Sexton's Pizza

- 360 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201

Welcome to our detailed guide on Sexton's Pizza, a popular carry-out establishment located at 360 W 3rd Ave in Columbus, Ohio. In a city with a rich and varied pizza scene, Sexton's has quickly carved out a niche for itself, winning over locals with its dedication to high-quality, delicious pizzas. This article is written for the Ohio community, offering an in-depth and factual overview of this business. We will explore the different styles of pizza they offer, their commitment to fresh ingredients, and the top-notch service that makes this a must-try spot for any pizza lover in the area.

Sexton's Pizza is known for its two distinct styles of pizza: a classic New York (NY) style and a Detroit style, which they affectionately call the "Mo Town." This variety is a major draw for customers, allowing them to choose between a thin-crust, foldable slice and a thick, pan-style pie. Customers consistently praise the quality of the food, with one reviewer stating that the pizza is "hands down the best I've had in a long time." The thin crust is noted for its perfect crispiness, and the dough itself is celebrated for having a great flavor that truly stands out. This balance between a satisfying crunch and a tender interior is what makes every bite a "delightful experience."

While the pizza quality is generally excellent, a nuanced review highlights some of the finer details that pizza connoisseurs will appreciate. The reviewer, focusing on the NY style, praised the "excellent chew" of the crust, a signature feature of a good NY slice. They also noted the "good quality cheese" and a well-balanced sauce that, while slightly acidic, was overall decent. The fermentation and flavor of the crust were also given high marks. This level of detailed feedback indicates that Sexton's is serious about its craft and has a keen understanding of what makes great pizza. It also suggests that the experience can vary slightly depending on factors like where the pizza sits in the conveyor oven, which is a testament to the fact that their pizzas are baked with care and not just mass-produced.

The Detroit-style "Mo Town" pizza is another key feature of the menu. This style is known for its thick, rectangular crust, crispy edges, and generous toppings. The ability to get both a classic thin-crust and a hearty deep-dish style from the same place makes Sexton's a versatile choice for any pizza craving. The aesthetic of the restaurant is also a notable feature. While it is a carry-out-only establishment, the space itself is described as having a "really nice aesthetic," which adds to the overall positive brand image.

Service is a major highlight at Sexton's Pizza. Despite being a carry-out-only business, the staff is described as "top-notch" and "incredibly friendly." The efficiency of their service is also a point of praise, with one customer mentioning that their pizza was pulled "out of the oven fresh and hot" right when they arrived for their online order. This attention to customer experience, from the moment of ordering to the pickup, makes the process seamless and pleasant.

For those who are particular about their pizza, Sexton's offers a truly worthy experience. The commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients, from the cheese to the sauce, is a recurring theme in customer feedback. The dedication to getting the core components of a great pizza right—the crust, the sauce, and the cheese—is what elevates this place above a typical takeaway joint. The availability of two distinct styles, NY and Detroit, also means that it caters to a broader range of tastes within the pizza-loving community.

Sexton's Pizza’s focus on carry-out only is a key part of its business model. This specialization allows them to focus entirely on producing high-quality food for customers to enjoy at home, a perfect fit for a busy, on-the-go lifestyle. This model also allows them to maintain quick and efficient service, ensuring that your pizza is hot and ready when you arrive.

The restaurant’s reputation as a "must-try" place is well-earned. The consistently positive reviews from both casual diners and pizza aficionados alike highlight its place as a valued member of the local food scene. Its presence provides a reliable, high-quality option for a meal that is both satisfying and convenient.

In conclusion, Sexton's Pizza is an excellent choice for anyone in the Columbus area seeking a delicious pizza experience. The menu's dual focus on authentic NY and Detroit styles, combined with a commitment to fresh ingredients and top-notch, friendly service, makes it a local favorite. Whether you're in the mood for a classic thin-crust slice or a hearty deep-dish pie, Sexton's delivers a high-quality product that is "absolutely incredible" and well worth the visit.

Location and Accessibility

Sexton's Pizza is conveniently situated in a central Columbus neighborhood.

Address: 360 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

This location is easily accessible for residents of the Harrison West and Victorian Village areas. While it is a carry-out establishment, its placement on W 3rd Avenue makes it a simple stop for those driving by or for people looking to pick up an order quickly. There is street parking available, though it can be competitive during peak hours. The area is also well-connected to public transportation, making it a convenient option for many throughout Columbus.

Services Offered

• Carry-out and pickup service only
• Online ordering for a quick and seamless experience
• Two distinct pizza styles: New York (NY) and Detroit (Mo Town)
• A variety of specialty pizzas and build-your-own options
• Top-notch, friendly customer service

Features / Highlights

• "Absolutely incredible" pizza with a perfectly crispy and flavorful crust.
• The "Mo Town" Detroit-style pizza is a unique offering.
• Commitment to high-quality ingredients, praised for fresh cheese and a good sauce.
• Efficient and friendly service, ensuring fresh and hot pizza upon pickup.
• The overall aesthetic and branding of the restaurant are well-regarded.

Contact Information

Address: 360 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

Phone: N/A

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For residents of Columbus and the wider Ohio region, Sexton's Pizza is a fantastic option for a high-quality, carry-out meal. Its unique offering of both New York and Detroit-style pizzas, combined with a dedication to fresh ingredients and friendly service, makes it a standout in the local pizza scene. The convenience of its location and the efficiency of its online ordering and pickup process are perfect for busy locals. Whether you're a long-time resident or a newcomer, Sexton's Pizza provides an exceptional pizza experience that is well worth a visit and a perfect choice for a delicious and satisfying takeaway meal.

Sexton's Pizza

360 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, USA