PJs Pizza Introduce
For anyone living in or visiting Columbus, Ohio, the search for a great pizza place is a top priority. While the city is home to numerous national chains, there's a special charm and quality that comes from a locally owned and operated pizzeria. PJs Pizza, located on S High Street, is one such place that has earned a special place in the hearts of its community. This article is a comprehensive look at what makes PJs Pizza a cherished local favorite. We'll explore its convenient location, the wide range of services it offers, its standout features, and why it's the perfect spot for locals seeking a delicious, affordable, and welcoming dining experience.
PJs Pizza is a restaurant that has built its reputation on more than just great food; it has cultivated an atmosphere of warmth and genuine hospitality. Customer reviews consistently highlight the kind and respectful nature of the employees, creating a dining environment that feels inviting and comfortable. One review praised the "very kind employees" and a "very clean place to sit and eat," further noting that the atmosphere is "quiet, respectful, great paced and great hospitality!" This kind of feedback is a testament to the business's commitment to its customers, treating each person not just as a transaction, but as a valued member of the community. While some might consider it a great alternative to well-known brands, as one local puts it, "other than Donatos Pizza, Pj's Pizza would be my second favorite pizza place," showing that it holds its own against even the biggest names in the pizza world. It's a place that goes "the extra mile to please," as another grateful customer noted, specifically thanking them for making their subs exactly as requested. This attention to detail and customer satisfaction is what transforms a simple pizza joint into a true neighborhood staple.
PJs Pizza is conveniently located at 3266 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA. South High Street is a major road in Columbus, making the restaurant easily accessible for residents of the South Side and beyond. This prime location ensures that PJs Pizza is a practical choice for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a convenient takeout order. Its spot on a well-known street means it's easy to find, whether you're a long-time resident or just looking for a new pizza place to try.
The accessibility of the restaurant extends to its physical location. For those driving, there is typically parking available, allowing for a hassle-free visit. Its presence in a residential-adjacent area means it's a natural hub for community gatherings and an easy stop for people on their way home. The address on South High Street is more than just a pin on a map; it's a signal to locals that this is a neighborhood-friendly spot where great food is always within reach. This strategic location solidifies PJs Pizza as a key player in the local dining scene, providing a reliable and accessible option for pizza lovers throughout the area.
PJs Pizza offers a variety of services designed to meet the diverse needs of its customer base, from those dining in to those who prefer to enjoy their food at home.
Dine-In Service: With a clean and quiet atmosphere, PJs Pizza provides a great space for customers to sit down and enjoy their meal. The friendly staff and great hospitality make for a pleasant on-site dining experience.
Takeout: For those on the go, the restaurant offers efficient takeout service. Customers can call ahead using the provided phone numbers, (614) 497-2727 or +1 614-497-2727, to place their order and have it ready for pickup, ensuring a quick and seamless transaction.
Catering and Party Ideas: The restaurant offers options for larger gatherings, with menu items suitable for feeding a crowd. This makes them a great choice for parties, office lunches, or family get-togethers, providing a convenient and delicious solution for any event.
Sub and Calzone Customization: As noted in a customer review, the staff is willing to go "the extra mile" to customize orders, such as subs, to a customer's liking. This personal touch and flexibility in service are highly valued by patrons.
These services collectively demonstrate a strong commitment to customer satisfaction and convenience, making PJs Pizza a versatile and reliable dining option for the community.
PJs Pizza is defined by several key features and highlights that set it apart from other pizzerias, making it a beloved institution in Columbus.
Affordable Pricing: A major highlight for customers is the restaurant's pricing. One review pointed out that their "prices aren't expensive at all," which is a significant factor in a local community where value is highly appreciated. This makes PJs Pizza a great option for families and individuals on a budget.
High-Quality, Fresh Ingredients: According to the business's own public statements, they never use frozen ingredients and every pizza is individually made with fresh toppings. This commitment to freshness and quality is a core part of their identity and contributes to the superior taste of their food.
