Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North

- 608 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215

For residents of Ohio with a serious craving for authentic, New York-style pizza, Goodfellas Pizzeria in the Short North neighborhood of Columbus is a name that needs to be on your radar. This establishment has quickly become a local favorite, known not just for its delicious food, but for the overall experience it provides. From the moment you step through the doors, you're greeted with a "very cool atmosphere" that sets the stage for a memorable meal. This article is your comprehensive guide to everything that makes Goodfellas Pizzeria a standout in the Columbus dining scene. We’ll cover its prime location, the array of services it offers, and the specific highlights that have diners giving it a ten-star rating.

The reputation of Goodfellas Pizzeria is built on a foundation of quality ingredients, great service, and a distinctively cool vibe. Our overview will delve into the details that matter most to local diners, from the menu options that go beyond just pizza to the welcoming staff that makes every visit a pleasant one. Whether you're planning a quick bite with friends, a casual date night, or a family dinner, Goodfellas Pizzeria offers an environment that is both comfortable and lively. We'll provide an in-depth look at what to expect, drawing from the positive feedback of real customers who have experienced the magic of this Short North gem firsthand. This is a place that promises more than just a meal; it offers a slice of genuine hospitality and fantastic flavor.

The commitment to creating a great atmosphere and serving excellent food is what truly sets Goodfellas Pizzeria apart. The cool decor, combined with the energetic buzz of the Short North district, makes it a destination in itself. As we move forward, we will explore the various aspects of the restaurant that contribute to its growing popularity, giving you all the information you need to plan your perfect pizza outing.

Goodfellas Pizzeria is conveniently located at 608 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA. This places it directly in the heart of the Short North Arts District, one of the most vibrant and walkable neighborhoods in Columbus. The location on North High Street makes it easily accessible for anyone in the Ohio region, whether you're coming from the suburbs or already in the downtown area. Being situated in this bustling area means it's surrounded by a variety of shops, galleries, and entertainment venues, making it a perfect stop before or after other activities.

For locals, accessibility is a major benefit. The Short North is a well-trafficked area with multiple transportation options. For those driving, there are numerous street parking spots and several parking garages within a short walking distance. Public transit is also a viable option, as the area is well-served by bus routes. The central and lively nature of the neighborhood contributes to the overall appeal of dining at Goodfellas. It’s a place that feels like it’s at the center of all the action, making it a natural choice for a fun night out. The restaurant’s strategic location allows it to serve a wide range of customers, from those who live nearby to those visiting for a concert or other event.

The restaurant’s prominent spot on North High Street ensures that it is easy to find and a regular part of the local community's flow. This excellent accessibility is a key reason why it is such a suitable and popular choice for residents across the Columbus metro area.

Goodfellas Pizzeria offers a variety of services designed to make dining convenient and enjoyable for its customers. While the delicious pizza is the main attraction, the establishment also provides a full-service experience.

Here is a list of services offered:

• Dine-in service with a welcoming and cool atmosphere.
• A full bar area with comfortable booths and attentive bartenders, perfect for enjoying drinks.
• Takeout orders for those who prefer to enjoy their pizza at home. The restaurant is noted for its quick turnaround time, with one customer stating their order was ready in just 20 minutes.
• A diverse menu that includes not only whole pizzas but also slices, breadsticks, and other delicious food items.
• A friendly staff that is quick to welcome and serve customers, making for a positive and welcoming experience.

The combination of a great dining environment and efficient takeout service caters to a variety of needs, whether you're looking for a night out or a quick and easy meal at home.

Goodfellas Pizzeria stands out for several key features and highlights that have earned it glowing reviews from customers.

Here are the standout features of the restaurant:

• Exceptional Food Quality: The pizza is described as "DELICIOUS" and customers have praised various menu items, including the breadsticks and cheesy bread, as "all very good." The "Vinny" pizza and a "slice of 3 topping" were specifically mentioned as being excellent choices.
• Cool Atmosphere and Decor: The restaurant has a "very cool atmosphere" with a distinctively styled bar area featuring "comfortable booths." This vibe contributes significantly to the overall enjoyment of the dining experience.
• Attentive Staff: The service is consistently praised as being "attentive" and "friendly." Customers have noted that the staff is "quick to welcome" them and makes them feel at home, which is a major factor in their desire to return.
• Delicious Drinks: The bar is a highlight, with customers enjoying unique and well-made cocktails like the "sunkissed sweetheart" and a "lemon drop," both described as "amazing." This makes Goodfellas a great spot for a drink as well as a meal.
• Efficiency: The speed of service for takeout orders is a significant highlight, with one review mentioning their delicious pizza was ready in just 20 minutes. This efficiency is a big plus for busy locals.

These features combined make Goodfellas Pizzeria a multifaceted establishment that excels in both its food and its hospitality, earning it high praise from those who visit.

To visit or contact Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North, here is the essential information:

Address: 608 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA

Phone: (614) 484-0277

This information is crucial for placing an order, making inquiries, or simply finding the restaurant with ease.

Goodfellas Pizzeria is an ideal spot for locals in Ohio for a number of compelling reasons. Its prime location in the Short North makes it a convenient and lively destination for any occasion, from a casual weeknight dinner to a fun weekend outing. The cool and welcoming atmosphere is a huge draw, offering a comfortable place to relax and enjoy a meal with friends or family. Most importantly, the quality of the food and drinks is consistently excellent, as evidenced by glowing customer reviews. The pizza is delicious, the breadsticks are a hit, and the cocktails are described as amazing, ensuring that there's something for everyone to love. The efficient and friendly service also sets this place apart, making customers feel valued and well taken care of. For an Ohio resident looking for a taste of authentic New York-style pizza and a fantastic overall dining experience, Goodfellas Pizzeria is an absolute must-visit. Its combination of great food, an appealing atmosphere, and outstanding hospitality makes it a true gem in the Columbus food scene.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North

608 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA