isla Photos










isla Introduce
Columbus, Ohio, has long been a city celebrated for its diverse and growing food scene, but every so often, a new establishment arrives that truly elevates the culinary landscape. Isla, the brainchild of acclaimed Chef Andrew Smith, is precisely that kind of place. It’s not just a restaurant; it’s an experience, a journey through complex and flavorful dishes designed to delight and surprise. For discerning locals in Ohio seeking a truly exceptional night out, Isla is quickly becoming the pinnacle of fine dining.
From the moment it opened its doors, Isla has garnered significant buzz, with diners raving about its ability to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with established culinary giants in Columbus. Reviews consistently highlight its role in "elevating food scene," placing it among an elite group of establishments that are redefining what it means to dine in the city. This isn't surprising, given Chef Andrew Smith's reputation for crafting dishes with "zero misses," ensuring that "everything from the first bite to the dessert was complex and flavorful."
Beyond the exquisite food, Isla offers an atmosphere that perfectly complements its culinary artistry. Described as "contemporary, but cozy," the "vibe" is "very conducive for a wonderful venting with friend." This harmonious blend of sophistication and comfort makes Isla an ideal setting for any special occasion, a memorable date night, or simply an evening where you want to treat yourself to something truly extraordinary. For Ohio residents who appreciate the finer things in life and seek out unparalleled dining experiences, Isla promises not to disappoint. It's truly a place where culinary excellence meets a beautiful, welcoming environment.
Isla is gracefully situated at 116 E Moler St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA. This location places it within a dynamic part of Columbus, offering both a sense of local charm and convenient accessibility for residents across the city and surrounding areas in Ohio. East Moler Street is nestled in a neighborhood that balances residential quietness with proximity to central Columbus attractions, making it a desirable destination for an evening out.
While the specific nature of parking at 116 E Moler St is not detailed in public information, locations within this part of Columbus often feature a combination of street parking and potentially nearby public parking options. For an establishment of Isla's caliber, it's often advisable for patrons to consider ride-sharing services or arrive with ample time to secure parking, ensuring a smooth start to their anticipated dining experience.
The address in Columbus, Ohio, makes Isla a relatively easy destination to reach from various parts of the metropolitan area. Whether you're coming from downtown, a northern suburb, or other parts of Central Ohio, reaching East Moler Street is typically straightforward via Columbus's well-established road networks. This accessibility ensures that locals can comfortably plan a visit to Isla for a special occasion or an exquisite meal, reinforcing its position as a premier dining destination in the Ohio region.
- Exceptional Tasting Menus: Isla specializes in offering incredible tasting menus, curated by Chef Andrew Smith. These multi-course culinary journeys are designed to be complex and flavorful, providing a comprehensive and evolving dining experience from appetizers to dessert, ensuring "zero misses."
- Communal Dining Experience: While offering an exclusive feel, Isla also provides a communal dining setting. This concept, often involving shared tables or a focused interaction around the culinary presentation, aims to foster human connection and shared appreciation for the food. Prepaid reservations are often required for these experiences.
- Chef-Driven Culinary Artistry: The restaurant is helmed by Chef Andrew Smith, renowned for his involvement in shaping Columbus's culinary scene. His passion for food and community is evident in every dish, showcasing a sophisticated approach to ingredients and flavors.
- Prepaid Reservation System: Isla operates on a prepaid reservation model for its tasting menus. This system ensures a streamlined and exclusive experience, typically accommodating parties of various sizes (e.g., 1 to 14 guests for some communal settings, or 2 to 6 guests for others), with prices per person.
- Fine Dining Service: Given the caliber of the food and the overall experience, customers can expect highly attentive and professional service that complements the elevated nature of the cuisine. This ensures that the entire dining experience, from arrival to departure, is seamless and memorable.
- Beautiful and Cozy Atmosphere: The interior design and ambiance are a significant part of the experience. The restaurant offers a "contemporary, but cozy" vibe, making it "very conducive for a wonderful venting with friend" or a romantic evening. This curated atmosphere enhances the enjoyment of the exquisite food.
- Chef Andrew Smith's Culinary Genius: The absolute cornerstone of Isla's appeal is the masterful culinary direction of Chef Andrew Smith. Reviews consistently laud his ability to prepare an "incredible tasting menu with zero misses." His reputation precedes him in Columbus, and Isla is seen as the culmination of his passion and expertise, delivering complex and incredibly flavorful dishes.
- Elevated Columbus Food Scene: Isla is recognized as a key player in "elevating food scene in Columbus." It stands among a select few restaurants that are pushing the boundaries of fine dining in the city, offering experiences that compete with renowned establishments nationally, making it a point of pride for local food enthusiasts.
- Unforgettable Tasting Menus: The tasting menu is not just a meal; it's a meticulously crafted culinary journey. Every dish, from the first bite to dessert, is described as "complex and flavorful," indicating a thoughtful progression of tastes and textures that provides a truly immersive dining experience. This commitment to a cohesive and exceptional menu sets Isla apart.
- Contemporary Yet Cozy Ambiance: The restaurant's "vibe" is a significant highlight. It's described as "contemporary, but cozy," creating a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere that is "very conducive for a wonderful venting with friend" or an intimate gathering. This balance of modern aesthetics with a warm feel enhances the overall dining pleasure.
- Exceptional Overall Dining Experience: Customers consistently refer to their time at Isla as the "absolute best dining experience we have had in Columbus" and ranking "as one of the top nights out we've ever had." This high level of satisfaction speaks volumes about the quality of food, service, and atmosphere combined.
- Beautiful Space and Lovely Atmosphere: The aesthetic appeal of the restaurant is highly praised, with comments like "The space is beautiful" and "the atmosphere was lovely." This attention to detail in the physical environment contributes to the luxurious and enjoyable feeling of dining at Isla.
- Exclusive and Anticipated Reservations: The high demand for reservations, even shortly after opening, suggests its immediate popularity and exclusivity. The notion that "reservations will be at a premium" after word gets out underscores its status as a must-visit destination, creating a sense of urgency and prestige for those who secure a table.
For those eager to experience the culinary artistry of Isla in Columbus, Ohio, here is the essential contact information:
Address: 116 E Moler St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA
Currently, a publicly listed phone number for direct inquiries to Isla is not readily available. Given its nature as a high-demand, tasting menu restaurant, reservations are typically managed through online platforms. Information from sources like Tock indicates that reservations are prepaid and can be made through their dedicated booking page. For the most accurate and up-to-date information regarding availability, menu details, or specific dining experiences, it is highly recommended to visit their official website or their reservation platform. This ensures you have access to the most current details directly from the restaurant.
For the discerning residents of Columbus, Ohio, Isla represents more than just a new restaurant; it embodies a significant advancement in the city's culinary landscape, making it exceptionally suitable for locals seeking an unparalleled dining experience. Its unique approach to fine dining, combined with a focus on connection and exquisite flavors, positions it as a must-visit destination.
Firstly, Isla's role in "elevating food scene in Columbus" is a point of pride for local food enthusiasts. For Ohioans who appreciate culinary innovation and want to support establishments pushing boundaries, Isla delivers. Chef Andrew Smith's mastery in creating an "incredible tasting menu with zero misses" ensures that every visit is a journey of complex and unforgettable flavors. This commitment to consistent excellence in a multi-course format sets a new benchmark for fine dining in the city, offering locals a world-class gastronomic experience without having to travel far from home. It's a testament to Columbus's growth as a culinary destination, and Isla is at its forefront.
Secondly, the "contemporary, but cozy" vibe of the restaurant makes it exceptionally inviting for various local occasions. Whether it's a special anniversary, a celebratory dinner with friends, or simply a desire for an extraordinary night out, Isla's atmosphere is "very conducive for a wonderful venting with friend." This balance of sophisticated design with a comfortable, welcoming feel resonates with locals who seek both elegance and genuine hospitality. The communal dining aspect further fosters human connection, transforming a meal into a shared experience that strengthens community bonds among patrons.
Finally, the sheer exclusivity and high praise that Isla has garnered, even shortly after opening, positions it as a premier local destination. Reviews describing it as the "absolute best dining experience we have had in Columbus" and "one of the top nights out we've ever had" speak volumes. This level of acclaim suggests that securing reservations will become a mark of enjoying the best the city has to offer. For locals who value unique, high-quality experiences and want to be at the forefront of the city’s burgeoning culinary identity, Isla offers a truly rare and rewarding opportunity. It is a beacon of culinary excellence that enriches the Ohio dining landscape and provides an unforgettable experience for its community.
isla Location
isla
116 E Moler St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA
isla Reviews
Another incredible restaurant has opened in Columbus. In addition to Veritas, Agni, Chapman’s, Commune, and a few others, Isla is helping elevate food scene in Columbus.Per usual, Chef Andrew Smith prepared an incredible tasting menu with zero misses. Everything from the first bite to the dessert was complex and flavorful.The vibe in the restaurant was contemporary, but cozy…very conducive for a wonderful venting with friend.If you are in Columbus and in search of a fabulous meal, you need to try this place. It won’t disappoint.
Jul 02, 2025 · Athlete- EnhancementThis was the absolute best dining experience we have had in Columbus, and it ranks as one of the top nights out we've ever had. I feel so lucky we were able to experience it right after opening--after everyone figures out how great it is, reservations will be at a premium.The space is beautiful. The food was outstanding, and the atmosphere was lovely. I have not enough superlatives to express how much we loved it.
Jul 27, 2025 · Jennifer MariucciAbsolutely phenomenal. Every dish at Isla was thoughtful and flavor-packed. The tasting menu was creative without being pretentious, and the service was truly elite. Our reservation said 8 courses but we counted 11. We were a little unsure about the communal dining setup at first, but it turned out to be fun and engaging. Easily one of the best dining experiences I’ve had in Columbus.
Jul 19, 2025 · Kyle DavisThere are not enough words to capture how magical isla is. Chef Andrew, his wife Devoney, and their team have curated the most welcoming, cozy, and thoughtful space with absolutely incredible food. The focus on human connection is strong and we left isla with full stomachs, light hearts, and a table of new friends. isla is a special place created by special humans and I cannot recommend it enough!
Jul 27, 2025 · Kylee WilsonChef Andrew Smith and his wife Devoney were able to transport the intimacy and superb quality of food from their Roy’s supper club into this space. Chefs innovative dishes are well executed, extremely thoughtful and obviously delicious. What a beautiful night and experience. We can’t wait to return.
Jul 10, 2025 · Alyssa Szu-Tu
More Best Restaurants Near Me

1290 S High St, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

1471 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

183 Thurman Ave, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

195 Thurman Ave, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

193 Thurman Ave, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

197 Thurman Ave, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

292 E Gates St, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

1111 S High St, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

35 Greenlawn Ave, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

1586 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

1385 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

1006 S High St, Columbus, OH 43206, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





