Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen

- 1725 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221

For those living in or visiting Columbus, Ohio, particularly in the Upper Arlington area, Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen is a familiar and cherished name when it comes to Italian-American comfort food. This article aims to provide a comprehensive look at this popular establishment, exploring what makes it a go-to spot for many locals seeking delicious pizza, savory strombolis, and a welcoming dining experience. From family dinners to catered events, Carsonie's has carved out a significant niche in the Columbus culinary scene.

Carsonie's has a rich history in the Columbus area, with its original Westerville location founded in 1987 by Frank Carsonie. The Upper Arlington location, which we're focusing on, opened in 2008, brought to life by his daughter, Christy, and son-in-law, David Zadnik. This multi-generational family ownership speaks volumes about the dedication to quality and tradition that Carsonie's strives to uphold. For over three decades, they've been serving up their famous strombolis and pizzas, earning a reputation for consistent flavor and hearty portions.

What truly sets Carsonie's apart for many Ohioans is its commitment to creating a memorable dining experience. Beyond the extensive menu of Italian favorites, the atmosphere, whether indoors or on their inviting patio, contributes to a relaxed and enjoyable meal. Customer reviews frequently highlight not just the great food, but also the positive ambiance and attentive service, which are crucial elements that transform a simple dinner into a pleasant outing.

This article will delve into the specifics of the Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen on West Lane Avenue, covering its convenient location, the diverse range of services offered, and the standout features that make it a favorite among local patrons. Whether you're planning a casual meal, a family gathering, or even a catered event, understanding what Carsonie's brings to the table will help you make an informed decision for your next Italian food craving in Ohio.

Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen is conveniently located at 1725 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, USA. This address places it prominently in the Upper Arlington area of Columbus, a well-established and easily navigable part of the city. West Lane Avenue is a significant thoroughfare, ensuring excellent visibility and straightforward access for residents throughout Columbus and its surrounding communities.

The restaurant's location in the Lane Avenue Shopping Center adds to its accessibility. Shopping centers typically offer ample parking, making it convenient for patrons to visit whether they are dining in or picking up a carry-out order. Its position within a vibrant commercial hub means it's often a natural stop during daily errands, shopping trips, or commutes for many Ohioans. This integration into a bustling area enhances its appeal as a convenient dining option.

For those utilizing public transportation or traveling on foot within the Upper Arlington neighborhood, the West Lane Avenue address is likely well-served by local transit routes, further expanding its reach to a broader segment of the community. The easily recognizable location and the surrounding commercial environment contribute to a sense of familiarity and ease for first-time visitors and regulars alike.

The strategic placement of Carsonie's in this accessible part of Columbus is a key factor in its suitability for locals. It allows for quick and efficient access, whether for a spontaneous meal or a planned gathering, making it a practical choice for various dining needs in the Ohio region.

• Dine-In Service: Provides a comfortable and inviting atmosphere for guests to enjoy their meals inside the restaurant.
• Patio Dining: Features outdoor seating, highly praised by customers for being "very nice," offering a pleasant alfresco dining experience during favorable weather.
• Take-Out Service: Offers convenient pick-up options for customers who prefer to enjoy their Italian favorites at home.
• Catering Services: Specializes in catering for various events, including birthdays, office happy hours, and special occasions. They are noted for being flexible and easy to work with, even offering to lend hot bags for food transport.
• Extensive Menu: Features a wide array of Italian-American dishes, including their renowned strombolis and pizzas (with traditional thick crust and thin available). Pizza options include classic Cheese, Veggie, Deluxe, Meats, The Falcon, and Frank's Favorite Pizza.
• Diverse Pasta Dishes: Offers a variety of pasta entrees such as Spaghetti and Meatballs, Baked Ziti (with meatball, sausage, and pepperoni), Lasagna, Eggplant Parmesan, Pesto Chicken Pasta, Chicken Carsonie, Ravioli, Pasta Rosa, Mediterranean Pasta, and Cajun Penne Alfredo.
• Hoagies and Sandwiches: A selection of hot and cold sandwiches including Sausage and Peppers, The Italian Stallion, Millie's Meatball Hoagie, The Godfather (steak hoagie), The Godmother (chicken parmesan hoagie), Columbus' Best Fish Sandwich, Veggie Hoagie, and Buffalo Chicken Philly.
• Appetizers and Salads: Features starters like garlic cheese bread, a range of salads (House, Caesar, Carsonie's Chopped, Cobb, Cranberry Candied Walnut Grilled Chicken, Greek, Caprese), and traditional Wedding Soup.
• Desserts: Includes unique offerings like the Nutella Stromboli, which has received positive customer feedback.
• Online Ordering and Reservations: Customers can order online for pickup or delivery and make table reservations, enhancing convenience.

• Outstanding Food Quality: Consistently praised for "great food," with specific mentions of "very good" pizza, "amazing" baked ziti (noted for flavorful sausage, pepperoni, and meatballs), and a "very good" Nutella Stromboli. This indicates a high standard across various menu items.
• Inviting Patio Dining: The availability and quality of the patio seating are frequently highlighted as a significant positive, providing a "very nice" outdoor dining experience.
• Exceptional Service: Customer reviews commend the "great service," indicating attentive and friendly staff who contribute to a positive dining atmosphere.
• Flexible and Easy Catering: For catered events, Carsonie's is noted for being "flexible and easy to work with," even going the extra mile by lending hot bags for food transport, showcasing their commitment to customer satisfaction for larger orders.
• Signature Strombolis and Pizzas: Known for their famous strombolis and a variety of pizzas, which are considered core strengths and draw a loyal customer base. They have even been recognized as an "award-winner" for their stromboli in Columbus for over 30 years.
• Homemade Comfort and Authentic Flavors: The restaurant emphasizes savoring authentic Italian flavors and providing "homemade comfort for all," reflecting a dedication to traditional preparation and a welcoming dining experience.
• Family-Owned and Operated: The business has a long history of family ownership, passing down through generations, which often contributes to a consistent quality and a personal touch in service.
• Popularity Among Locals: Described as a restaurant "cemented into the UA culture" and a "favorite of many UA residents," indicating a strong connection and high regard within the local community.

Address: 1725 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, USA

Phone: (614) 481-5555

Mobile Phone: +1 614-481-5555

For the residents of Columbus, Ohio, particularly those in the Upper Arlington area, Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen at 1725 W Lane Ave stands out as an exceptionally suitable and appealing choice for Italian dining. The restaurant's consistent delivery of "great food," encompassing everything from perfectly baked pizzas and "amazing" baked ziti to the unique Nutella Stromboli, ensures a satisfying culinary experience. This wide array of delicious options caters to diverse tastes within families and groups, making it a versatile choice for any meal occasion.

Beyond the food, the overall dining experience at Carsonie's is highly praised. The availability of a "very nice" patio provides a delightful outdoor dining option, perfect for enjoying Ohio's pleasant weather. Complementing this inviting atmosphere is the "great service," a testament to the attentive and friendly staff who make every visit enjoyable. This combination of quality food, comfortable ambiance, and excellent service fosters a loyal customer base and makes diners feel truly valued.

Carsonie's also proves to be incredibly convenient for locals, not just through its accessible location in the Lane Avenue Shopping Center but also through its robust catering services. Their flexibility and willingness to assist with event logistics, such as lending hot bags, make them an invaluable partner for local parties, office gatherings, and special occasions, simplifying meal planning for large groups in Ohio.

As a long-standing, family-owned establishment with deep roots in the community, Carsonie's represents more than just a restaurant; it's a piece of local heritage. Its consistent quality and commitment to customer satisfaction have cemented its place as a beloved "Upper Arlington favorite." For Ohioans seeking authentic Italian comfort food in a welcoming environment, whether for a casual meal or a celebratory event, Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen is an ideal and highly recommended destination.

Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen

1725 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, USA