Ted's Montana Grill: Columbus's Premier Destination for Upscale American Fare

Ted's Montana Grill Introduce

In the bustling heart of Columbus, Ohio, where the energy of sports and entertainment converges, finding a restaurant that perfectly blends a warm, welcoming atmosphere with high-quality, upscale American food can be a challenge. That's where Ted's Montana Grill comes in. This isn't just another American restaurant; it's a destination that has become a local staple, especially for those heading to an event at Nationwide Arena or Huntington Park. Known for its unique menu featuring premium bison and classic beef dishes, Ted's provides a dining experience that feels both familiar and elevated. The restaurant's philosophy is rooted in using fresh, made-from-scratch ingredients, ensuring that every dish, from the iconic bison burger to the hearty steaks, is a memorable one. While it can get busy, especially on game nights, the staff's efficiency and friendly demeanor consistently shine through, making a visit here a pleasure. This article will provide a comprehensive overview of what makes Ted's Montana Grill a beloved part of the Columbus community, exploring its prime location, exceptional menu offerings, and the reasons why it's such a suitable and appealing choice for locals in Ohio.

Ted's Montana Grill is perfectly situated at 191 W Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH 43215, USA, placing it at the epicenter of the Arena District. This is a significant advantage for locals who are fans of the Columbus Blue Jackets or the Columbus Clippers, as it is just a short walk from both Nationwide Arena and Huntington Park. The location's convenience makes it the go-to spot for pre-game or post-game meals and drinks. Accessibility is a major highlight; the restaurant is surrounded by numerous parking garages and lots, making it easy for those driving to find a place to park. The area is also well-connected by public transportation, so it's a breeze to get to for those who live or work downtown. The vibrant, high-energy atmosphere of the Arena District, particularly on game nights, adds to the overall dining experience at Ted's. You can feel the excitement of the crowd, and the restaurant serves as a perfect starting point for a night of entertainment. This prime location is a key reason why Ted's has become a part of the local ritual for many Ohioans. It’s not just about the food; it's about the entire experience of being in the center of Columbus's sports and entertainment heart. The location allows for a seamless transition from a great meal to a fun event, which is a convenience that is highly valued by the local community.

Ted's Montana Grill provides a variety of services to ensure a top-notch dining experience for its customers. A key service is its commitment to happy hour, which runs from Monday to Friday, typically from 3 PM to 6:30 PM. This is a great opportunity for locals to enjoy discounted drinks and appetizers, which is especially popular with the after-work crowd and those looking to save a little before a game. The restaurant also has a friendly and efficient staff. Bartenders, for example, are known for their ability to handle busy periods with grace, squeezing in happy hour drink orders and taking food orders promptly. This level of attentiveness and speed is particularly appreciated by customers who are on a tight schedule to make it to a game on time. Ted's menu itself is a service, as it caters to a wide range of tastes and dietary needs. They offer a selection of classic American dishes, including burgers, steaks, and other entrees, with the option to substitute bison for beef on many items. They also offer made-from-scratch side dishes and a variety of appetizers. For those who prefer to dine at home, Ted's offers delivery through popular platforms, making it easy to enjoy their delicious food from the comfort of your couch. They also cater to different dining experiences, whether it's a sit-down meal for a table or grabbing a seat at the bar. The staff is well-trained and knowledgeable about the menu, and they are able to handle special requests, such as dietary allergies, with care and expertise. This dedication to customer satisfaction is a core part of their service model.

Here are some of the standout features and highlights that make Ted's Montana Grill a local favorite:

Premium Bison Burgers: The bison burger is the star of the show. Customers consistently rave about them, noting that they are "perfectly cooked" and a "must-try." The unique flavor and lean quality of the bison meat are what set these burgers apart.
Exceptional Staff and Service: The waitstaff and bartenders are consistently praised for being "good," "sweet," and efficient. Their ability to handle large crowds and busy periods with a smile and a prompt approach is a major highlight, especially in the fast-paced Arena District.
Made-from-Scratch Food: Ted's prides itself on using fresh ingredients and making everything from scratch. This commitment to quality is evident in the food's flavor and is a key reason why patrons return again and again. Even the complimentary pickles are noted as being very good.
A Must-Try Appetizer: The onion rings are a frequently mentioned highlight and are described by a customer as a "must!" This popular appetizer is a perfect way to start a meal or share with a group.
Great Cocktail and Drink Menu: The bar menu is another feature that gets high marks. Customers love the cocktails, with the "green and hot" and "george’s classic cadillac" being specifically mentioned as "amazing." The "giant and ice cold" beers are also a big draw.
Perfect for Game Nights: The restaurant's location and efficient service make it the ideal place to grab an "upscale" meal before a Blue Jackets or Clippers game. The staff is well-aware of game times and works to ensure customers get their food quickly, allowing them to make it to the game on time.

