstone of the Columbus, Ohio, dining scene, particularly cherished by those in Upper Arlington and surrounding neighborhoods. This isn't just another pizza place; it's a local institution known for its distinctive Columbus-style pizza, characterized by a unique thin, cracker-like crust and square cuts. Tommy's Pizza has built a loyal following over the years, becoming a go-to spot for generations of families and friends seeking a reliable and satisfying meal. Beyond their iconic pizzas, they also offer a variety of other classic Italian-American comfort foods, including hearty subs and fresh salads, making it a versatile option for lunch or dinner.

What truly sets Tommy's Pizza apart is its enduring legacy and the consistent quality that keeps customers coming back. While the dining room might be cozy and bustling, especially during peak lunch hours, the attentive and friendly service ensures a pleasant experience. It's a place where the pleasant cracking sound of pizzas being cut in the kitchen is a familiar melody, signaling the arrival of a freshly baked pie. Despite occasional minor inconsistencies, the overall sentiment among long-time patrons is one of deep affection for its unique flavor profile and the comforting, familiar atmosphere it provides to the Ohio community.

Tommy's Pizza is conveniently located at 1350 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, USA. This prime address places it squarely in the heart of Upper Arlington, a well-established and easily accessible area for residents throughout Columbus and its surrounding communities. West Lane Avenue is a significant thoroughfare, making the restaurant simple to find whether you're driving from downtown, a nearby suburb, or just a short distance within Upper Arlington.

The restaurant’s location ensures good visibility and ease of access. While parking can be a consideration during peak times due to its popularity and the surrounding commercial activity, there are usually options available. Its presence in a vibrant neighborhood means it’s a natural stop for those running errands, shopping, or simply looking for a quick and satisfying meal. The familiarity of this location for many Ohio locals further enhances its accessibility, making Tommy's Pizza a staple for both planned outings and spontaneous cravings in the Columbus area.

Tommy's Pizza offers a range of services designed to provide a satisfying and convenient dining experience for its loyal customer base.

• Dine-In Service: Customers can enjoy their meals in a casual and friendly dining room, though it can get packed during busy periods. The service is often praised for being fast, attentive, and friendly.
• Lunch Specials: Tommy's Pizza serves popular lunch specials, often including enticing combinations like subs with fresh salads, providing excellent value and generous portions.
• Pizza Orders: Their signature pizzas, known for their unique thin, cracker-like crust and square cuts, are available for both dine-in and take-out. They offer various sizes and toppings to customize your pie.
• Sub Sandwiches: A beloved part of their menu, featuring classic options like meatball subs and Italian subs, often served on baked bread with fresh ingredients.
• Salads: Fresh and generously portioned salads are available, with options like garden salad featuring fresh greens and a good selection of toppings.
• Appetizers and Sides: Beyond pizza, they offer a selection of classic sides and appetizers to complement your meal.

Tommy's Pizza is renowned for several distinct features and highlights that have cemented its place as a local favorite in Columbus, Ohio.

• Unique Columbus-Style Pizza: This is arguably their most defining feature. Tommy's Pizza is famous for its thin, cracker-like crust, which offers a satisfying crispiness. The pizzas are traditionally cut into squares, a hallmark of the "Columbus style" of pizza. This distinct crust has earned decades of loyalty from patrons who find it unparalleled.
• Delicious and Generous Subs: Beyond pizza, their sub sandwiches are a major highlight. The meatball sub is particularly praised for being "juicy with decent cheese and baked bread." The generous portions and fresh ingredients make the subs a fantastic alternative or accompaniment to pizza.
• Fresh and Flavorful Salads: Even their salads receive accolades. The garden salad is noted for its freshness and tasty dressings, with specific appreciation for the quality of ingredients like black olives, which are noted for not being "extremely sour at all."
• Fast and Friendly Service: Despite the dining room often being packed, especially during lunch, customers consistently commend the staff for being attentive, friendly, and efficient. Food reportedly comes out "really fast," contributing to a positive dining experience.
• Value and Portion Sizes: Many customers are impressed by the "price and size" of their lunch specials and other menu items, indicating that Tommy's Pizza offers excellent value for the quality and quantity of food provided.
• Long-Standing Local Tradition: With over 40 years in business, Tommy's Pizza carries a significant nostalgic value for many long-time Columbus residents, representing a consistent and cherished part of their local culinary landscape.

For orders, inquiries, or to learn more about Tommy's Pizza, you can reach them using the contact information below.

Address: 1350 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, USA

Phone: (614) 486-2969

Tommy's Pizza is an excellent choice for locals in the Ohio region, particularly in Upper Arlington and the broader Columbus area, for numerous reasons. Its status as a multi-decade staple in the community speaks volumes about its consistent appeal and quality. For those who appreciate the distinctive Columbus-style thin-crust pizza, Tommy's is simply unparalleled, offering a nostalgic and genuinely unique flavor profile that sets it apart from other pizzerias. It's the kind of place where generations of families have created fond dining memories, contributing to its cherished status.

Beyond the pizza, the comprehensive menu with delicious subs, fresh salads, and satisfying lunch specials ensures there’s a perfect option for any craving or occasion. The combination of generous portions, fair pricing, and notably fast and friendly service makes it incredibly convenient and welcoming for regular visits. Whether it's a quick lunch break, a casual family dinner, or simply picking up a classic pie, Tommy's Pizza provides a comforting and reliable experience that perfectly suits the local Ohio lifestyle. It’s more than just a pizza place; it’s a taste of Columbus history and a cherished part of the community’s culinary fabric.

Tommy's Pizza

1350 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, USA