Terita's Pizza

- 3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224

Hey there, Ohio pizza enthusiasts! When it comes to finding truly exceptional pizza, we know you've got your preferences. But if you haven't experienced Terita's Pizza on Cleveland Avenue in Columbus, you might be missing out on what many locals, and even visitors from afar, consider some of the best pizza they've ever tasted. This isn't just another pizza place; it's a long-standing, family-owned institution that has been perfecting its craft since 1959, serving up a distinct "Columbus-style" pizza that has garnered a fiercely loyal following.

For us living in Ohio, particularly in the Columbus area, Terita's Pizza represents a comforting blend of tradition, quality, and flavor that's hard to beat. It’s the kind of place that comes highly recommended by word-of-mouth, even making its way onto local sports radio discussions about the best pizza in town. What sets it apart is its unique approach: a cracker-thin crust that's perfectly crisp on the rim yet delightfully chewy on the inside, a sauce with just the right balance of kick and sweetness, and a cheese blend that’s consistently praised for its deliciousness. Whether you’re a devout pepperoni lover or prefer a simple plain cheese, Terita's manages to elevate every bite into a memorable experience, cementing its status as a must-try for any true pizza connoisseur in our beloved Buckeye State.

Terita's Pizza is conveniently located at 3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224, USA. This address places it squarely on a well-known and easily accessible thoroughfare in Columbus. Cleveland Avenue is a major artery, making it straightforward to reach Terita's from various parts of the city, including nearby neighborhoods like Clintonville and Westerville, as well as areas around The Ohio State University. Its presence in a commercial area ensures that there's typically ample parking available, which is a significant plus for any local establishment where convenience is key. While reviews note that there might not be extensive room for sitting inside, the focus here is clearly on efficient service for pickup, making it perfect for those who want to grab their gourmet pizza and enjoy it in the comfort of their own home. Its long-standing presence and prominent location make it a recognizable and dependable landmark for top-notch pizza in Ohio.

Terita's Pizza offers a focused menu, allowing them to excel in their specialty: authentic Columbus-style pizza, alongside a few complementary items. Here are the key services and offerings you can expect:

• Columbus-Style Pizza: Their primary offering is pizza characterized by a thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and a square cut (also known as tavern cut or party cut). This style is a local favorite.
• Customizable Pizzas: Customers can build their own pizzas with a wide array of classic toppings including pepperoni, homemade sausage, bacon, capicola (ham), onions, green peppers, mushrooms, olives, hot peppers, and pineapple. Premium toppings like fajita-style chicken and ground beef are also available.
• Specialty Pizzas: Terita's offers several popular specialty pizzas, such as:
  • Terita's Special: Topped with pepperoni, mushrooms, homemade sausage, green peppers, and onions.
  • Terita's Meat Lovers: Featuring pepperoni, ham, sausage, and bacon.
  • Terita's Veggie: Loaded with mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, and tomatoes.
  • Terita's White Pizza: A slightly thicker crust with olive oil, garlic, oregano, provolone, and Romano cheese.
  • Terita's Hawaiian: Generously topped with ham and pineapple.
  • Terita's Chicken Special: With fajita chicken, tomato, onions, and green peppers.
• Gluten-Free Crust: A 10-inch gluten-free crust option is available for those with dietary restrictions.
• Sub Sandwiches: A selection of hot and cold subs including Italian, Double Italian, Veggie, Ham & Cheese, Turkey, Meatball, and their Homemade Sausage Sub.
• Wings: Oven-roasted wings available in BBQ, spicy, and plain (oven roasted) flavors, served with a side of bleu cheese.
• Spaghetti Dinner: A classic offering that includes spaghetti with meatballs, garlic bread, and a side salad.
• Garlic Bread: Available plain or with cheese as a side appetizer.
• Takeout & Pickup: The primary service model is efficient takeout, allowing customers to quickly pick up their orders.
• Online Ordering: Customers can place orders through their website or third-party delivery services like Uber Eats and Slice.

Terita's Pizza holds a special place in the hearts of many Columbus locals, thanks to several distinguishing features and highlights:

• Iconic Columbus-Style Pizza: Terita's is widely recognized for perfecting the "Columbus-style" pizza – a thin, crispy crust with edge-to-edge toppings cut into squares. This specific style is a beloved local tradition and a key draw.
• Exceptional Crust: Customers consistently praise the "cracker thin" crust, noting its perfect crispiness on the rim and chewy interior. This distinctive texture is a major highlight.
• Unique and Flavorful Sauce: The pizza sauce is frequently mentioned for having "a slight kick and the perfect amount of sweet," creating a well-balanced flavor profile that contributes significantly to the overall taste.
• High-Quality Cheese Blend: Reviewers often highlight the "way good" cheese blend, indicating that the quality and taste of their cheese are superior and contribute to the pizza's deliciousness.
• Family-Owned Since 1959: Being a long-standing, family-run operation since 1959, Terita's carries a sense of tradition and community, fostering trust and loyalty among its customer base.
• Friendly and Welcoming Staff: Customer experiences consistently mention the staff, like "Mike," for being "real cool," "down to earth," and welcoming, creating a positive interaction for patrons.
• Consistent Excellence: Many customers declare it "the best pizza I’ve had anywhere" and state they "can’t recall ever having had a better pizza," testifying to the consistent high quality and memorable taste.
• Great Value: Despite the high quality, the pizza is considered reasonably priced, especially given the generous toppings and overall satisfaction.
• Focused Menu: By specializing primarily in pizza and a few complementary items, Terita's maintains a strong focus on quality and efficiency in its core offerings.

For those in Ohio eager to experience the legendary pizza at Terita's Pizza, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224, USA

Phone: (614) 475-2100

In conclusion, Terita's Pizza on Cleveland Avenue is undeniably a standout choice for locals across Ohio, particularly in the Columbus area. Its long-standing history as a family-owned pizzeria since 1959 speaks volumes about its enduring quality and local appeal. What makes it truly suitable for us Ohioans is its mastery of the distinct "Columbus-style" thin-crust pizza, complete with a perfectly balanced sauce and delicious cheese blend that earns consistent rave reviews. While it's primarily a takeout establishment, the welcoming staff and efficient service ensure a smooth experience. For anyone seeking a genuinely exceptional pizza that goes beyond the ordinary, offering a taste of local tradition and consistent deliciousness, Terita's Pizza is an absolute must-visit right here in our vibrant Columbus community. It's more than just a meal; it's a taste of local history and a true pizza revelation.

Terita's Pizza

3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224, USA