For those looking to get in touch with Ted's Montana Grill, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 191 W Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH 43215, USA

Phone: (614) 227-0013

Ted's Montana Grill is a highly suitable place for locals in the Ohio region, particularly in Columbus, for a host of compelling reasons. Its prime location in the Arena District makes it a perfect hub for sports fans and concert-goers, providing a convenient and high-quality dining option right in the center of the action. The menu offers a fantastic combination of familiar American comfort food and unique options like bison, catering to a wide range of palates. The commitment to fresh, made-from-scratch food sets it apart from more generic chain restaurants, giving locals a taste of something special. Moreover, the restaurant's professional and efficient staff ensures that the dining experience is a pleasant one, even on the busiest of nights. For a local Ohioan, Ted's represents a reliable and satisfying option for a variety of occasions, from a quick bite before a game to a more leisurely, upscale dinner. It's a place where you can count on great food, a friendly atmosphere, and a sense of community that is woven into the fabric of the Arena District. The dedication to quality, from the perfectly cooked bison burgers to the sweet and attentive service, is what makes Ted's Montana Grill more than just a restaurant; it’s a cherished part of the Columbus dining scene, and a destination that truly feels like home for many in the community.

Ted's Montana Grill Menu

Starters $
Bar None Bison Sliders US$19.75
Four bison sliders, topped with American cheese and served on a warm yeast roll with a side of homemade chips.
St. Phillip's Island Crab Cake US$20.75
Jumbo lump crab, guacamole, kale salad.
Bar None Beef Sliders US$17.25
Four beef sliders, topped with American cheese and served on a warm yeast roll with a side of homemade chips.
Grilled Shrimp US$19.00
Ciabatta toast, arugula, lemon vinaigrette
Karen's "Flying-D" Bison Chili US$0.00
Hearty flavors of slow-cooked bison, tangy tomatoes, ranch-style beans and original spices, topped with cheddar cheese, red onion and freshly sliced jalapeños.
Salt & Pepper Onion Rings US$15.00
Hand-breaded, horseradish sauce.
Homemade Chips US$12.75
Fresh-cut chips served with scratch-made ranch onion dip.
Bison Nachos US$18.50
Pepper jack, bison chili, fresh toppings.

Steaks
Beef Delmonico Ribeye (14 Oz) US$48.50
Aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.
Beef Filet (8 Oz) US$48.50
Aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.
Bison Delmonico Ribeye (14 Oz) US$55.25
Aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.
Bison New York Strip (12 Oz) US$45.00
(11oz) Bison New York Strip aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.
Beef New York Strip (12 Oz) US$38.00
(12oz) Certified Angus Beef® New York Strip aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.
Bison Filet (8 Oz) US$54.25
Aged, hand-cut in our on-premise butcher shop, seasoned and finished with lemon butter, choice of two sides.

Sips
Boylan Orange Soda US$5.25
Sprite US$4.75
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
Boylan’s Root Beer US$5.25
Boylan Crème Soda US$5.25
Diet Coke US$4.75
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Coca-Cola Classic US$4.75
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Boylan Black Cherry US$5.25
Bottled Sparkling Water US$5.25
Bottled Spring Water US$5.25

Desserts
Vanilla Ice Cream US$7.00
Brownie US$12.75
Caramel sauce, coffee icing, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, kahlua fudge sauce.
Strawberry Shortcake US$15.00
Fresh-baked sweet drop biscuits, topped with vanilla ice cream, housemade whipped cream and fresh strawberries
Ted's Wildberry Cheesecake US$11.50
Cheesecake topped with wildberries and finished with a buttery graham cracker crust, topped with hand-whipped cream.

Kids
Kid's Grilled Cheese US$9.25
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.
Kid's Mac N' Cheese US$9.25
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.
Kid's Chicken Tenders US$11.50
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.
Kid’s Bison Steak US$16.75
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.
Kid’s Salmon US$16.25
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.
Kid’s Beef Steak US$14.50
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.
Kid's Beef Cheeseburger US$10.50
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.
Kid's Meatloaf US$15.25
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink
Kid's Grilled Chicken US$11.50
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.
Kid's Bison Cheeseburger US$12.75
Choice of buttered carrots or fresh-cut fries. Served with a drink.

Sides
Buttered Carrots US$8.25
Buttered carrots.
Kale Salad US$8.25
Kale Salad
Asparagus US$9.25
Roasted Asparagus
Fresh Cut French Fries US$8.25
Our proprietary, gluten-free fries.
Garlic Mashed Potatoes US$8.25
Garlic mashed potatoes with gravy.
Baked Potato (AFTER 4PM ONLY) US$8.25
Salt & Pepper Onion Rings. US$8.25
Hand-breaded, horseradish sauce.
50/50 Fries & Onion Rings US$8.25
Half fresh-cut fries, half hand-breaded onion rings.
Parmesan Roasted Broccoli US$8.25
Parmesan roasted broccoli.

Seafood
Absolute Best Fish Sandwich US$20.25
Lightly breaded cod, lettuce with chive caper tartar sauce on a cracked wheat bun, served with kale salad and fresh-cut fries.
9 Oz Salmon US$34.00
Fresh salmon seasoned with salt and pepper and roasted on a cedar plank, served with garlic mashed potatoes, Parmesan roasted broccoli and a side of horseradish sauce.
St. Phillip's Crab Cakes US$42.75
Southwestern seasoned crab cakes, served with a side of guacamole, Parmesan roasted broccoli and kale salad.
7 Oz Salmon US$30.50
Fresh salmon seasoned with salt and pepper and roasted on a cedar plank, served with garlic mashed potatoes, Parmesan roasted broccoli and a side of horseradish sauce.

Side Salads
Chili And Caesar Salad US$21.50
Karen's "Flying-D" bison chili with a Caesar side salad.
Chili And House Salad US$21.50
Karen's "Flying-D" bison chili with a house side salad.
House Salad US$9.25
Iceberg, romaine, organic spring mix, cucumber, vine-ripened tomato, croutons and red onion with your choice of housemade dressing.
Caesar Salad US$9.25
Romaine, Parmesan, croutons, “eggless” Caesar dressing.
Chili And Wedge Salad US$24.75
"Flying-D" bison chili with a wedge side salad.
Wedge US$12.75
Bacon, vine-ripened tomato.

Poultry
Brick Chicken Plate US$24.25
All-natural chicken breast, expertly seasoned and cooked on our cast iron grill to perfection. Served with garlic mashed potatoes and parmesan roasted broccoli.
Snowcrest Chicken Fried US$19.75
Fried all-natural chicken breast, mustard remoulade, lettuce, vine-ripened tomato, dill pickle chips on a cracked wheat bun with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Snowcrest Chicken Grilled US$19.75
Grilled all-natural chicken breast, mustard remoulade, lettuce, vine-ripened tomato, dill pickle chips on a cracked wheat bun with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Chicken Green & Hot Sandwich US$18.50
Chicken breast topped with pepper jack, grilled jalapeñoes, guacamole and Sriracha aioli with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Chicken Skinny Dip Sandwich US$18.00
Bunless, avocado, with vine-ripened tomatoes and your choice of side.
Red Rock Chicken Sandwich US$19.75
All-natural grilled chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, jalapeñoes, cilantro, fried onion straws and Z-sauce served on ciabatta bread with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.

Entrée Salads
Grilled Caesar US$22.00
Romaine, Parmesan, croutons, “eggless” Caesar dressing with your choice of cedar plank salmon or chicken.
Balsamic Blue Steak Salad US$25.50
Premium steak, iceberg, romaine, organic spring mix, cucumber, blue cheese, bacon, vine-ripened tomato, balsamic reduction, topped with onion straws.
Chicken Chopped Salad US$0.00
Iceberg, grilled chicken, roasted corn, garbanzo beans, vine-ripened tomato, green pepper, red onion, fresh chopped basil, cucumber, bacon, tossed in fresh basil vinaigrette dressing.
Big Sky Grilled Salad US$22.00
Iceberg, romaine, organic spring mix, bacon, cheddar, egg, vine-ripened tomato, avocado and housemade croutons with your choice of grilled chicken, beef burger, bison burger or cedar plank salmon.

Bison
Bison Short Ribs US$33.50
Slow-braised bison ribs, served with garlic mashed potatoes and buttered carrots.
Bison Brisket US$33.50
Pulled bison brisket, gravy, served with garlic mashed potatoes and buttered carrots.
Meatloaf Sandwich US$22.00
Bison meatloaf sandwich topped with pepper jack, grilled onions on ciabatta bread, served with fresh-cut fries.
Bison Meatloaf US$28.75
Bison meatloaf with gravy served with garlic mashed potatoes and buttered carrots.

Burgers
Naked Burger US$0.00
Perfectly simple bison or beef burger with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Avalon Burger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger with Gruyère and blue cheese, bacon-caramelized onions, roasted garlic aioli and baby arugula with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Green And Hot Burger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger topped with pepper jack, grilled jalapeñoes, guacamole and Sriracha aioli with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
George's Cadillac Burger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger topped with BBQ sauce, cheddar, bacon, served with a side of mustard and fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Ted's Bacon Cheeseburger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger topped with Cheddar or Swiss, smoky bacon and grilled onions with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Delicious Duo US$19.00
Two 3oz burgers (bison and beef), American cheese, lettuce, tomato, dill pickle, mustard remoulade on a sesame bun, served with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Smashburger US$0.00
Two 3oz. patties, American, diced red onions, sweet and spicy pickles, Ted’s ranch sauce on a buttered brioche bun
Red Rock Burger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger topped with pepper jack, jalapeñoes, cilantro, onion straws and Z-sauce served on ciabatta bread with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Knife & Fork Chili Cheese US$0.00
Bison or Beef burger topped with pepper jack, cheddar, bison chili, tomato, jalapeño, red onion, sour cream, ciabatta
Veggie Burger US$20.25
(Vegan) Lettuce, tomato, roasted garlic aioli, cracked wheat bun
Cheeseburger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger topped with your choice of American, cheddar, pepper jack or Swiss cheese with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Canyon Creek US$0.00
Cheddar, bacon, jalapeño, raspberry jam, fried egg. beef or bison.
Skinny Dip Burger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger served bunless with avocado, vine-ripened tomatoes and kale salad.
Blue Creek Burger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger topped with Blue cheese and smoky bacon with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
Swiss & Mushroom Burger US$0.00
Bison or beef burger topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms and sour cream with fresh-cut fries or your choice of side.
1977 Americas Cup US$0.00
American, bacon, grilled onion, mushroom, fried egg. beef or bison. items are served raw, or undercooked, or may contain raw or undercooked ingredients. consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Ted's Montana Grill Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great wine list

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy-hour drinks
Happy-hour food
Spirits
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar on site
Toilet

Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy

Crowd
Family friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Paid multi-storey car park
Paid street parking

Ted's Montana Grill Photos

Ted's Montana Grill Location

Ted's Montana Grill

Ohio Franklin County Columbus Arena District West Nationwide Boulevard

191 W Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH 43215, USA

Ted's Montana Grill Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 1293 user reviews.

bisongameblue jacketsbartendermashed potatoesribeyeny stripasparagushuckleberrykale salad

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Ted’s is a great place to grab upscale food before a Blue Jackets game or Clippers game. Tonight both teams were home so Ted’s was busy. We arrived at the restaurant around 6 - just in time for one happy hour drink. The wait for a table was 45 minutes, but we, fortunately, were able to grab a bar seat.Our bartender was good. He squeezed in our happy hour drink and took our food order at the same time so our bison burger, which was perfectly cooked, arrived within eight minutes. That was so awesome given we wanted to get to the game with time to order drinks.Who doesn’t love a perfectly cooked bison burger? I love bison and I love Ted’s.
April 01 · bobbie Stonerock
onion rings are a must! food was super fresh and our server was the sweetest. we split a green and hot and george’s classic cadillac. both were amazing
July 27 · jolie carroll
The Mrs and I decided to try bison meet for the first time before going to Nationwide for an event. I'd highly suggest making a reservation if you're also doing an event. It's possible to receive seating at the bar (pictured below) but it's first come first serve. They were able to graciously seat us earlier than our reservation making it perfect in time for our event! Cocktails were absolutely great. Both the blackberry smash and the new fashioned were both excellent, might I add, once mixed well enough. They definitely needed some more mixture but otherwise great. Buffalo nachos were also a great appetizer. Bison filet was a fantastic cut and I always order "as pink as possible" which includes 'blue rare' if a restaurant will do it. I was very satisfied with the level of pink (pictured). The onion rings and fries were both very good and I was a fan. The brussel sprouts were the chef special side for the evening and I must say I was a bit disappointed. They weren't bad, but for being the special side of the evening and an additional upcharge they definitely didn't deliver like I expected. Overall the brussel sprouts are not the news flash. You'll definitely enjoy your time here and the convenience of being next to the arena. Still highly recommend.
February 05 · Gatlin Weyer
Austin is a very good server. The food was brought out hot. Even though they ran out of a few beers, it didn't really matter because that stuff is just a fact of life. The nachos were packed with meat and cheese. We were seated quickly, and our drinks were served quickly. The buffalo meatloaf was very good, covered with tasty gravy. The complimentary pickles are very good and a nice touch.
October 21 · Thomas Kemmett
We stopped in for a drink and appetizers. The waitress was wonderful! Based on our conversation, she gave me a wine suggestion and I loved it! We shared Bar None Sliders and they were fantastic. We also had Grilled Shrimp on Ciabatta Toast. We all enjoyed the appetizers and will be back for dinner soon. The Arena District gets super busy so it’s a good idea to make reservations. The have outdoor patio as well as indoor and bar dining.
July 29 · Lisa B