Mikey's Late Night Slice

- 268 S 4th St, Columbus, OH 43215

For anyone in Ohio, especially those in the Columbus area, seeking a pizza experience that transcends the ordinary, Mikey's Late Night Slice is a name that consistently comes up. It's not just a pizza place; it's a Columbus institution, celebrated for its distinctive approach to pizza and its undeniable personality. Whether you're an out-of-towner making your first visit or a local with a long-standing love affair with their pies, Mikey's promises a memorable culinary adventure.

Mikey's Late Night Slice has carved out a unique niche in the Columbus dining scene by focusing on high-quality, New York-style inspired pizza, often sold by the generous slice. This concept was born out of a desire to offer something different and delicious for late-night cravings, but its appeal has since broadened to encompass lunch, dinner, and everything in between. The establishment prides itself on creating a culture around "raving fans, dedicated employees, and quality food," aiming for every visit to be an "experience to visit."

What truly sets Mikey's apart, as many loyal customers attest, is the exceptional quality and innovative flavor profiles of their pizzas. The crust often receives high praise for its thin crispness and the perfect char from the oven. Toppings are described as "otherworldly," creating "a whirl of whimsy" in the mouth. This isn't just hyperbole; it's a reflection of a commitment to unique recipes and ingredients that make each slice stand out. From their signature "Plain-Ass Pepperoni" to their ever-changing "Pizza-of-the-Week" (PoW) creations, there's always something exciting to discover.

Beyond the food, the vibrant energy of Mikey's Late Night Slice is a key part of its charm. The staff are frequently described as friendly, welcoming, and helpful, ready to guide first-timers through the menu and offer advice. This engaging atmosphere, combined with the undeniably delicious pizza, ensures that Mikey's Late Night Slice consistently "sets the bar high" for dining experiences in Columbus. It's a testament to why this local spot has earned a reputation that extends far beyond Ohio's borders.

Mikey's Late Night Slice's 4th & Main location is conveniently situated at 268 S 4th St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA. This address places it squarely in the bustling heart of downtown Columbus, making it highly accessible for a wide array of local residents, professionals, and visitors alike.

For those navigating downtown on foot, the restaurant is easily walkable from numerous office buildings, residential complexes, and entertainment venues. Its presence on South 4th Street, a well-known thoroughfare, ensures that it's easy to find whether you're heading to or from work, or enjoying the city's nightlife. Public transportation options are robust in this area, with multiple COTA bus stops within a short distance, providing convenient access from various neighborhoods across Columbus.

While downtown parking can sometimes require planning, the central location often means there are public parking garages and metered street parking options nearby, although availability can vary. Importantly, this particular Mikey's location is known for its "Pizza & Booze" setup, offering a full bar area in addition to its pizza offerings. This combination further enhances its appeal as a convenient spot for an evening out. Furthermore, Mikey's is recognized for its inclusive dining experiences, being a pioneer in offering both gluten-free and vegan specialty pizzas, ensuring accessibility for diverse dietary needs. Its inviting atmosphere, often described as having a quirky charm with eclectic decor, adds to its overall appeal and welcoming nature for all patrons.