Diverse Menu: While pizza is their specialty, PJs Pizza offers a much wider menu, including delicious subs, pasta, wings, and appetizers. They also offer options like garlic bread, cheesy breadsticks, and a variety of appetizers, providing a comprehensive menu for all tastes and preferences.
Exceptional Customer Service: The friendly and accommodating nature of the staff is a recurring theme in customer reviews. The "great hospitality" and willingness to customize orders are key features that create a positive and memorable experience for every patron.
Clean and Quiet Atmosphere: The environment of the restaurant is a notable highlight. As mentioned by a customer, the place is "very clean" with a "quiet" and "respectful" atmosphere, making it a comfortable place to enjoy a meal, which is not always the case with every fast-casual dining option.
These highlights are the reasons why PJs Pizza has a loyal following and is a favorite among those who value quality, service, and community.
For those ready to experience the delicious food and friendly service, here is the essential contact information for PJs Pizza. The restaurant is located at 3266 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA. You can easily reach them by phone to place an order or ask a question using the provided phone numbers: (614) 497-2727 and the mobile number +1 614-497-2727. It's always a good idea to call ahead during peak hours to ensure your order is ready when you arrive.
PJs Pizza is an excellent choice for locals in Columbus, Ohio, because it truly embodies the spirit of a community-focused business. Its convenient location on S High Street makes it a practical option for anyone in the area. What truly sets it apart, however, is the combination of its delicious food, commitment to fresh ingredients, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. It offers great food at an affordable price, making it a go-to for families and individuals alike. The dedication to customer satisfaction, as evidenced by their willingness to go "the extra mile," creates a sense of trust and loyalty that larger chains often cannot replicate. For those who value quality food, great service, and supporting a local establishment, PJs Pizza is the perfect destination for your next pizza night or casual meal. It's more than just a pizza place; it's a cherished part of the Columbus community.
PJs Pizza Services
Appetizers
- French Fries US$2.95
- Cheese Sticks US$4.95
comes with pizza sauce
- Loaded Fries US$4.95
smothered in cheddar cheese and bacon, served with sour cream
- Garlic Pie With Cheese US$4.95
comes with pizza sauce
- Potato Skins US$4.95
- Poppers US$4.95
Salads
- Side Salad US$1.25
1/2 pint of salad with pepperoni, hot peppers and tomato
- Italian Salad US$1.95
one pint of salad topped with cheese, pepperoni, hot peppers, and tomato slices
- Antipasto Salad US$4.25
crisp lettuce, cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, ham, tangy hot peppers, onions and tomato slices
Sub Sandwiches
All Subs Served Hot, Extra Toppings Available At Additional Cost, Including Dressing
- Pj's Italian Sub US$4.55
layers of spicy hot ham and aged salami, with two layers of pure 100% mozzarella cheese, tangy hot peppers rings, topped with lettuce and tomatoes, served on our delicious italian bun
- Sausage Sub US$4.55
spicy italian sausage served with green peppers, onions, rich spaghetti sauce, and a layer of 100% pure mozzarella cheese, topped with lettuce and tomatoes, served on our delicious italian bun
- Steak Sub US$4.55
al beef steak sausage served with green peppers, onions, rich spaghetti sauce, and a layer of 100% mozzarella cheese, topped with lettuce and tomatoes, on our delicious italian bun - bbq sauce optional
- Meatball Sub US$4.55
three juicy meatballs topped with rich spaghetti sauce and a layer of 100% pure mozzarella cheese, served on our delicious italian bun
- Ham And Cheese US$4.55
layers of premium ham and 100% pure mozzarella cheese piled on our delicious italian bun topped with lettuce and tomatoes
- Pizza Sub US$4.55
our delicious italian bun open face, covered with our original pizza sauce, piled with pepperoni, and 100% pure mozzarella cheese
- Veggie Sub US$4.55
a venety of garden vegetables, mushrooms, green peppers, hot peppers, and onions, with 100% pure mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomatoes, served on our delicious italian bun
- Spicy Chicken Bbq Sub US$4.55
a zesty blend of chicken and cajun bbq sauce, and 100% pure mozzarella cheese, toppped with lettuce and tomatoes, served on our delicious italian bun
Sides
- Garlic Bread US$2.00
- Garlic Bread With Cheese US$2.50
- Bread Sticks With Cheese US$3.50
comes with a choice of garlic butter or pizza sauce for dipping
- Pepperoni Sticks With Cheese US$4.00
comes with pizza sauce for dipping
Wings
- Hot-n-spicy US$5.95
- Bar-b-q US$5.95
sweet and tangy
Specialty Pizzas
- Pj's Supreme
italian pizza sauce, loads of mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tangy hot peppers, and fresh italian sausage
- Veggie
italian pizza sauce, loaded with mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, tangy hot peppers, green peppers, onions, and fresh sliced tomatoes
- Taco
spicy ground beef, loaded with mozzarella cheese, jalapeno peppers, cheddar cheese, and dont forget the fresh sliced tomatoes - sour cream available upon request
- Blt
mounds and mounds fo mozzarella cheese, 100% real bacon, fresh crisp lettuce, and sliced tomatoes
- Hawaiian
italian pizza sauce, sweet pineapple, ham, loads of mozzarella cheese and 100% real bacon
- Bacon Double Cheese Burger
italian pizza sauce, loaded with mozzarella cheese, 100% real bacon, mild cheddar cheese, and ground beef
- Spicy Cajun Bbq Chicken
a zesty blend of chicken, in a spicy cajun bbq sauce, topped with loads of mozzarella cheese
Pizza
All Pizzas Include Cheese And Sauce
- 1-item
- Additional
- Items
pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, ground beef, ham, black olives, green olives, hot peppers, anchovies, onions, pineapple, sliced tomatoes, salami, extra cheese, bacon, jalapenos, and green peppers
Dinners
- Spaghetti Dinner US$6.25
served with italian spaghetti sauce, 2 juicy meatballs, salad, grated romano cheese, and garlic bread
- Lasagna Dinner US$6.75
delicious lasagna, rich in cheese, choice ground meat and covered with italian spaghetti sauce, served with salad, grated romano cheese, and garlic
Party Ideas
- 2-foot Party Pizza US$24.95
extra item $4.50, serves 5-8 adults
- 3-foot Party Sub US$26.95
served cold, 5-8 adults
PJs Pizza Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Seating
Amenities
- Toilet
Atmosphere
- Casual
Crowd
- Locals
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- Parking
PJs Pizza Photos










PJs Pizza Location
PJs Pizza
3266 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA
PJs Pizza Reviews
subspricepizza subperiodcrustoven
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Very kind employees, very clean place to sit and eat and their prices aren't expensive at all! I'd have to say other than Donatos Pizza, Pj's Pizza would be my second favorite pizza place. The atmosphere is quiet, respectful, great paced and great hospitality!
April 18 · Amy RaybernI would like to express my gratitude for making our subs the way I ask.Will continue to be a customer for you going the extra mile to please.THANK YOU PJ's PIZZA
April 17 · John GillilanExcellent small town pizza shop here. Medium crust that is delicious. I don’t normally eat my crust but I did this time.
March 14 · Jeff HollabaughPlaced an order and was told I could pick it up in 25 minutes. I show up in 30 minutes try to walk in and the door is locked so I rang a button I assume was a bell to get their attention but nobody was in the store so I sit in my car for 5 minutes, walk back up and push the button again and even knocked on the glass, it’s 8pm and 25 degrees outside so of course I’m not sticking around, to be expecting someone at a certain time and be completely oblivious that the person has showed up in that expected time period is crazy how do places ran like this stay in buisness not only wasting my time but their own! Make it make sense
January 03 · William SuharMs Jennifer Bassett took my order and was AWESOME, because my order was PERFECT ❣️ SIMPLY DELICIOUS 🤤😋 THANKS PJ'S
January 03 · Dora Imes
More Best Restaurants Near Me

3250 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3386 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3402 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3444 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3475 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3545 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3605 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3554 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3503 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3503 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3566 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA

3615 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Bites & Banter Posts