• Dine-in Service: Enjoy your pizza and drinks in a vibrant, quirky, and relaxed atmosphere.
• Pizza by the Slice: A core offering, allowing customers to quickly grab a single, generous slice of various pizza options, perfect for a quick lunch or late-night snack.
• Whole Pizzas: Full 18-inch pies available for those looking to feed a group or enjoy leftovers.
• Extensive Menu: Features a wide range of pizza choices, including "Plain-Ass Pepperoni," "Spicy-Ass Pepperoni," "Cheese w/ Fresh Basil," "Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic," "Mikey's Favorite," "THICC-Ass Pepperoni," "P.M.S." (Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Sausage), "Weggie," "Garbàge," and "Kowalski."
• Pizza-of-the-Week (PoW): A rotating special featuring unique and inventive pizza creations that keep the menu fresh and exciting.
• Vegan Options: Pioneers in vegan specialty pizzas, offering options like "Vegan BBQ Chick'n" and "Vegan Pepperoni" with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
• Gluten-Free Options: Accommodating for gluten sensitivities with gluten-free crusts available for whole pizzas (though a 20-minute wait is typical for preparation).
• Full Bar & Cocktails: This "Pizza & Booze" location features a bar area with table service, 10 taps of craft beer, and "designer cocktails."
• Late-Night Hours: Lives up to its name by operating late into the night, making it a popular spot after local bars close. (e.g., Sun-Thurs 11:00 AM - 2:30 AM; Fri-Sat 11:00 AM - 3:00 AM at the 4th & Main location).
• Online Ordering & Delivery: Offers convenient online ordering through their website and popular delivery platforms like Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Grubhub.
• Catering: Provides catering services for various events, allowing you to bring Mikey's unique pizza experience to your gathering.
• Sides & Extras: Menu includes breadsticks, Cheezy-Sticks, Cinna-Sticks, Unicorn Bars, and various dipping sauces (Garlic Sauce, Unicorn Sauce, Ranch, Vegan Ranch).

• Legendary Pizza Quality: Consistently praised for having "very likely the best pizza," with a thin, crispy, and charred crust, and "otherworldly" toppings.
• Unique & Playful Menu: Features creatively named pizzas and a constantly rotating Pizza-of-the-Week (PoW) that keeps the offerings fresh and exciting.
• Late-Night Availability: One of its defining features, catering to the late-night crowd and providing hot, delicious food into the early morning hours.
• Inclusive Options: A pioneer in offering excellent vegan and gluten-free pizza options, making it accessible for diverse dietary needs.
• Vibrant & Quirky Atmosphere: The decor and overall vibe are described as fun, relaxed, and eclectic, creating an engaging experience beyond just the food.
• Exceptional Customer Service: Staff are consistently highlighted for being friendly, welcoming, helpful, and energetic, enhancing the overall dining experience.
• Convenient Downtown Location: Situated prominently on S 4th St, making it easily accessible for locals and visitors in the heart of Columbus.
• Full Bar Service: This specific location offers a wide selection of alcoholic beverages, including craft beers on tap and designer cocktails, complementing the pizza experience.
• Local Columbus Icon: Widely recognized and celebrated as a staple of the Columbus food scene, often winning local awards for its pizza and late-night offerings.

Address: 268 S 4th St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA

Phone: (614) 737-3801

For residents of Ohio, especially those in the bustling city of Columbus, Mikey's Late Night Slice on South 4th Street isn't just a pizza place; it's an integral part of the city's culinary landscape. Its distinct personality and unwavering commitment to quality make it an exceptionally suitable and cherished establishment for the local community. The prime downtown location ensures unparalleled accessibility, whether you're a professional grabbing a quick lunch, a group of friends kicking off an evening, or someone simply seeking a satisfying bite after a night out. Its ability to serve delicious, fresh pizza well into the late hours perfectly aligns with the varied schedules and cravings of urban life.

What truly resonates with locals is the extraordinary quality of the pizza itself. Descriptions from patrons, even those from out of town, elevate Mikey's pizza to an almost legendary status. The thin, crisp, and charred crust, coupled with imaginative and flavorful toppings, creates a taste experience that is genuinely unique and highly addictive. The ever-changing "Pizza-of-the-Week" keeps the menu fresh and exciting, providing a continuous reason for repeat visits and encouraging culinary adventure within the comfort of a familiar favorite. Furthermore, Mikey's commitment to inclusivity, with pioneering vegan and gluten-free options, ensures that a wider segment of the Columbus community can enjoy their acclaimed pies.

Beyond the food, the vibrant and welcoming atmosphere, bolstered by friendly and helpful staff, makes every visit a positive experience. The energy of the place, combined with the assurance of consistently high-quality food, fosters a strong connection with its patrons. Mikey's isn't just a convenient pizza joint; it’s a place that understands and caters to the diverse needs and desires of the Columbus populace, making it an indispensable part of the local dining scene and a place where Ohioans can always find a slice of "otherworldly" deliciousness.

Mikey's Late Night Slice

268 S 4th St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA